Description
Rural consumers in South and South-East Asia have tremendous potential for telecom adoption but very few know how to either identify these consumers or reach out to them. Remoteness and low spending capacities are cited by prominent organizations as reasons for not conceptualizing dedicated rural marketing strategies. The situation is changing with growing rural prosperity and the need for technology to resolve challenges of remoteness through information access.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 1
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 2
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 3
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Summary Report
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 4
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services Report is the outcome of a research program funded
and supported by the Nokia Siemens Networks.
Research Director Dr. Aditya Dev Sood
Project Manager Dhruv Sharma
Report Author Saswati Saha-Mitra
Graphics Aarti Vashisht
Anurag Dommeti
Shwetha Kikla
Researchers Meera Mary Sunny
Veena Rajagopal
www.cks.in
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Copyright © 2008 Nokia Siemens Networks
All rights reserved. A license is hereby granted to download and print a copy of this document for personal
use only. No other license to any other intellectual property rights is hereby granted. Unless expressly
permitted herein or by law, reproduction, adaptation, transfer, distribution or storage of part or all of the
contents of this document in any form without the prior written permission of Nokia Siemens Networks is
prohibited. The content of this document is provided “as is”, without warranties of any kind with regards
its accuracy or reliability, and specifcally excluding all implied warranties, for example of merchantability,
ftness for purpose, title and non-infringement. In no event shall Nokia Siemens Networks be liable for any
special, indirect or consequential damages, or any damages whatsoever resulting from loss of use, data
or profts, arising out of or in connection with the use of the document. Nokia Siemens Networks reserve
the right to revise the document or withdraw it at any time without prior notice.
Nokia Siemens Networks and the wave logo are registered trademarks of Nokia Siemens Networks.
Other company and product names mentioned herein may be trademarks or trade names of their
respective owners.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 5
Preface 1
Executive Summary 2
Research Objectives and Methodology 3
Understanding South and South- East Asia 4
Defning Rural and Urban Asia 6
Understanding Rural Consumers 7
Assessment of the Asian Rural Telecom Scenario 8
Rural Marketing Best Practices 9
Strategies for Success 13
Appendix 15
About Nokia Siemens Networks 15
About CKS 15
Commissioned By:
Nokia Siemens Networks
Authored By:
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Further Information:
www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com
www.cks.in
Content
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 6
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 1
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services report created by CKS
Consulting Pvt. Ltd. (hereafter ‘CKS’) reviews key learnings from the research
conducted by CKS on behalf of Nokia Siemens Networks during May- June, 2008
in Vietnam, Philippines, Indonesia, Bangladesh and India.
The Rural Marketing Practices research for South and South- East Asia was
designed with the aim of gaining key marketing insights from the middle
management of companies successfully involved in rural markets in these
world regions. Initial secondary research revealed that the most successful
rural marketing organizations came not only from the Telecom sector but also
very substantially from other service sectors like FMCG, Banking, Insurance,
Pharmaceuticals, Fertilizers and Pesticides and Retail. These sectors were
perceived to have entered the rural ecology in ways more fundamental than
targeting these locales as mere markets. Consequently, they have reaped the
benefts of being the market leaders when it came to catering to the substantial
rural population.
The fndings of this research are divided into three main axis of analysis. First,
building a comprehensive understanding of South and South- East Asia as
a region for tremendous telecom growth. Secondly, identifying current rural
marketing best practices that are being successfully implemented in emerging
economies. Finally, recommending key strategies for adoption and new research
areas which, if initiated, can successfully strengthen rural marketing strategies in
a bid to reach out to the next 100 million users who are expected to come from
rural centers.
Preface
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 2
Executive Summary
Rural consumers in South and South- East Asia have tremendous potential for telecom adoption but very few
know how to either identify these consumers or reach out to them. Remoteness and low spending capacities
are cited by prominent organizations as reasons for not conceptualizing dedicated rural marketing strategies.
The situation is changing with growing rural prosperity and the need for technology to resolve challenges of
remoteness through information access.
In order to cater to rural consumers, it is important to understand and respect their livelihood. Companies
which are considered to be rural marketing leaders have an average rural presence of more than two
decades. Through consistent presence and support for the rural ecology, such organizations have
strengthened their hold over these markets. New companies trying to rapidly reach such levels of rural
presence will need to convey that they take their responsibility- offering a service- seriously and that they
will be constant partners in rural living. The frst mover in such markets has the potential of becoming
synonymous with the product category itself. In terms of successful promoting efforts, mass media campaigns
will continue but various last mile strategies like ‘dangdut’ (musical soiree in Indonesia) or participating
in local fairs also need to be evolved to reach out to the largest sections of the sparsely distributed rural
population. Price reductions based on innovative service bundling across urban and rural locations stand to
beneft rural consumers. Lowering the initial costs of entry is expected to keep organizations in proft since
reduced proft margins stand to be compensated by a larger consumer base.
CKS further recommends the need for service segmentation and innovative bundling for proftability,
integration of various rural organizations into exclusive marketing networks, adoption of a rural
enablement policy, implementation of hyper local strategies and most importantly, initiation of detailed rural
segmentations, as key ways in which telecom players stands to strengthen their positions and lead global
rural marketing efforts.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 3
The rural marketing practices research was conducted with the objective of:
• Identifying key operators and service providers who have been reaching out to rural consumers in
innovative ways
• Understanding diverse market segmentation models for rural consumers which are currently being used by
market experts
• Understanding communication strategies adopted by service sector companies in reaching out to the rural
consumers
• Explaining how key elements of the marketing process are actioned by marketing teams
In order to meet these objectives, the research process was initiated with in- depth secondary research.
This enabled a better understanding of the service market in terms of rural and low income consumers in
these designated economies. Based on these fndings, 20 in- depth expert interviews were conducted in
the 5 countries identifed for this research. Out of 4 experts interviews conducted per country, 2 were taken
from the telecom sector and the other 2 from a combination of the previously- mentioned service sectors. 20
middle managers were interviewed and their thoughts were analyzed in internal review sessions. A workshop
was also conducted by CKS during which all expert comments were reviewed collectively, analyzed and
tagged under the following heads:
• Characteristics low income and rural consumers
• Position, promotion, price and placement of service product
• Marketing best practices in the service industry for low income and rural consumers
The outcomes from the workshop were then synthesized and mapped to further secondary research fndings
in order to project for telecom stakeholders the most effective rural marketing strategies.
Research Objectives and Methodology
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 4
Understanding South and South-East Asia
South and South- East Asia is the current global favor for foreign direct investments. This region is the
primary recipient of private equity investment, attracting more than 60% of net portfolio equity investment
fows to emerging market economies in 2006. Such investments are well warranted since Asia has three of
the fastest growing economies in the world, namely, China, Vietnam and India. However, the region also has
ample diversity in terms of demographics, infrastructure growth potentials, income parameters, technology
penetration levels, local markets and potential adapters, for there to be a need to understand these countries
more specifcally and more strategically.
In spite of differences, rural Asia faces similar challenges of hard infrastructure. Hard Infrastructure like
paved roads, basic electricity, healthcare, transport and educational institutions are extremely sparse. Ta Van
in Vietnam received its frst fxed phone as late as 2004. Less than 60% of India’s villages have metal roads
or electrical connection. Vietnam is the only country in this study which is currently investing 7% of its annual
GDP to upgrade its infrastructure and in this it is only second to China in Asia.
The absence of hard infrastructure in these regions is partially compensated by their rapid soft infrastructure
growth. Soft infrastructure includes terrestrial cable, satellite television, mobile coverage and broadband
cable. Soft infrastructure growth compensates to some degree for the problem of remoteness by enabling
easier information availability. Soft infrastructure roll out, however, is being perceived as the prerogative of
private organizations involved in these sectors. Private players, especially the frst movers, stand to beneft
from continued soft infrastructure roll - out as a wholly untapped 50% of their subscriber base in these
economies are located in rural areas.
The size of the rural telecom market in most of South and South- East Asia is between 50 and 70% of
their populations, except Philippines which is more than 60% urbanized. Characteristically, in most Asian
countries, although more than 50% of the population is engaged in agri - related services, progressively lesser
and lesser percentage of the national GDP is coming from this sector. In India, the rural sector’s contribution
decreased from 48% in 1950 to around 27% of the GDP in 2000. Rural consumption, however, is on the rise
due to increasing agricultural pricing, strong growth in employment in manufacturing and service sectors,
steady remittances fow from international labor migration and the overall rural development agenda of these
economies. The profle of the fastest rural technology adopter is male, aged between 30 to 35, possessing
adequate literacy and having growing employment needs or alternative earning needs. Bangladesh is the
only perceivable exception to such a profling since its rural women already enjoy substantial benefts due to
Grameen’s women empowerment policy.
Fig 1: Socio-technological profle of South and South-East Asia
(Source: CKS-EER Team based on Encylopedia Britannica, United
Nations Development Programe, ITU World Telecommunication and
ICT Indicators Database)
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 5
In gearing up for this market, some key factors need to be kept in mind. First, rural income levels being lower
than the urban population’s, in turn, affect their capacity for telecom adoption. Secondly, rural employment
is gradually moving away from traditional agriculture to explore new opportunities in the service industry.
Thirdly, the gaps between urban and rural markets in Asia are on the decline. Per household consumption
in rural India will reach today’s urban levels by 2017. Fourthly, the youth sector plays a key role in Asian
telecom market. They are rapidly beginning to rely more on online and wireless media. The South- East Asian
wireless telecom industry is projected to grow by more than 50% in the next fve years. Young people are at
the forefront of the evolution of this medium and their usage habits will dictate the types of media, products,
entertainment options and platforms that will be available. Fifthly, women are emerging as interesting partners
in Asia’s rural telecom growth since they are less of a credit risk than men and using them as telecom service
providers also improves telecom penetration among the rural female consumer base. Sixthly, given the lower
income in rural households, rural telecom users prefer a service- based model than a purchase- based one
since the purchase cost is itself a substantial frst hurdle for rural consumers to cross. Lastly, in order to meet
rural Asia’s telecom needs, the mobile phone is perceived to be the current favorite amongst platforms. Fig 2: Bangladesh’s Household Expenditure by Sector
(Source: World Resources Institute)
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 6
Understanding telecom needs and growth potentials of rural Asia, however, remain incomplete without an
understanding of what is rural in these economies. Defnitions vary from country to country. Most countries
defne urban. Areas beyond that are understood as rural.
In Vietnam all places with 4,000 inhabitants or more are considered to be urban. Areas beyond this criterion
are rural.
Bangladesh defnes its urban area as concentrations of at least 5,000 persons in a continuous collection of
houses where the community sense is well developed and the community maintains public utilities, such as
roads, street lighting, water supply and sanitary arrangements. These places are also centers of trade and
commerce where the labor force is mostly non- agricultural and literacy levels are high. Areas that fall beyond
such parameters are understood to be rural.
In Indonesia the defnition of urban includes Municipalities (‘kotamadya’), regency capitals (‘kabupaten’) and
other places with urban characteristics. All others are rural.
In Philippines an area is urban if a ‘barangay’ (ward) has a population size of 5,000 or more, has at least
one establishment with a minimum of 100 employees, has 5 or more establishments with a minimum of 10
employees, and 5 or more facilities within the two- kilometer radius from the barangay hall. All other remaining
areas beyond this defnition are rural in Philippines.
The Census of India, on the other hand, defnes rural explicitly. Areas with clear surveyed boundaries not
having a municipality, corporation or board, with density of population not more than 400 per km
2
and with at
least 75% of the male working population engaged in agriculture and allied activities qualify as rural.
Rurality as a concept, thus remains, complex to identify even today. Improved understanding will require
more sophisticated analysis based on factors of remoteness, income and growth potentials.
Defining Rural and Urban Asia
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 7
In trying to cater to rural markets, as important as it is to identify the market size and location, it is equally
important to understand the challenges in livelihood of this potential consumer base. Understanding the
intricacies of their lives enables successful product service creations that are resonant with their needs and
expenditure capacities.
In rural Asia, consumers face 6 key challenges which affect rural prosperity. These challenges arise out of
infrastructural and information needs which are aggravated by remoteness. Rural consumers identify lack
of transportation, diffculties in managing their commercial transactions, lack of healthcare services, being
uninformed of governance policies, lacking effective education and shortage of opportunities in infotainment as
prime deterrents to their living an improved lifestyle. (The Mobile Development Report, 2006)
In order to make rural prosperity achievable, certain key services need to emerge. First, coordinated rural
transportation based on mobile information delivery, will increase convenience and allow users to fnd
transportation ‘on- demand’ without depending on unreliable pliers, irregular timings or incurring huge
expenses. Secondly, the rural economy will be strengthened through exhaustive micro- commerce ventures
like mobile ordering, payments and delivery requests; all helping isolated small - scale entrepreneurs working in
remote locations. Thirdly, healthcare services through telecom and broadband intervention will allow doctors,
nurses and midwives to stay in closer contact with patients. Fourthly, rural governance services giving access
to citizen data will allow the rural population to be more informed of national level developments and reduce
the urban- rural divide. Fifthly, rural education needs to beneft from more sophisticated processing and
exchange of multimedia data across national regions for educational benefts. Lastly, mobile and broadband
will allow peer - to- peer distribution of infotainmnet data, opening up new streams of rural content creation and
distribution. Meeting these basic rural needs is possible for the telecom industry. Rural consumers are also
willing to invest in service offerings that can fundamentally improve these aspects of their lives.
Understanding Rural Consumers
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 8
In rural South and South- East Asia, telecom is still a novelty. It continues to be introduced even now as
penetration levels hover at just around 20% on average. The telecom sector as a whole also keeps undergoing
continuous innovation, up gradation and repositioning with new products and service offerings for different
sectors of the population. As a category, it is highly volatile to the minds of the rural consumers since they see
the same category offering so much variety. Coca Cola sells Coke but Nokia sells handsets for the rich, for the
poor and for the youth. It enters in joint ventures with Airtel or is present as event sponsors in IPL cricket. Such
multi - platform brand presence is complex to the rural mind. Educating rural consumers on how to become
telecom users and commodifying telecom to the extent of FMCG goods, will be the biggest challenge for rural
telecom marketing.
In attempting to enter the rural markets, telecom companies will also face the task of re- positioning themselves
to an almost wholly new subscriber base. There will always be a frst and a later mover when the market
expands. For various reasons different companies may chose to become either one of them. The frst mover
has the advantage of unlimited numbers. Later players will capitalize on the market that has been set up by
the frst mover. BSNL in India initiated the task of taking telecom connectivity to rural India. At the present,
however, it is faced with competitions from Bharti Airtel, Reliance and Vodafone. In order for BSNL to continue
maintaining its lead in this market, it will need to undertake serious innovations in telecom service design and
rural marketing to maintain its lead. Viettel from Vietnam, on the other hand, positions itself as a competitor
and not a cheap brand. It is of the view that pricing has a direct impact on the positioning of the product and it
has no immediate aim of reducing costs in order to consciously make stronger rural inroads. It does, however,
make special provisions like its TOMATO package, ‘a package for everybody’ or its HOMEPHONE which is a
wireless local loop (WLL), ‘Package for every home’ in its bid to capture more subscribers.
Our research also indicates that in order to cater to the rural segment, it is also advisable to avoid using
premium lifestyle images, since such a lifestyle is beyond rural income capacity. Idea Cellular uses Abhishek
Bachchan as a ‘Jat’. (‘Jat’ is an ethnic group resident mainly in Punjab, India and traditionally involved in
agriculture). In spite of belonging to a higher class, he tries to resolve community class and caste differences
by identifying all through their mobile numbers than through their names, race or religion. This is topical, and
thus, highly appreciated. On the other hand, Idea’s My Gang ads focusing on the urban youth’s cool, energetic
appeal, would loose some resonance for this segment. Rural operator positioning thus needs to appeal to the
actualities of rural lifestyle. Service providers, however, are simultaneously cautioned about not losing their
existing urban clientele due to an exaggerated rural focus.
Assessment of the Asian Rural Telecom Scenario
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 9
Promotion
Rural product marketing is emerging as an interesting challenge both for the advertisement fraternity as well
as for global organizations commissioning such campaigns. Current promotions of rural products continue
to fall back on traditional mass media practices of making use of the broadcast media and using celebrity
endorsements. These methods enjoy intermediate success.
Mass media campaigns though commonly used, often remain untargeted and do not reach the widest segment
of the rural population due to challenges of low literacy, remoteness and low population density across the rural
landscape. In a country like India, there are roughly 105 million homes with televisions which is about the same
as in the United States, but for India, it amounts to only about 50% penetration in the country’s households
through shared access, compared to 98% penetration for the U. S. A. Mass media also represents a primarily
urban and an overarching national sensibility since the national entertainment industry fails to echo local
dialectical and cultural variations. In terms of a mass media strategy, the recommendations of this research
is that companies will need to continue using this media but there needs to be an awareness that some
percentage of the population will always remain left out of this media reach.
Celebrity endorsements are an equally prominent marketing strategy for telecom products and services.
Indosat in Indonesia makes use of the musical band Radja which is a favorite of the youth. Globe Telecom in
Philippines uses the singer Sharon Cuneta. These endorsements are most effective with the youth segment
but for rural marketing purposes, such endorsements will need to be done more succinctly than just tapping in
a celebrity’s star status. An informational approach is more resonant with rural and low income consumers as
they need product information to make the right decision. Regionalization and localization of campaigns also
help target consumers associate with the product.
In order to truly cater to the remotest of consumers, we also observe the emergence of various innovative last
mile marketing strategies. Organizing ‘Dangdut’ in Indonesia and ‘Jatras’ (dramas) in India and Bangladesh,
sending trained personnel to the felds directly to interact with the rural consumers, involving Islamic leaders
or village heads in utilizing a certain product or service and then using them as spokespersons to make others
aware of the benefts of the schemes, arranging monthly lucky draws in village markets or before local banks
and taking the help of local self help groups, are all yielding crucial rural marketing success.
Rural Marketing Best Practices
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 10
Placement
Product placement in rural Asia emerges as a substantial diffculty due to the widely disseminated nature
of rural living. Lack of basic infrastructure like transport, electricity and roads further heighten such diffculty
levels. Most rural marketing enterprises fnd it diffcult to fnd their target consumers, market to them or even
place their products due to diffculties in setting up a distribution channel. Setting up retail points in rural areas
amount to heavy investments and private companies often refrain from making such investments due to low
returns from these areas. In such situations, FMCG retail agencies are found to have the highest success
rate in rural penetration. With greater remoteness, retail points become smaller in size and limited in product
options but they manage to distribute the basic service even to the remotest of locations. Latching on to an
existing successful retail distribution network like the ‘Sari Sari’ shops in Philippines increases the reach of
the telecom product and helps telecom penetrate the rural remote markets. Once the market matures and
becomes cost effective to the company, the telecom company can opt to have its own network. In areas where
there are not enough such retail chains, the product has to be placed using innovative retail points which can
be small portable kiosks or booths.
The sales networks of service providers like banking and insurance are also effective placement points.
Financial sales networks operate through trained personnel who educate and inform the rural consumers
about their service offerings. Since telecom companies may not want to invest from the beginning in trained
personnel who can go and sell the products door to door, they can tie up with these agencies, leverage the
knowledge of their personnel and beneft from the overall sales networks. Using the ‘human touch’ to expand
one’s sales networks in rural areas is a crucial strategy.
Rural agencies like post offces, electricity supply divisions and educational institutions all have existing
infrastructure in rural areas. Electricity of Vietnam Telecom (EVN) and Vietnam Posts and Telecommunications
Group (VNPT) use the distribution outlets of their parent companies as sales channels for their telecom
products. Partnering with schools and colleges will also help telecom companies reach the lower income
consumer segment and possible future adopters, i.e. parents and students. Tying up with public agencies can
help telecom operators use existing infrastructure as their distribution and sales base without having to invest
in creating this infrastructure while tapping into possible consumers who come to such institutions.
Position
In rural markets in South and South- East Asia, consumers have diffculty in understanding multifaceted brand
positioning. Coca Cola sells Coke but Nokia sells handsets for the rich, for the poor and for the youth. It
enters in joint ventures with Airtel. It also has a PC- mobile platform through Ovi. Such multi -platform or multi
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 11
modal brand positioning is complex to the rural mind and consequently should not be a priority at the initial
stages of entry into the rural market. Secondly, to off - set consumer demands for cheaper offerings, telecom
marketing has to undertake consumer education frst. At an early stage of introduction of a product or service,
a brand has an opportunity to become the category. In Indonesia, auto rickshaws ‘ojeks’ are called ‘Bajaj,’
(an eminent Indian auto maker exporting these vehicles). In some parts of Africa trucks are called ‘Tatas’
(globally renowned Indian automotive company). Such identifcation of a brand with the category is extremely
desirable. It indicates an ownership of the product or service category itself. Thirdly, rural and low income
consumers want to know the benefts of the product in the light of the category. Hutch and Nokia’s brand
message of ‘Connecting People’ is no different than what is valued in the category of telecom- connectivity. In
rural marketing, the message that counts and needs to be pushed consistently is ‘Use the service’.
Rural consumers once they start using a particular product or service which wins their liking, become
extremely brand loyal. Companies with substantial rural footprint have almost 20 plus years of strong rural
presence. In order for new companies to rapidly reach such levels of rural presence, they will need to convey
that they take their responsibility- offering a service- very seriously and that they will be constant partners
in rural living. Grameen Bank in Bangladesh provides every member’s family with an insurance amount on
the member’s death. Telecom companies need not provide insurance but in rural Asia, they have to initially
focus on constant presence rather than on service diversity and quality improvement. A telecom brand that
becomes a trusted rural resource and maintains consistent service will retain its consumers for a very long
time due to the slow rate of rural roll - out. ‘We are there’- is the message to be spread across. It is straight -
forward and it needs to be projected straight up.
A successful rural marketing strategy would also involve widespread and well timed presence in rural lifecycle
events and occasions. Presence in large village congregations like fairs and weddings help a brand gain
visibility amongst a large segment of the rural population in a single place. Involvement in village ‘panchayat’
(governance) and counseling services is an important indicator of the company’s intention to make its rural
presence a continuous and long term relationship. Sponsoring and / or organizing sports activities and other
rural events also help in establishing the brand as integral to rural lifestyle. Thus in terms of positioning,
it is important to identify mass congregation occasions in rural areas, use rural market days as the best
opportunity for regular product marketing and participate in rural social occasions in order to show your
support for the community while benefting from mass presence.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 12
Price
In terms of pricing, there is a lot of fallacy regarding the capacities of rural consumers. Our rural marketing
experts reveal that rural consumers are ready and willing to adopt mobile technology in varying degrees and
at different price points than urban users. These varying degrees of tech adoption and price points depend
on their communication needs and levels of affordability. For rural consumers a telecom service bundle
must contain information on areas that are relevant to their livelihood like market data, fnance availability or
potential sales data. In order to understand a price point that is payable by rural consumers, the needs and
affordable price limits of rural consumers need to be mapped and matched. Any pricing for the rural market
should also refect a respect for the value of rural income.
Another fnding of this research is that telecom companies so far, have not made enough efforts to analyze
income variations in rural contexts. They have been using urban benchmarks for rural markets. Some
companies rely on retail and product sector segmentation, whereas the two are very different. The telecom
market has now reached a threshold where it can no longer afford to follow the segmentation of the FMCG
sector. They need to understand the income capacities of their rural consumers and innovate their service
offerings per segment so as to prevent them from cannibalizing on each other’s interests. Only when service
offerings for each consumer group become truly exclusive, they will justify different tariff rates and consumers
will understand and accept such price marks based on their own necessities and capacities.
Rural telecom pricing also stands to beneft from any lowering of the initial barriers to entry. Rural consumers
living on a day- to- day basis, have no disposable income to pay for the repeated costs of handsets, sim
charges and other ancillary expenses. These up- front costs are substantially high and any means that can
reduce this frst cost will beneft rural consumers. Viettel in Vietnam started the 6 seconds +1 policy where
subscribers had to pay for the frst 6 seconds as default after which they were charged on per second basis
rather than on a minute pulse. EVN telecom’s strategy of giving away sim cards with credit amount loaded is
very popular with the rural and low income consumers in Vietnam. Reducing such basic entry level costs will
not make company profts suffer since a larger consumer base will compensate for the reduced proft margins.
Having enunciated the current rural marketing best practices that can be adopted, CKS further recommends
some key long term strategies which stand to beneft long range rural marketing endeavors.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 13
Consumer Segmentation, Service Innovation, Profitability
In order to develop a sophisticated understanding of Asia’s rural markets, it needs to be understood that rural
telecom services will have to be customized based on extensive consumer segmentation. This consumer
segmentation will depend on varied parameters of occupation, literacy, income and noticeable service needs.
Detailed segmentation of this kind will allow for the preservation of proft margins in sectors which can afford
such premium costs while allowing for subsidized rates in the rural markets. Rural consumers will thus be
served strategically with a good service and at effective price points.
Integrated Rural Marketing Strategies
The telecom industry needs to identify successful partners in sectors like agriculture, health, banking and
retail. Identifying as many different partners as possible will help organizations reach out to a maximum
variety of the rural population. The purpose of such partnership will be to leverage the existent marketing
network that has already been created by these partnering companies. Both partners stand to beneft through
extended knowledge sharing as well as proft division. However, if one wants to retain one’s own stronghold
on the rural market, telecom companies will need to opt for exclusive partnerships creating a complex
network of monopolistic rural distribution chain.
Rural Enablement
Telecom companies which intend to take advantage of being the frst movers, will also have to have a rural
enablement agenda. Providing quality service that will connect remote environments is the best way in which
it can assist rural enablement. As the frst mover in rural service provision, it will also have to undertake some
basic infrastructural responsibility. Further enablement will also occur with educating rural consumers on the
benefts of telecom adoption and possible incremental income hikes. True rural enablement will occur once
organizations begin to perceive the rural community as a special customer base which is worth investing in.
Hyper Local Strategies
In order to appeal to the consumers of rural Asia, telecom marketing will need to adopt very local strategies in
its marketing and distribution schemes. Adopting local strategies will position the brand as well informed and
interested in rural conditions. Such strategies are also considerably inexpensive as opposed to nationwide
mass media campaigns which also fail to reach the whole population. In order to fully beneft from the
Strategies for Success
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 14
adoption of such hyper local strategies, telecom companies will need to undertake detailed research on socio-
cultural knowledge systems in each of these focus countries individually and assess how the same can be
converted into country- specifc marketing efforts.
Initiating a Rural Segmentation
Rural segmentation remains a challenge for all telecom companies. This segmentation will be key to
evolving successful marketing strategies. The telecom sector has the opportunity to evolve such a complex
understanding of rural consumers by undertaking further studies in possible ways of rural segmentation. The
data that will be collected about rural Asia, will then need to be further contextualized to specifc country needs,
providing telecom companies with strategic market insights that will be unparalleled in the public domain.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 15
About Nokia Siemens Networks
Nokia Siemens Networks is a leading global enabler of communications services. The company provides a
complete, well - balanced product portfolio of mobile and fxed network infrastructure solutions and addresses
the growing demand for services with 20,000 service professionals worldwide. Nokia Siemens Networks
is one of the largest telecommunications infrastructure companies with operations in 150 countries. The
company is headquartered in Espoo, Finland. For more information, please visit our website at www.
nokiasiemensnetworks.com
A world where everyone can be connected
Mobile communication technology is expanding so fast that by 2015, an estimated 5 billion people will have
access to communications and information services. In emerging markets, the affordability and convenience
of mobile devices, networks and services are playing a crucial role in bringing the internet to more and
more people- even those who live and work in the most isolated parts of the world. Affordable access to
communications technology encourages social inclusion and contributes to progress in a range of social
economic and environmental issues. We in Nokia Siemens Networks will continue to work closely with other
companies, the public sector and civil society to promote the spread of mobile technology. Together, we can
create a future of untold benefts for everyone. To fnd out more, please visit
www.unite.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/nextbillion
The Center for Knowledge Societies (CKS) is the world’s leading research, design and innovation
consulting company focusing on Emerging Economies. CKS has worked with global corporations in various
sectors from Telecommunications, Mobile Services, Aviation, Automotive, Hospitality and Financial Services
among many others. CKS has pioneered new solutions for communities and individuals, who may not enjoy
continuous access to media, communications, energy and other forms of infrastructure. For more information,
please visit our website at www.cks.in
Appendix
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 16
Authored By:
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Commissioned By:
Nokia Siemens Networks
Further Information:
www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com
www.cks.in
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 17
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 18
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services Report offers a frst of its kind in-depth understanding of rural
markets in South and South- East Asia. It provides unique insights on innovative ways in which various service
sectors are reaching out to their potential customer base. The images in the report taken in actual feld locations,
highlight interesting marketing efforts developed to overcome challenges of remoteness and infrastructure lacks.
New research directions are also proposed on the basis of feld fndings, to ensure that rural consumers beneft
from specialized efforts made to reach out to them.
doc_905598849.pdf
Rural consumers in South and South-East Asia have tremendous potential for telecom adoption but very few know how to either identify these consumers or reach out to them. Remoteness and low spending capacities are cited by prominent organizations as reasons for not conceptualizing dedicated rural marketing strategies. The situation is changing with growing rural prosperity and the need for technology to resolve challenges of remoteness through information access.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 1
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 2
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 3
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Summary Report
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 4
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services Report is the outcome of a research program funded
and supported by the Nokia Siemens Networks.
Research Director Dr. Aditya Dev Sood
Project Manager Dhruv Sharma
Report Author Saswati Saha-Mitra
Graphics Aarti Vashisht
Anurag Dommeti
Shwetha Kikla
Researchers Meera Mary Sunny
Veena Rajagopal
www.cks.in
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services
Copyright © 2008 Nokia Siemens Networks
All rights reserved. A license is hereby granted to download and print a copy of this document for personal
use only. No other license to any other intellectual property rights is hereby granted. Unless expressly
permitted herein or by law, reproduction, adaptation, transfer, distribution or storage of part or all of the
contents of this document in any form without the prior written permission of Nokia Siemens Networks is
prohibited. The content of this document is provided “as is”, without warranties of any kind with regards
its accuracy or reliability, and specifcally excluding all implied warranties, for example of merchantability,
ftness for purpose, title and non-infringement. In no event shall Nokia Siemens Networks be liable for any
special, indirect or consequential damages, or any damages whatsoever resulting from loss of use, data
or profts, arising out of or in connection with the use of the document. Nokia Siemens Networks reserve
the right to revise the document or withdraw it at any time without prior notice.
Nokia Siemens Networks and the wave logo are registered trademarks of Nokia Siemens Networks.
Other company and product names mentioned herein may be trademarks or trade names of their
respective owners.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 5
Preface 1
Executive Summary 2
Research Objectives and Methodology 3
Understanding South and South- East Asia 4
Defning Rural and Urban Asia 6
Understanding Rural Consumers 7
Assessment of the Asian Rural Telecom Scenario 8
Rural Marketing Best Practices 9
Strategies for Success 13
Appendix 15
About Nokia Siemens Networks 15
About CKS 15
Commissioned By:
Nokia Siemens Networks
Authored By:
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Further Information:
www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com
www.cks.in
Content
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 6
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 1
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services report created by CKS
Consulting Pvt. Ltd. (hereafter ‘CKS’) reviews key learnings from the research
conducted by CKS on behalf of Nokia Siemens Networks during May- June, 2008
in Vietnam, Philippines, Indonesia, Bangladesh and India.
The Rural Marketing Practices research for South and South- East Asia was
designed with the aim of gaining key marketing insights from the middle
management of companies successfully involved in rural markets in these
world regions. Initial secondary research revealed that the most successful
rural marketing organizations came not only from the Telecom sector but also
very substantially from other service sectors like FMCG, Banking, Insurance,
Pharmaceuticals, Fertilizers and Pesticides and Retail. These sectors were
perceived to have entered the rural ecology in ways more fundamental than
targeting these locales as mere markets. Consequently, they have reaped the
benefts of being the market leaders when it came to catering to the substantial
rural population.
The fndings of this research are divided into three main axis of analysis. First,
building a comprehensive understanding of South and South- East Asia as
a region for tremendous telecom growth. Secondly, identifying current rural
marketing best practices that are being successfully implemented in emerging
economies. Finally, recommending key strategies for adoption and new research
areas which, if initiated, can successfully strengthen rural marketing strategies in
a bid to reach out to the next 100 million users who are expected to come from
rural centers.
Preface
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 2
Executive Summary
Rural consumers in South and South- East Asia have tremendous potential for telecom adoption but very few
know how to either identify these consumers or reach out to them. Remoteness and low spending capacities
are cited by prominent organizations as reasons for not conceptualizing dedicated rural marketing strategies.
The situation is changing with growing rural prosperity and the need for technology to resolve challenges of
remoteness through information access.
In order to cater to rural consumers, it is important to understand and respect their livelihood. Companies
which are considered to be rural marketing leaders have an average rural presence of more than two
decades. Through consistent presence and support for the rural ecology, such organizations have
strengthened their hold over these markets. New companies trying to rapidly reach such levels of rural
presence will need to convey that they take their responsibility- offering a service- seriously and that they
will be constant partners in rural living. The frst mover in such markets has the potential of becoming
synonymous with the product category itself. In terms of successful promoting efforts, mass media campaigns
will continue but various last mile strategies like ‘dangdut’ (musical soiree in Indonesia) or participating
in local fairs also need to be evolved to reach out to the largest sections of the sparsely distributed rural
population. Price reductions based on innovative service bundling across urban and rural locations stand to
beneft rural consumers. Lowering the initial costs of entry is expected to keep organizations in proft since
reduced proft margins stand to be compensated by a larger consumer base.
CKS further recommends the need for service segmentation and innovative bundling for proftability,
integration of various rural organizations into exclusive marketing networks, adoption of a rural
enablement policy, implementation of hyper local strategies and most importantly, initiation of detailed rural
segmentations, as key ways in which telecom players stands to strengthen their positions and lead global
rural marketing efforts.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 3
The rural marketing practices research was conducted with the objective of:
• Identifying key operators and service providers who have been reaching out to rural consumers in
innovative ways
• Understanding diverse market segmentation models for rural consumers which are currently being used by
market experts
• Understanding communication strategies adopted by service sector companies in reaching out to the rural
consumers
• Explaining how key elements of the marketing process are actioned by marketing teams
In order to meet these objectives, the research process was initiated with in- depth secondary research.
This enabled a better understanding of the service market in terms of rural and low income consumers in
these designated economies. Based on these fndings, 20 in- depth expert interviews were conducted in
the 5 countries identifed for this research. Out of 4 experts interviews conducted per country, 2 were taken
from the telecom sector and the other 2 from a combination of the previously- mentioned service sectors. 20
middle managers were interviewed and their thoughts were analyzed in internal review sessions. A workshop
was also conducted by CKS during which all expert comments were reviewed collectively, analyzed and
tagged under the following heads:
• Characteristics low income and rural consumers
• Position, promotion, price and placement of service product
• Marketing best practices in the service industry for low income and rural consumers
The outcomes from the workshop were then synthesized and mapped to further secondary research fndings
in order to project for telecom stakeholders the most effective rural marketing strategies.
Research Objectives and Methodology
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 4
Understanding South and South-East Asia
South and South- East Asia is the current global favor for foreign direct investments. This region is the
primary recipient of private equity investment, attracting more than 60% of net portfolio equity investment
fows to emerging market economies in 2006. Such investments are well warranted since Asia has three of
the fastest growing economies in the world, namely, China, Vietnam and India. However, the region also has
ample diversity in terms of demographics, infrastructure growth potentials, income parameters, technology
penetration levels, local markets and potential adapters, for there to be a need to understand these countries
more specifcally and more strategically.
In spite of differences, rural Asia faces similar challenges of hard infrastructure. Hard Infrastructure like
paved roads, basic electricity, healthcare, transport and educational institutions are extremely sparse. Ta Van
in Vietnam received its frst fxed phone as late as 2004. Less than 60% of India’s villages have metal roads
or electrical connection. Vietnam is the only country in this study which is currently investing 7% of its annual
GDP to upgrade its infrastructure and in this it is only second to China in Asia.
The absence of hard infrastructure in these regions is partially compensated by their rapid soft infrastructure
growth. Soft infrastructure includes terrestrial cable, satellite television, mobile coverage and broadband
cable. Soft infrastructure growth compensates to some degree for the problem of remoteness by enabling
easier information availability. Soft infrastructure roll out, however, is being perceived as the prerogative of
private organizations involved in these sectors. Private players, especially the frst movers, stand to beneft
from continued soft infrastructure roll - out as a wholly untapped 50% of their subscriber base in these
economies are located in rural areas.
The size of the rural telecom market in most of South and South- East Asia is between 50 and 70% of
their populations, except Philippines which is more than 60% urbanized. Characteristically, in most Asian
countries, although more than 50% of the population is engaged in agri - related services, progressively lesser
and lesser percentage of the national GDP is coming from this sector. In India, the rural sector’s contribution
decreased from 48% in 1950 to around 27% of the GDP in 2000. Rural consumption, however, is on the rise
due to increasing agricultural pricing, strong growth in employment in manufacturing and service sectors,
steady remittances fow from international labor migration and the overall rural development agenda of these
economies. The profle of the fastest rural technology adopter is male, aged between 30 to 35, possessing
adequate literacy and having growing employment needs or alternative earning needs. Bangladesh is the
only perceivable exception to such a profling since its rural women already enjoy substantial benefts due to
Grameen’s women empowerment policy.
Fig 1: Socio-technological profle of South and South-East Asia
(Source: CKS-EER Team based on Encylopedia Britannica, United
Nations Development Programe, ITU World Telecommunication and
ICT Indicators Database)
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 5
In gearing up for this market, some key factors need to be kept in mind. First, rural income levels being lower
than the urban population’s, in turn, affect their capacity for telecom adoption. Secondly, rural employment
is gradually moving away from traditional agriculture to explore new opportunities in the service industry.
Thirdly, the gaps between urban and rural markets in Asia are on the decline. Per household consumption
in rural India will reach today’s urban levels by 2017. Fourthly, the youth sector plays a key role in Asian
telecom market. They are rapidly beginning to rely more on online and wireless media. The South- East Asian
wireless telecom industry is projected to grow by more than 50% in the next fve years. Young people are at
the forefront of the evolution of this medium and their usage habits will dictate the types of media, products,
entertainment options and platforms that will be available. Fifthly, women are emerging as interesting partners
in Asia’s rural telecom growth since they are less of a credit risk than men and using them as telecom service
providers also improves telecom penetration among the rural female consumer base. Sixthly, given the lower
income in rural households, rural telecom users prefer a service- based model than a purchase- based one
since the purchase cost is itself a substantial frst hurdle for rural consumers to cross. Lastly, in order to meet
rural Asia’s telecom needs, the mobile phone is perceived to be the current favorite amongst platforms. Fig 2: Bangladesh’s Household Expenditure by Sector
(Source: World Resources Institute)
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 6
Understanding telecom needs and growth potentials of rural Asia, however, remain incomplete without an
understanding of what is rural in these economies. Defnitions vary from country to country. Most countries
defne urban. Areas beyond that are understood as rural.
In Vietnam all places with 4,000 inhabitants or more are considered to be urban. Areas beyond this criterion
are rural.
Bangladesh defnes its urban area as concentrations of at least 5,000 persons in a continuous collection of
houses where the community sense is well developed and the community maintains public utilities, such as
roads, street lighting, water supply and sanitary arrangements. These places are also centers of trade and
commerce where the labor force is mostly non- agricultural and literacy levels are high. Areas that fall beyond
such parameters are understood to be rural.
In Indonesia the defnition of urban includes Municipalities (‘kotamadya’), regency capitals (‘kabupaten’) and
other places with urban characteristics. All others are rural.
In Philippines an area is urban if a ‘barangay’ (ward) has a population size of 5,000 or more, has at least
one establishment with a minimum of 100 employees, has 5 or more establishments with a minimum of 10
employees, and 5 or more facilities within the two- kilometer radius from the barangay hall. All other remaining
areas beyond this defnition are rural in Philippines.
The Census of India, on the other hand, defnes rural explicitly. Areas with clear surveyed boundaries not
having a municipality, corporation or board, with density of population not more than 400 per km
2
and with at
least 75% of the male working population engaged in agriculture and allied activities qualify as rural.
Rurality as a concept, thus remains, complex to identify even today. Improved understanding will require
more sophisticated analysis based on factors of remoteness, income and growth potentials.
Defining Rural and Urban Asia
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 7
In trying to cater to rural markets, as important as it is to identify the market size and location, it is equally
important to understand the challenges in livelihood of this potential consumer base. Understanding the
intricacies of their lives enables successful product service creations that are resonant with their needs and
expenditure capacities.
In rural Asia, consumers face 6 key challenges which affect rural prosperity. These challenges arise out of
infrastructural and information needs which are aggravated by remoteness. Rural consumers identify lack
of transportation, diffculties in managing their commercial transactions, lack of healthcare services, being
uninformed of governance policies, lacking effective education and shortage of opportunities in infotainment as
prime deterrents to their living an improved lifestyle. (The Mobile Development Report, 2006)
In order to make rural prosperity achievable, certain key services need to emerge. First, coordinated rural
transportation based on mobile information delivery, will increase convenience and allow users to fnd
transportation ‘on- demand’ without depending on unreliable pliers, irregular timings or incurring huge
expenses. Secondly, the rural economy will be strengthened through exhaustive micro- commerce ventures
like mobile ordering, payments and delivery requests; all helping isolated small - scale entrepreneurs working in
remote locations. Thirdly, healthcare services through telecom and broadband intervention will allow doctors,
nurses and midwives to stay in closer contact with patients. Fourthly, rural governance services giving access
to citizen data will allow the rural population to be more informed of national level developments and reduce
the urban- rural divide. Fifthly, rural education needs to beneft from more sophisticated processing and
exchange of multimedia data across national regions for educational benefts. Lastly, mobile and broadband
will allow peer - to- peer distribution of infotainmnet data, opening up new streams of rural content creation and
distribution. Meeting these basic rural needs is possible for the telecom industry. Rural consumers are also
willing to invest in service offerings that can fundamentally improve these aspects of their lives.
Understanding Rural Consumers
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 8
In rural South and South- East Asia, telecom is still a novelty. It continues to be introduced even now as
penetration levels hover at just around 20% on average. The telecom sector as a whole also keeps undergoing
continuous innovation, up gradation and repositioning with new products and service offerings for different
sectors of the population. As a category, it is highly volatile to the minds of the rural consumers since they see
the same category offering so much variety. Coca Cola sells Coke but Nokia sells handsets for the rich, for the
poor and for the youth. It enters in joint ventures with Airtel or is present as event sponsors in IPL cricket. Such
multi - platform brand presence is complex to the rural mind. Educating rural consumers on how to become
telecom users and commodifying telecom to the extent of FMCG goods, will be the biggest challenge for rural
telecom marketing.
In attempting to enter the rural markets, telecom companies will also face the task of re- positioning themselves
to an almost wholly new subscriber base. There will always be a frst and a later mover when the market
expands. For various reasons different companies may chose to become either one of them. The frst mover
has the advantage of unlimited numbers. Later players will capitalize on the market that has been set up by
the frst mover. BSNL in India initiated the task of taking telecom connectivity to rural India. At the present,
however, it is faced with competitions from Bharti Airtel, Reliance and Vodafone. In order for BSNL to continue
maintaining its lead in this market, it will need to undertake serious innovations in telecom service design and
rural marketing to maintain its lead. Viettel from Vietnam, on the other hand, positions itself as a competitor
and not a cheap brand. It is of the view that pricing has a direct impact on the positioning of the product and it
has no immediate aim of reducing costs in order to consciously make stronger rural inroads. It does, however,
make special provisions like its TOMATO package, ‘a package for everybody’ or its HOMEPHONE which is a
wireless local loop (WLL), ‘Package for every home’ in its bid to capture more subscribers.
Our research also indicates that in order to cater to the rural segment, it is also advisable to avoid using
premium lifestyle images, since such a lifestyle is beyond rural income capacity. Idea Cellular uses Abhishek
Bachchan as a ‘Jat’. (‘Jat’ is an ethnic group resident mainly in Punjab, India and traditionally involved in
agriculture). In spite of belonging to a higher class, he tries to resolve community class and caste differences
by identifying all through their mobile numbers than through their names, race or religion. This is topical, and
thus, highly appreciated. On the other hand, Idea’s My Gang ads focusing on the urban youth’s cool, energetic
appeal, would loose some resonance for this segment. Rural operator positioning thus needs to appeal to the
actualities of rural lifestyle. Service providers, however, are simultaneously cautioned about not losing their
existing urban clientele due to an exaggerated rural focus.
Assessment of the Asian Rural Telecom Scenario
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 9
Promotion
Rural product marketing is emerging as an interesting challenge both for the advertisement fraternity as well
as for global organizations commissioning such campaigns. Current promotions of rural products continue
to fall back on traditional mass media practices of making use of the broadcast media and using celebrity
endorsements. These methods enjoy intermediate success.
Mass media campaigns though commonly used, often remain untargeted and do not reach the widest segment
of the rural population due to challenges of low literacy, remoteness and low population density across the rural
landscape. In a country like India, there are roughly 105 million homes with televisions which is about the same
as in the United States, but for India, it amounts to only about 50% penetration in the country’s households
through shared access, compared to 98% penetration for the U. S. A. Mass media also represents a primarily
urban and an overarching national sensibility since the national entertainment industry fails to echo local
dialectical and cultural variations. In terms of a mass media strategy, the recommendations of this research
is that companies will need to continue using this media but there needs to be an awareness that some
percentage of the population will always remain left out of this media reach.
Celebrity endorsements are an equally prominent marketing strategy for telecom products and services.
Indosat in Indonesia makes use of the musical band Radja which is a favorite of the youth. Globe Telecom in
Philippines uses the singer Sharon Cuneta. These endorsements are most effective with the youth segment
but for rural marketing purposes, such endorsements will need to be done more succinctly than just tapping in
a celebrity’s star status. An informational approach is more resonant with rural and low income consumers as
they need product information to make the right decision. Regionalization and localization of campaigns also
help target consumers associate with the product.
In order to truly cater to the remotest of consumers, we also observe the emergence of various innovative last
mile marketing strategies. Organizing ‘Dangdut’ in Indonesia and ‘Jatras’ (dramas) in India and Bangladesh,
sending trained personnel to the felds directly to interact with the rural consumers, involving Islamic leaders
or village heads in utilizing a certain product or service and then using them as spokespersons to make others
aware of the benefts of the schemes, arranging monthly lucky draws in village markets or before local banks
and taking the help of local self help groups, are all yielding crucial rural marketing success.
Rural Marketing Best Practices
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 10
Placement
Product placement in rural Asia emerges as a substantial diffculty due to the widely disseminated nature
of rural living. Lack of basic infrastructure like transport, electricity and roads further heighten such diffculty
levels. Most rural marketing enterprises fnd it diffcult to fnd their target consumers, market to them or even
place their products due to diffculties in setting up a distribution channel. Setting up retail points in rural areas
amount to heavy investments and private companies often refrain from making such investments due to low
returns from these areas. In such situations, FMCG retail agencies are found to have the highest success
rate in rural penetration. With greater remoteness, retail points become smaller in size and limited in product
options but they manage to distribute the basic service even to the remotest of locations. Latching on to an
existing successful retail distribution network like the ‘Sari Sari’ shops in Philippines increases the reach of
the telecom product and helps telecom penetrate the rural remote markets. Once the market matures and
becomes cost effective to the company, the telecom company can opt to have its own network. In areas where
there are not enough such retail chains, the product has to be placed using innovative retail points which can
be small portable kiosks or booths.
The sales networks of service providers like banking and insurance are also effective placement points.
Financial sales networks operate through trained personnel who educate and inform the rural consumers
about their service offerings. Since telecom companies may not want to invest from the beginning in trained
personnel who can go and sell the products door to door, they can tie up with these agencies, leverage the
knowledge of their personnel and beneft from the overall sales networks. Using the ‘human touch’ to expand
one’s sales networks in rural areas is a crucial strategy.
Rural agencies like post offces, electricity supply divisions and educational institutions all have existing
infrastructure in rural areas. Electricity of Vietnam Telecom (EVN) and Vietnam Posts and Telecommunications
Group (VNPT) use the distribution outlets of their parent companies as sales channels for their telecom
products. Partnering with schools and colleges will also help telecom companies reach the lower income
consumer segment and possible future adopters, i.e. parents and students. Tying up with public agencies can
help telecom operators use existing infrastructure as their distribution and sales base without having to invest
in creating this infrastructure while tapping into possible consumers who come to such institutions.
Position
In rural markets in South and South- East Asia, consumers have diffculty in understanding multifaceted brand
positioning. Coca Cola sells Coke but Nokia sells handsets for the rich, for the poor and for the youth. It
enters in joint ventures with Airtel. It also has a PC- mobile platform through Ovi. Such multi -platform or multi
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 11
modal brand positioning is complex to the rural mind and consequently should not be a priority at the initial
stages of entry into the rural market. Secondly, to off - set consumer demands for cheaper offerings, telecom
marketing has to undertake consumer education frst. At an early stage of introduction of a product or service,
a brand has an opportunity to become the category. In Indonesia, auto rickshaws ‘ojeks’ are called ‘Bajaj,’
(an eminent Indian auto maker exporting these vehicles). In some parts of Africa trucks are called ‘Tatas’
(globally renowned Indian automotive company). Such identifcation of a brand with the category is extremely
desirable. It indicates an ownership of the product or service category itself. Thirdly, rural and low income
consumers want to know the benefts of the product in the light of the category. Hutch and Nokia’s brand
message of ‘Connecting People’ is no different than what is valued in the category of telecom- connectivity. In
rural marketing, the message that counts and needs to be pushed consistently is ‘Use the service’.
Rural consumers once they start using a particular product or service which wins their liking, become
extremely brand loyal. Companies with substantial rural footprint have almost 20 plus years of strong rural
presence. In order for new companies to rapidly reach such levels of rural presence, they will need to convey
that they take their responsibility- offering a service- very seriously and that they will be constant partners
in rural living. Grameen Bank in Bangladesh provides every member’s family with an insurance amount on
the member’s death. Telecom companies need not provide insurance but in rural Asia, they have to initially
focus on constant presence rather than on service diversity and quality improvement. A telecom brand that
becomes a trusted rural resource and maintains consistent service will retain its consumers for a very long
time due to the slow rate of rural roll - out. ‘We are there’- is the message to be spread across. It is straight -
forward and it needs to be projected straight up.
A successful rural marketing strategy would also involve widespread and well timed presence in rural lifecycle
events and occasions. Presence in large village congregations like fairs and weddings help a brand gain
visibility amongst a large segment of the rural population in a single place. Involvement in village ‘panchayat’
(governance) and counseling services is an important indicator of the company’s intention to make its rural
presence a continuous and long term relationship. Sponsoring and / or organizing sports activities and other
rural events also help in establishing the brand as integral to rural lifestyle. Thus in terms of positioning,
it is important to identify mass congregation occasions in rural areas, use rural market days as the best
opportunity for regular product marketing and participate in rural social occasions in order to show your
support for the community while benefting from mass presence.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 12
Price
In terms of pricing, there is a lot of fallacy regarding the capacities of rural consumers. Our rural marketing
experts reveal that rural consumers are ready and willing to adopt mobile technology in varying degrees and
at different price points than urban users. These varying degrees of tech adoption and price points depend
on their communication needs and levels of affordability. For rural consumers a telecom service bundle
must contain information on areas that are relevant to their livelihood like market data, fnance availability or
potential sales data. In order to understand a price point that is payable by rural consumers, the needs and
affordable price limits of rural consumers need to be mapped and matched. Any pricing for the rural market
should also refect a respect for the value of rural income.
Another fnding of this research is that telecom companies so far, have not made enough efforts to analyze
income variations in rural contexts. They have been using urban benchmarks for rural markets. Some
companies rely on retail and product sector segmentation, whereas the two are very different. The telecom
market has now reached a threshold where it can no longer afford to follow the segmentation of the FMCG
sector. They need to understand the income capacities of their rural consumers and innovate their service
offerings per segment so as to prevent them from cannibalizing on each other’s interests. Only when service
offerings for each consumer group become truly exclusive, they will justify different tariff rates and consumers
will understand and accept such price marks based on their own necessities and capacities.
Rural telecom pricing also stands to beneft from any lowering of the initial barriers to entry. Rural consumers
living on a day- to- day basis, have no disposable income to pay for the repeated costs of handsets, sim
charges and other ancillary expenses. These up- front costs are substantially high and any means that can
reduce this frst cost will beneft rural consumers. Viettel in Vietnam started the 6 seconds +1 policy where
subscribers had to pay for the frst 6 seconds as default after which they were charged on per second basis
rather than on a minute pulse. EVN telecom’s strategy of giving away sim cards with credit amount loaded is
very popular with the rural and low income consumers in Vietnam. Reducing such basic entry level costs will
not make company profts suffer since a larger consumer base will compensate for the reduced proft margins.
Having enunciated the current rural marketing best practices that can be adopted, CKS further recommends
some key long term strategies which stand to beneft long range rural marketing endeavors.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 13
Consumer Segmentation, Service Innovation, Profitability
In order to develop a sophisticated understanding of Asia’s rural markets, it needs to be understood that rural
telecom services will have to be customized based on extensive consumer segmentation. This consumer
segmentation will depend on varied parameters of occupation, literacy, income and noticeable service needs.
Detailed segmentation of this kind will allow for the preservation of proft margins in sectors which can afford
such premium costs while allowing for subsidized rates in the rural markets. Rural consumers will thus be
served strategically with a good service and at effective price points.
Integrated Rural Marketing Strategies
The telecom industry needs to identify successful partners in sectors like agriculture, health, banking and
retail. Identifying as many different partners as possible will help organizations reach out to a maximum
variety of the rural population. The purpose of such partnership will be to leverage the existent marketing
network that has already been created by these partnering companies. Both partners stand to beneft through
extended knowledge sharing as well as proft division. However, if one wants to retain one’s own stronghold
on the rural market, telecom companies will need to opt for exclusive partnerships creating a complex
network of monopolistic rural distribution chain.
Rural Enablement
Telecom companies which intend to take advantage of being the frst movers, will also have to have a rural
enablement agenda. Providing quality service that will connect remote environments is the best way in which
it can assist rural enablement. As the frst mover in rural service provision, it will also have to undertake some
basic infrastructural responsibility. Further enablement will also occur with educating rural consumers on the
benefts of telecom adoption and possible incremental income hikes. True rural enablement will occur once
organizations begin to perceive the rural community as a special customer base which is worth investing in.
Hyper Local Strategies
In order to appeal to the consumers of rural Asia, telecom marketing will need to adopt very local strategies in
its marketing and distribution schemes. Adopting local strategies will position the brand as well informed and
interested in rural conditions. Such strategies are also considerably inexpensive as opposed to nationwide
mass media campaigns which also fail to reach the whole population. In order to fully beneft from the
Strategies for Success
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 14
adoption of such hyper local strategies, telecom companies will need to undertake detailed research on socio-
cultural knowledge systems in each of these focus countries individually and assess how the same can be
converted into country- specifc marketing efforts.
Initiating a Rural Segmentation
Rural segmentation remains a challenge for all telecom companies. This segmentation will be key to
evolving successful marketing strategies. The telecom sector has the opportunity to evolve such a complex
understanding of rural consumers by undertaking further studies in possible ways of rural segmentation. The
data that will be collected about rural Asia, will then need to be further contextualized to specifc country needs,
providing telecom companies with strategic market insights that will be unparalleled in the public domain.
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 15
About Nokia Siemens Networks
Nokia Siemens Networks is a leading global enabler of communications services. The company provides a
complete, well - balanced product portfolio of mobile and fxed network infrastructure solutions and addresses
the growing demand for services with 20,000 service professionals worldwide. Nokia Siemens Networks
is one of the largest telecommunications infrastructure companies with operations in 150 countries. The
company is headquartered in Espoo, Finland. For more information, please visit our website at www.
nokiasiemensnetworks.com
A world where everyone can be connected
Mobile communication technology is expanding so fast that by 2015, an estimated 5 billion people will have
access to communications and information services. In emerging markets, the affordability and convenience
of mobile devices, networks and services are playing a crucial role in bringing the internet to more and
more people- even those who live and work in the most isolated parts of the world. Affordable access to
communications technology encourages social inclusion and contributes to progress in a range of social
economic and environmental issues. We in Nokia Siemens Networks will continue to work closely with other
companies, the public sector and civil society to promote the spread of mobile technology. Together, we can
create a future of untold benefts for everyone. To fnd out more, please visit
www.unite.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/nextbillion
The Center for Knowledge Societies (CKS) is the world’s leading research, design and innovation
consulting company focusing on Emerging Economies. CKS has worked with global corporations in various
sectors from Telecommunications, Mobile Services, Aviation, Automotive, Hospitality and Financial Services
among many others. CKS has pioneered new solutions for communities and individuals, who may not enjoy
continuous access to media, communications, energy and other forms of infrastructure. For more information,
please visit our website at www.cks.in
Appendix
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 16
Authored By:
CKS Consulting Pvt. Ltd.
Commissioned By:
Nokia Siemens Networks
Further Information:
www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com
www.cks.in
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 17
Rural Marketing For Telecom Services 18
The Rural Marketing Practices for Telecom Services Report offers a frst of its kind in-depth understanding of rural
markets in South and South- East Asia. It provides unique insights on innovative ways in which various service
sectors are reaching out to their potential customer base. The images in the report taken in actual feld locations,
highlight interesting marketing efforts developed to overcome challenges of remoteness and infrastructure lacks.
New research directions are also proposed on the basis of feld fndings, to ensure that rural consumers beneft
from specialized efforts made to reach out to them.
doc_905598849.pdf