Description
Reports on Ethical Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India and a Proposal for a Globalization Ethic:- A multinational state is a sovereign state which is viewed as comprising two or more nations. Such a state contrasts with a nation-state where a single nation comprises the bulk of the population.
Reports on Ethical Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India and a Proposal for a Globalization Ethic
Executive Summary Multinationals have driven the rapid economic expansion of India at a breathtaking pace. At the same time, India's infrastructure has not kept up with demand, the poor are not able To tap into the economic influx and multinationals have raised locals concerns on what Ethical practices should be driven within the country. India's situation is different from past "outsourcing activity" with the rise of globalization and makes the questions bigger. How multinationals conduct business within India and what should does an ethical framework look like specifically within India and in light of the changes caused by globalization? This paper will look at a proposal for an ethical framework for multinationals doing business in India and will propose a need to inquire and put in place a globalization ethic that will serve today's new business climate. Beyond the normative business ethics of utilitarianism and Kant's theory of the categorical imperative the ethical model of virtue ethics will be applied through the lens of a vocational metaethic. The new ethical framework will also apply Indian tradition in the context of present and past reflection to strive for Justice in the new expansion of India. An additional framework of the ethical model is globalization to ensure that business strives forward but at the same time considers the realities of the market situation. To complete the ethical model the paper analyzes key stakeholders in Indian business, beyond the traditional stakeholders, to give multinationals a framework to weave within the fabric of their organization and help put in place policies and process that reflect the ethical model. The fictional company Transporter, a creator and manufacture of cell phones, provides a "case study" of how the ethical model can take shape within a multinational complex situation in doing business in India.
Page 3
I. Introduction The world is truly flat proclaims the now famous "short" history of the 21st century that explores the new trends and reality of globalization.1 Companies all over India echo the sentiment of a "flat world" and talk about the changes it is making on both Indian and multinationals companies and the larger society. As more and more business flows into India, multinational companies (MNC) need to take a step back and analyze the best way to approach business in a country that has in the past been exploited by outsiders 2 and is cautiously drinking the kool-aid of money as it flows into a country that is bursting from expansion. At the same time that a new generation of entrepreneurial talent has been unleashed,3 "infrastructure, such as roads and power, and public services, such as education and drinking water, are woefully inadequate and limit growth."4 The latest issue of The Economist mentions "it seems incongruous that somebody can own a mobile phone, yet has to waste hours queuing in line for drinking water."5 The chairman of the Confederation of Indian Industries Banmali Agarwala, " ?in [a] answer to a question about business ethics and [the] fact that some CEOs in the U.S. face criminal and civil charges, said Maharashtra is developing a 'code of conduct' in partnership with industry leaders. Whatever framework is developed 'has to be for the public good.'"6 The proposal of an ethical framework is critical to ensuring the continued expansion of multinationals into India's vast potential market. This project will analyze the implications of doing business in India from the perspective of a multinational that needs to grow a market, outsource work, and help a country continue to develop India's infrastructure. First, it will look at how MNCs and Indian companies have
1
Thomas L. Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century (New York: Farrar, Straus and Girox, 2006), 7. 2 Amartya Sen, The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity (New York: Picador, 2005), 139. 3 "India Overheats," The Economist, February 3rd-9th 2007, 11. 4 Ibid. 5 Ibid. 6 Richard Springer, "Maharashtra Cm Reassures Silicon Valley Entrepreneurs," India West, Jul 1 2005.
Page 4
approached doing business in India over the last few years. Next, the paper will look at journal articles on business ethics in order to look at ethical approaches to conducting business. This information will help identify the stakeholders within India that are the MNC responsibility to treat with respect. When the analysis/synthesis is complete, it will help to define the framework of an ethical model in which MNCs can utilize when doing business in India. India also provides a live "case study" in which to develop an ethical model for the future of globalization. The unique situation of India is the experiencing urbanization in a large scale in the era of globalization verse urbanization that happened during the industrial revolution.7 Theshift calls for an urgent re-evaluation of the today's normative business models to embrace and include the larger factors of globalization and multiple stakeholders affected in today's business environment. It should not be about the "haves and have nots" but should be about making profits in an ethical manner that also values contributing to the common good and social well-being of the world.
II. Current Company Practices in India: Insights from the University of San Francisco Study Tour India's business practice has had different effects over the years on Indian business norms. India has experienced everything from the Great Indian Peninsular Railway Campaign in England during the colonial period to current MNCs in today's period of globalization.8 The globalization affects on India are noticeable through the growth within the country and the attitude of today's business both local and foreign. On the University of San Francisco's India Study Tour, the class was able to hear from many voices throughout many different industries in India focusing mainly in the Bangalore area. Companies as well as non-profits visited by the class included: Infosys, JP Morgan Chase, NEXT, Toyota, TIE Bangalore,
7 8
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India, January 5 - January 20, 2007. Nilanjana Bardhan and Padmini Patwardhan, "Multinational Corporations and Public Relations in a Historically Resistant Host Culture," review of Reviewed Item, Journal of Communication Management, no. 3 (2004).
Page 5
Wipro, The Prem Jen Foundation, Cisco, an SOS Children's Village.9 The trip revealed many management practices both good and bad as well as the direction of companies in the future. An issue that was brought up at the TIE Bangalore visit was MNCs currently are focused on increasing profits since a big trend has been outsourcing for lower wages instead of focusing on the community where its business resides.10 Not all businesses are focused on only profits as can be seen by the examples of WiPro with the Prem Jen Foundation for helping schools and Cisco's eGovernance and Networking Academy initiatives. However, even with the inflow of investment, India's poor is still a real and extremely visible problem. During the trip, additional issues/problems bubbled to the forefront as themes facing both national and MNCs. The first theme was around the education and retention of employees in a highly competitive culture. Companies in India face very high demand for recent graduates and skilled workers from both internally and externally (countries such as the US and the EU), driven by the advances of globalization. Although India has 350,000 engineering graduates, each year supply has not keep up with demand. WiPro offers its employees the Wipro University and employs over 100 professors to ensure employees are equipped. Workers loyalty to companies is low especially when a competing firm can offer 50% increases in salary. This practice has created quite a situation in which MNCs that want to establish operations quickly recruit from Indian companies who have invested years of training and education on an employee. The practice has raised the eyebrows of wellrespected Indian business men and women who have pointed to a management problem and an ethical problem. Another theme that was prominent in discussions with many of the businesses within Bangalore was the topic of infrastructure. Cities such as Bangalore and Chennai are "creaking at its seams."11 Companies have created large-scale corporate campuses that are
9
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. 10 Ibid. TIE Bangalore, Jan 15, 2007 11 "Infrastructure Needs Serious Attention in Tn," Businessline (2007).
Page 6
essentially islands. These "islands" consist of their own power, infrastructure, food service etc. while the surrounding city overflows with traffic, housing, people, and in some cases requiring the poor to relocate. Companies at the same time have brought an immense amount good to India, especially in the form of monetary benefit. However, the infrastructure needs of the country cannot go without notice and private industry needs to be part of the solution rather than just seen as the problem.12 As I start to formulate the ethical framework for MNCs doing business in India, I will use a fictional company named Transporter, their business model being the creation of software and hardware for the cell phone industry. Their goal is to provide a low cost handset for emerging markets as well as penetrate more developed markets in the future with a low cost operation model. The company's revenues are currently at $1 billion dollars and they have made healthy profits in developing software that is in most of the world's cell phones. The headquarters of the company is in Canada and the company is on the NASDAQ under the symbol TRPT. Although they are currently in several countries including most of the
European countries as well as China and South Korea they have decided to make a huge push in their strategy to both manufacture in India and engage the ever growing Indian cell phone industry. As the ethical framework develops in this paper, Transporter will allow us to provide examples and nuances that would otherwise be lost if the concepts were strictly discussed in the abstract. First, we will look at developing an ethical framework/model for MNCs conducting business within India.
III. Developing an Ethical Framework "Many multinationals see Asia as a source of opportunity, but it will also give them their greatest challenges in business ethics and corporate social responsibility."13 One of the issues that companies face is what ethical model to use within the business operations. In the past, business ethics discussions centered on two normative approaches to making
12 13
"Public-Private Partnership Is the Way to Build Infrastructure," Businessline (2006). Chandran Nair, "Why Asia Must Look Beyond Profits to Ethics Chandran Nair," Financial Times, Sep 5 2005.
Page 7
ethical decisions in business in the older ethical models of deontology and teleology. Deontology is the belief "?that there are certain sorts of acts that are wrong in themselves, and thus morally unacceptable means to the pursuit of any ends, even ends that are morally admirable, or morally obligatory."14 Kant expressed a derivative of this view in the language of acts.15 Although at first glance this position seems to be a very moral position, it fails to take into account consequences of decisions especially when the decisions are in grey areas of large and complex business problems that do not have a clear right or wrong attached to them. These decisions however could materialize in grave ethical issues if the outcomes are not considered. In an article from The Journal of Business Ethics on the ethical implications of sweatshops, it is concluded that deontology falls short for offering a solution for this very big problem. The article concludes: "Deontology thus fails to offer adequate assistance in enabling individuals to contextualize their decision-making within a range of norms and the parameters of foreseeable consequences."16 Teleology, also known as utilitarianism only focuses on the ultimate outcome and the greatest utility. The philosopher Macintyre "?rejects the enlightenment view of ethics as rational action based on duty or rules (deontological), or the greatest happiness for the largest number (utilitarianism or consequentialism)."17Both normative views are lacking a complete picture of ethical decision-making. A motivation beyond utility and defining attention to character is needed to move past the current stalemates and to move into a model that will help businesses make ethical decisions that are embedded within the fabric of the organization and its people in light of new era of globalization.
14
Nancy Davis, "Contemporary Deontology," in A Companion to Ethics, ed. Peter Singer, Blackwell Companions to Philosophy (Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd., 1993), 205. 15 Ethical Theory and Business, ed. Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie (Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004), 25. 16 Tara J. Radin and Martin Calkins, "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business," Journal of Business Ethics, no. 66 (2006): 264. 17 David Knights and Majella O'Leary, "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other," Journal of Business Ethics, no. 67 (2006): 132.
Page 8
IV. A Vocational "Calling" Metaethic: Wisdom Lessons in Motivation In setting out to define an ethical model, I want to first define the source of inspiration when applying normative ethical approaches to business. Without a source of inspiration or motivation, it is hard to argue for a need for an ethical model beyond legal or profitable concerns. A source of motivation will help provide a reason for performing within an ethical model. The motivation to the framework I am proposing is a metaethic of "calling" or viewing your role in society as a vocation, similar to a profession of a doctor or priest who are both called into actions beyond their own personal gain. A business leader within the organization needs a purpose beyond their work environment that drives them to make ethical decisions or even apply an ethical model.18 Without this motivation or reason why would a business leader want to make good decisions beyond those that would benefit the company's profits? This especially becomes a concern in areas that are not legally binding and fall into seemly grey areas that without an ethical model would drive profits to rule out ethical decisions. These "grey" areas are important because the decisions made within this area can move companies to large-scale unethical behavior and practice, especially in countries that do not have clearly defined laws (i.e. child labor practices within India).19 The question arises on how the first step of the framework will help the fictional company Transporter in its operations within India. The metaethic concept, defined as questions on the meaning of ethics, or "what they are doing when they talk about what they do"20 helps ensure one is really looking at the motivation behind an ethical act or acts. Transporter first needs to have a reason to do an ethical act. Is it purely legal? On the other hand, are business actions motivated by a sense of higher purpose? The concept of calling or vocation gives a motivation that one's purpose as a business and organizational leader is to "?hold
18
Payson Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business," (University of San Francisco, 2005). 19 Augendra Bhukuth and JÈrÙme Ballet, "Is Child Labour a Substitute for Adult Labour?," International Journal of Social Economics 33, no. 8 (2006). 20 Alexander Miller, An Introduction to Contemporary Metaethics (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2003), 2-3.
Page 9
resources, people and capital in trust for many and it is essential that their guiding principles for such stewardship transcend the instrumental and narrowly parochial concerns of their professional positions and practices."21 Unfortunately, in today's business environment organizational leadership does not yet have the respect of a true profession or vocation even though organizations have a large affect on the morals of people and the society.22 This is a key area in the realm of business that needs to change in order to build a more robust framework for ethical decisions. By Transporter applying the concept of vocation as the motivation for the ethical model, it helps provide the motivation for acting ethically beyond the law or solely profits. It helps the leader regard business management in terms of stewardship and stakeholders. Moreover, it moves the motivation beyond any individual person's self gain to something that provides a societal purpose of improvement of the common good. If Transporter's employees embrace the concept of vocational decision making the motivation of thecompany will be ensuring the welfare of all involved. Society and India will be better for this since business leaders are now "social roles, which provide a culture with its moral definitions."23
V. Values: Tempering the Market with Virtue Ethics The normative ethical theory of virtue ethics is the second step within the framework of the proposed business model. This theory is ?"an alternative to the main deontological and consequentialist traditions in modern moral"24 thought and "challenges the autonomous
21
Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach
t22 Business," 10. o "The Ethical Mind: A Conversation with Psychologist Howard Gardner," Harvard Business Review 85, no. 3 (2007): 53. 23 Alasdair MacIntyre, After Virtue (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981), 31. 24 Virtue Ethics, ed. Stephen Darwall (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003), From the Back Cover.
Page 10
self."25 It is "?argued that the recent corporate scandals could be seen as resulting from ethical failures arising from contemporary concerns with material and symbolic success, which reside in an ultimate pre-occupation with the self."26 In contrast to the other normative theories, virtue ethics provides a balance of individual actions with understanding and looking at the ultimate consequences. It aligns more closely with the value-based system of India, explored later. A recent article in the Journal of Business Ethics discusses why virtue ethics can help in business decisions where other normative theories fail: "?our sympathy towards virtue ethics resides in a view of the telos or moral project outlined by MacIntyre as a perfect accompaniment to Levinas's responsibility to the Other. An ethic of responsibility moves us away from a preoccupation with the self towards an indeclinable and unlimited responsibility to the Other, experienced in the face-to-face interaction and driven by an inexhaustive care. In-keeping with the constructionist approach, which we endorse, leadership here is interpretation of the Other and the self in the face-to-face interaction."27 Virtue Ethics is "agent-centered" as compared to other normative business ethics are theories that tend to be "act-centered."28 The system has several principles. The first principle is because "I acknowledge I am far from perfect?I need to ask for advice from someone who knows."29 The second principle is that of "?virtue generate a prescription act honestly, charitably, unjustly - but each vice a prohibition - do not act dishonestly, uncharitably, unjustly."30 This version of ethics "?has always emphasized the importance of moral education, not as the inculcation of rules but as the training of character."31 Instead of just a series of rules, the overall character of the individual is the key concern. One of the potential issue of virtue ethics is that there has not been enough written about applying it to
25 26
Knights and O'Leary, "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other," 134. Ibid. 27 Ibid. 28 Rosalind Hursthouse, "Normative Virtue Ethics," in Virtue Ethics, ed. Stephan Darwall (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003), 185. 29 Ibid., 189. 30 Ibid., 190. 31 Rosalind Hursthouse, Virtue Ethics (Metaphysics Research Lab, SDLI, Stanford University, 2003 [cited February 12 2007]).
Page 11
business ethics since it has been newly re-discovered in the last twenty years. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy highlights why there has been a lack of writings of virtue theory textbooks on ethical theories: Textbooks "?now try to include articles representative of each of the three normative approaches but are often unable to find any virtue ethics article addressing a particular issue. This is sometimes, no doubt, because "the" issue has been set up as a deontologicial/utilitarian debate, but it is often simply because no virtue ethicist has yet written on the topic. However, this area can certainly be expected to grow in the future."32 For purposes of this discussion I will only mention five virtues that can be applied to the context of Transporter when doing business in India: Justice, which was praised by Aristotle as the "first virtue of political life."33 Wisdom is the virtue that helps in identifying stakeholders. Fortitude, the driving force to move forward with courage. Temperance, the virtue of restraining from excess and the love of extremes in decisions and tames the forces of the drive for profit. Charity, which shows compassion on all stakeholders involved.34 How can Transporter express these virtues within the context of business decision? One example is through the virtue of justice. Transporter can apply the virtue principle of "justice" in the view of both the past and present situations in terms of righting wrongs that were committed in the past through exploitation. An example of utilizing the virtue of justice is through the modern day practice of multinationals developing product that are geared towards the poor in quantities and prices they can afford. This allows the poor to contribute in the market that traditionally was not available. At the same time, it allows some of the basics of life to become available. Transporter's vision of a low cost cell phone for all economic levels can help start to provide access to communications, enable
32 33
Ibid. MacIntyre, After Virtue, 244. 34 Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business," 21.
Page 12
education information to be available and provide access to market information that can be utilized by rural farmers and commodity type businesses.35 Despite the value that virtue ethics brings to business ethics by focusing on both the actor and action, some issues arise when looking at specific business concerns such as the ethical concerns of a sweatshop. Tara J. Radin and Martin Calkins in their article entitled "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving towards Responsible Global Business" discussed some of the potential downfalls of Virtue Ethics when evaluating business practices such as ethical considerations in international manufacturing or outsourcing: While helpful in providing a mechanism for accounting for the broader impact of sweatshops on people, as individuals and as a group, and while facilitating an understanding of subjective differences and the reasons why people conclude one situation is a sweatshop and another is not, virtue ethics is deficient in a number of key areas and this inhibits virtue ethics from offering a comprehensive treatment of sweatshops. First, it fails to provide firm guidelines for consensus gathering and sanctioning wrong-doers. In addition, while the virtue of justice (an excellence of the soul that distributes to each according to his or her desert) motivates the individual to relate properly to others (and although modern virtue theories consider justice to be the preeminent ''social virtue''), without principles and laws to back it up, justice remains rather toothless and arbitrary. Finally, as a normative moral theory, virtue ethics espouses the development of subjective notions of character and recommends the individual strive toward an ambiguous final good end (telos) of happiness (eudaimo´nia). In doing so, virtue ethics has limited utility and appeal when dealing with international issues such as sweatshops, which bring in highly diverse viewpoints about character and the final end of happiness."36 In this example, it highlights that even virtue ethics along with the other normative theories has its faults. None of the theories are perfect and "?all of them appear vulnerable to manipulation and can be used almost as easily to defend sweatshops as to condemn them. As a result, part of the reason sweatshops continue to exist is that moral philosophy does not offer a robust and uniform argument against them."37 This is the problem of all the
35
David Lehr, Project Market Light (Pml) (Digital Vision Program at Stanford Univeristy, 2006 [cited February 17, 2007); available from http://rdvp.org/fellows/2005-2006/davidl36hr/.e Radin and Calkins, "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business," 264-5. 37 Ibid.: 265.
Page 13
normative business ethic models including virtue ethics viewed in the context of an ethical theory standing alone without a motivation besides rules developed within the model. However, the proposal of this paper considers virtue ethics as the tempering value that follows the motivation of a calling. In addition to motivation of calling and the temperance of virtue ethics the proposed ethical framework looks at justice in considering Indian identity, globalization as the "value" enabler of economic creation between trading nations, and the consideration of stakeholders as a community viewed through the virtue of charity. Within this framework it will help expand the "utility and appeal"38 of utilizing an ethical framework that is applied through the lens of virtue ethics. As Transporter uses the values of virtues to restrain business decisions it helps motivate questions such as: What will my factories working conditions be like? To answer the question first one must ask what is it to be charitable and just? Will I need to have safe working conditions? Justice would demand at least equality to other working standards in more developed countries. VI. Culture Context: Justice and Indian Identity Amartya Sen, The Indian Nobel Peace Prize winner in Economics describes, "attempts from outside India to understand and interpret the country's traditions can be put into at least three distinct categories?exoticist approaches, magisterial approaches and curatorial approaches."39 The first two relate to the imagination in the eyes of romanticism or imperial power.40 The latest is more of an objective observer approach to viewing India. 41 Sen concludes that the best approach to viewing India is to look at a threefold categorization of all three of exoticist, magisterial, and curatorial approaches. 42 All these approaches however, are from the West looking in on India. A MNC faces a tougher question and needs to develop a lens beyond what has happened in the past, whether it is through politics or
38 39
Ibid. Sen, The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity, 141. 40 Ibid., 141-2. 41 Ibid., 142. 42 Ibid.
Page 14
business ventures. Becoming part of the fabric of a country and embracing it from within is key with a healthy tension to the knowledge of the need to also identify with globalization. Friedman's concept of the local culture going global expresses this concept well in the statement: "It is the local which goes global."43 Within the Indian culture context a big concern is the issue of how the poor are affected. This has also been a concern to writers in the past on the negative affects of colonization and its lack of addressing the concerns of the poor at the time.44 Although the question of how to deal with the poor is a reality in most places, India's issue is troubling since the large amount of cash inflow has not necessarily helped the condition of its poor as can bee seen in malnutrition rates of children and other indicators.45 Along with the realities of the present, India's past can help contribute to the present discussion on business ethics. Kautilya's Arthashastra provides inspiration to ethics within India Business in the 4th century BC.46 His ethical based model for the organization touches on organizational structures, leadership requirements and even recommends a value based system similar to one proposed within modern virtue ethics or Aristotelian ethics.47 The Journal Humanomics expresses the almost prophetic nature of Kautilya's system: Not only the Socratic question was asked more than a thousand years earlier in India but also a comprehensive and consistent theory of attaining Moksha was developed, the virtues of truthfulness, compassion, tolerance and non-violence were identified and recommended, and elaborate rules were formulated to lead a virtuous life. Kautilya was way ahead of the Greeks and Adam Smith in offering both morality-based and legality-based approaches to ethics for resolving conflict of interest issues. Moreover, he believed that ethical values and prosperity were interdependent whereas the Greeks thought that prosperity was a threat to the ethical fabric of a society. Similarity, Kautilya recommends a proper mix of security,
43 44
Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century, 508. Simon Gikandi, "Preface: Modernism in the World," Modernism/Modernity 13, no. 3 (2006). 45 Somini Sengupta, "Even Amid Its Wealth, India Finds, Half Its Small Children Are Malnourished," New York Times, Feb 10 2007. 46 N. Siva Kumar and U. S. Rao, "Guidelines for Value Based Management in Kautilya's Arthashastra," Journal of Business Ethics 15, no. 4 (1996). 47 Ibid.
Page 15
servings and strings but above all, ethical grounding and moral incentives to elicit optimum effort.48 As Transporter conducts business within India, culture factors such as history, past abuses of foreign governments and companies, as well as local concerns such as the poor, need to be taken into consideration when formulating business decisions. Keeping the local perspective at the forefront of business decisions in light of the vastness of globalization is key when doing business with India or any country. Considering the values of the country will help Transporter be sensitive to the cultural context and history India posses. Business profit cannot override these factors and if culture and profit collides, Transporter needs to take a step back and work through the issues with dignity and respect of the Indian culture.
VII. "Value" Enabler: Driving Forward with Fortitude in Globalization "Outsourcing is not a good word to use anymore," says the CEO of JP Morgan Chase's India operation. The word creates fear and the charge that protectionism is needed whether in the US, Europe, or Japan. Those affected by the possibilities of outsourcing are rightly concerned. However, with the rise of globalization, it is no longer a question about outsourcing but how will specific countries compete in a "globalized" world. Globalization conjures up glimpses of what Adam Smith was writing about in his Wealth of Nations 300 years ago. He observed, "Scarce any nation has dealt equally and impartially with every sort of industry."49 Modern economics has proven that the trade of two nations or many nations of their expertise creates additional value beyond what already existed. The companies that will benefit the most are those that embrace globalization and redesign their business model to support it or those, such as Infosys, who have been "forced to be a flat world company
48
Balbir S. Sihag, "Kautilya on Ethics and Economics," Humanomics 21, no. 3/4 (2005): 14. 49 Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations (London: George Bell & Sons, 1892), 3.
Page 16
from the start."50 The Journal of Business Ethics proposes an approach to globalization via the concept of a Global Business Citizen (GBC): The GBC approach is a hybrid of these two strategic patterns that takes into account the fact that some situations require a company to take an absolute and uniform policy and other situations necessitate responsiveness and adaptability to local norms or contingencies. In addition, and importantly, GBC explicitly accommodates several levels of ''ethical certainty,'' or the degree to which norms and values match up with behaviors, practices, and customs in a particular locale or across sites.51 However, "?few topics are more intensely debated or generate more contrasting emotions than the merits and costs of globalization, particularly foreign direct investment (FDI) by multinational companies in emerging markets."52 A McKinsey Global Institute study showed a positive economic impact on multinationals when growing business in emerging countries. The study also shows that the local consumer won via better prices and improved living standards when global investment increased, although local companies have had issues.53 concludes: "Today there is a growing backlash against globalization and many observers question whether it has broadly alleviated poverty and increased standards of living. The evidence from our research clearly shows that it can. Rather than holding foreign direct investment at arm's length, developing nations would do better by embracing it and implementing sound policies to get the most from it." 54 The study
50 51
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. Jeanne M. Logsdon and Donna J. Wood, "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct," Journal of Business Ethics 59, no. 1-2 (2005): 58. 52 Diana Farrell, "The Case for Globalization," The International Economy 18, no. 1 (2004): 52. 53 Ibid. 54 Ibid.: 55.
Page 17
As MNCs increase investment inside these developing countries, they need to be careful not to repeat the failures of the past in other types of movements. Globalization is a value enabler that drives improvement in a country. At the same time, unconstrained globalization could be worse than other past movements. Ethical models AND market rules must restrain globalization in order to govern a more "compassionate capitalism." 55 This type of globalization will not only look at the profits it is generating but also will look at how it can make this profit ethically and at the same time give back to society. When this double bottom line is real, globalization can truly become a "value enabler" for both profits and social impact.
IX. Community Responsibility: Stakeholder Analysis & Synthesis with Considerations of Charity The focus of MNCs for cost cutting is something that needs to change as they consider all the key stakeholders. R. Edward Freeman, in the article entitled "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation" argued for defining the key stakeholders of the corporation as "suppliers, customer, employees, stockholders, and the local community, as well as management in its role as agent for these groups."56 Globalization has caused stakeholders to expand past the boundaries of traditional stakeholders especially since MNCs stretch again several countries and in a sense serve in a larger capacity of governance than some countries.
55
The "compassionate capitalism" discussion has been voiced within Catholic Social Thought in such documents as: "A Decade after Economic Justice for All: Continuing Principles, Changing Context, New Challenges," in National Conference of Catholic Bishops (1995). Other movements have started to address this new type of capitalism such as the Social Entrepreneurship movement in double bottom line ventures of profit and social impact. Many of these ventures are highlighted in a recent PBS program: Marion Rice, "The New Heros," (2006). 56 R. Edward Freeman, "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation," in Ethical Theory and Business, ed. Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie (Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004), 55.
Page 18
Globalization has resulted in more and more nations with diverse cultures and experiences participating in the global economy. It has also seen increased scrutiny of corporate behavior by the communities. Unethical behavior by individuals costs the organizations, stakeholders and society, billions of dollars, not withstanding the social cost of such actions. The rising numbers of corporate misconducts and failures in the recent past have further accentuated the need for a closer look at the issues of managerial ethics. Clearly managers are under increased pressure from stakeholders not only to outperform their competitors but also are expected to do so in an ethical manner.57 Although market dynamics drive business and can bankrupt the company, if the business is not careful, it should not be the sole driving force of decisions in business. Remembering stakeholders in context of the proposed ethical framework outlined will help keep the focus on good ethical decisions within a corporation. As globalization has arisen, more and more groups have started to state their opinion on this matter: Other stakeholders are asking for greater support of human rights, a higher concern for the natural environment, more genuine stakeholder dialogue, and more information about the decisions and impacts of organizations.58 The fictional company Transporter needs to clarify whom their stakeholders are and what concerns are pivotal in order to make sure that the company is moving in an ethical direction. The first sets of stakeholders in Transporter's business are the traditionally defined stakeholders of suppliers, stockholders, customer, employees, and the local community. When making decisions Transporter needs to ensure that all stakeholders are considered. However, three additional stakeholders need consideration by Transporter in the context of India and globalization. The first stakeholders are specifically defined as those at the bottom of the pyramid (BOP) as argued by C. K. Prahalad in his book The Fortune atthe Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits.59 The second group of stakeholders is the Indian companies that are Transporter's affected competition. The third
57
Manjit Monga, "Managers' Moral Reasoning: Evidence from Large Indian Manufacturing Organisations," Journal of Business Ethics 71, no. 2 (2007): 179. 58 Logsdon and Wood, "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct," 55. 59 C. K. Prahalad, The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits (Upper Saddle River: Wharton School Publishing, 2005).
Page 19
set of stakeholders is a subset of Transporters employees who are by shifts in work from one country or region to another. Along with the traditional stakeholders, in the context of India, Transporter needs to consider the BOP as a subset broken out from the local community. This does not just need to be in the context of monetary help for the BOP's needs but in looking for ways to limit their suffering as well as benefit Transporter in both social viewpoints as well as profit. This can be accomplished in many ways such as providing education to the poor to train workers in Transporter's factories. Transporter, as mentioned earlier, can design products,
especially cell phones, that help solved the needs of the poor at an affordable price and enable the BOP to benefit from products specifically designed for them and marketed to them. The second set of stakeholders that Transporter needs to review is its competition within India. The word competition is defined as stakeholders that are by the recruitment practices, hiring, and training competing for resources. Although not traditional defined as stakeholders, India companies are very important in this consideration since unethical practices against them could trigger a more protectionist response and appeal to the Indian government. Transporter should take care to explain its hiring practices, should view hiring in India as long-term investments in training, and not solved by a quick fix of pulling people from companies who have invested years in them. College recruitment and training of people who would not necessarily have the skill sets can help Transporter's reputation as caring for the community instead of only recruting employees by offering money incentives. This also can be accomplished by shifting senior leadership from other regions to establish and train a staff that is focused on a long-term perspective, as can be seen on the latest move from Cisco shifting 20% of its current executives to establish Bangalore as a globalization center.60 The third sets of stakeholders are the workers of Transporter affected by shifts in the business to new regions. As business shifts based on cost or market trends, globalization is
60
"Cisco Puts Executives in India," FinancialWire (2007).
Page 20
causing "the emergence of [a] completely new social, political, and business model." 61 Workers affected by layoffs or skill-set changes will face the global impact of the world were jobs can be done from almost anywhere without worrying about location. Transporter needs to view its employees as more than just resources and constantly consider the longterm benefits of firing in one region and hiring in a lower cost region. If job shifting is necessary, employees need treatment with respect and the focus of the company should be on retraining their employees for the next phase of skill-sets that will propel the company for the future. This will not only create loyalty of the employees to the company but will help Transporter nurture a reputation with host governments that it can be trusted. The case applies to both economically mature nations as well as India in the future. Transporter can break the trends and instill in the company a framework that helps the company maintain an ethical standard with it stakeholders. This should not only be talked about but MUST be lived out by its organizational leaders as well as engrained within it policies and processes. This action will ensure the organization itself has an ethical framework to guide the decision makers to first ask if they do not know how to make an ethical decisions and second nurture the virtues needed to ensure ethical business practices in India and the globalized world at large.
IX. Business Action: Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India The framework proposed in this paper is a holistic approach to large decision-making, as well as a process/policy guideline for operations. Wisdom of ones vocation or calling drives the motivation of the system to consider virtues that provide a grid in which to function. Virtue Ethics provide temperance to know if decisions are ethical and consider them in reflection to ones individual action as well as the results of the actions. Justice is reflected when considered in the Indian context in making decisions: honoring culture on one hand and being mindful of past exploitation to ensure it does not happen again. Fortitude drives a
61
Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century, 48.
Page 21
company
to
embrace
globalization as the business model of the future that will enable the world to experience economic prosperity like is has never known before in the past. The embracing of
globalization allows for the extension of the market to dominate transactions were
companies are responsible if un-ethical practice occurs. The key to tempering the market forces is by considering all stakeholders with charity, An Ethical Framework for Multinationals Conducting Business in India
including the poor, other India companies, and one's global workforce. This charity is not
in the context of a "free handout" but in an understanding that a business should not only make a profit but should also consider a double bottom line of social impact and improvement. Returning to Transporter, one last time: when applying this ethical model it provides a structure to answer questions that are beyond the mere yes or no. It will help Transporter forge forward in the new era of globalization while considering the local Indian perspective.
X. Future Trends& Implications: Globalization Ethic What are the future trends and implications of a new type of ethical framework? The first is that a company must embrace guidelines of some sort in order to avoid the potential
Page 22
pitfalls of recent and past companies. This model will not create a perfect framework but recreates the tools needed to counteract what MacIntyre laments "there seems to be no rational way of securing moral agreement in our culture."62 As India expands, a new ethical approach to globalization is critically necessary. This is especially true since India is a democratic and market driven economy and there is not an "artificial" moral guide (i.e. the government) that monitors one behavior not defined by the law.63 The model, although applied to the context of India, is applicable to future movement of MNC's business operations to new centers of business. There are limitations to any model or framework. A MNC must think through how the globalization ethic framework interlocks and entwines in the fabric of the companies' culture and applied through the policies and processes of their company to ensure ethical decisions and virtues are at the heart of the company. Organizational leaders must model this and hold their people to this standard in order to ensure a company can reflect true ethical virtues. The challenge is real and is necessary in order to temper the abuse of the past and forge ahead with a new globalization ethic64 modeled by MNCs in the new era of expansion into the India nation and into a new era of ethical companies.
62 63
MacIntyre, After Virtue, 6. "Europe: Do as I Say--or as I Do?; Charlemagne," The Economist 382, no. 8516 (2007). 64 Declaration toward a Global Ethic (Parliament of the World's Religion, 1993 [cited February 28, 2007); available from http://www.weltethos.org/dat_eng/index_e.htm. The concept of a Global Ethic was originally proposed by Hans Kung and the Parliament of the World's Religions for the focus on religious tolerance. This paper proposes using the concept and expanding it to the era of globalization, in addition to the rest of the proposed framework.
Page 23
XI. Bibliography "A Decade after Economic Justice for All: Continuing Principles, Changing Context, New Challenges." In National Conference of Catholic Bishops, 1995. Bardhan, Nilanjana, and Padmini Patwardhan. "Multinational Corporations and Public Relations in a Historically Resistant Host Culture." Review of Reviewed Item. Journal of Communication Management, no. 3 (2004). Bhukuth, Augendra, and JÈrÙme Ballet. "Is Child Labour a Substitute for Adult Labour?" International Journal of Social Economics 33, no. 8 (2006): 594. "Cisco Puts Executives in India." FinancialWire (2007): 1. Davis, Nancy. "Contemporary Deontology." In A Companion to Ethics, edited by Peter Singer. Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd., 1993. Declaration toward a Global Ethic. 1993. In, Parliament of the World's Religion, http://www.weltethos.org/dat_eng/index_e.htm. (accessed February 28, 2007. Ethical Theory and Business. Edited by Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004. "Europe: Do as I Say--or as I Do?; Charlemagne." The Economist 382, no. 8516 (2007): 46. Farrell, Diana. "The Case for Globalization." The International Economy 18, no. 1 (2004): 52. Freeman, R. Edward. "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation." In Ethical Theory and Business, edited by Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie, 55-74. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004. Friedman, Thomas L. The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century. New York: Farrar, Straus and Girox, 2006. Gikandi, Simon. "Preface: Modernism in the World." Modernism/Modernity 13, no. 3 (2006): 419. Hursthouse, Rosalind. "Normative Virtue Ethics." In Virtue Ethics, edited by Stephan Darwall. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003. ———. 2003. Virtue Ethics. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Metaphysics Research Lab, SDLI, Stanford University. (accessed February 12, 2007). "India Overheats." The Economist, February 3rd-9th 2007. "Infrastructure Needs Serious Attention in Tn." Businessline (2007): 1.
Page 24
Johnston, Payson. "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business." University of San Francisco, 2005. Knights, David, and Majella O'Leary. "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other." Journal of Business Ethics, no. 67 (2006): 125-37. Kumar, N. Siva, and U. S. Rao. "Guidelines for Value Based Management in Kautilya's Arthashastra." Journal of Business Ethics 15, no. 4 (1996): 415. Lehr, David. 2006. Project Market Light (Pml). In, Digital Vision Program at Stanford Univeristy, http://rdvp.org/fellows/2005-2006/david-lehr/. (accessed February 17, 2007. Logsdon, Jeanne M., and Donna J. Wood. "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct." Journal of Business Ethics 59, no. 1-2 (2005): 55. MacIntyre, Alasdair. After Virtue. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981. Miller, Alexander. An Introduction to Contemporary Metaethics. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2003. Monga, Manjit. "Managers' Moral Reasoning: Evidence from Large Indian Manufacturing Organisations." Journal of Business Ethics 71, no. 2 (2007): 179. Nair, Chandran. "Why Asia Must Look Beyond Profits to Ethics Chandran Nair." Financial Times, Sep 5 2005, 13. Prahalad, C. K. The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits. Upper Saddle River: Wharton School Publishing, 2005. "Public-Private Partnership Is the Way to Build Infrastructure." Businessline (2006): 1. Radin, Tara J., and Martin Calkins. "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business." Journal of Business Ethics, no. 66 (2006): 261-72. Rice, Marion. "The New Heros." 2006. Sen, Amartya. The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity. New York: Picador, 2005. Sengupta, Somini. "Even Amid Its Wealth, India Finds, Half Its Small Children Are Malnourished." New York Times, Feb 10 2007, 7. Sihag, Balbir S. "Kautilya on Ethics and Economics." Humanomics 21, no. 3/4 (2005): 1. Smith, Adam. Wealth of Nations. London: George Bell & Sons, 1892.
Page 25
Springer, Richard. "Maharashtra Cm Reassures Silicon Valley Entrepreneurs." India - West, Jul 1 2005, A1. "The Ethical Mind: A Conversation with Psychologist Howard Gardner." Harvard Business Review 85, no. 3 (2007): 51-6. University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. January 5 - January 20, 2007. Virtue Ethics. Edited by Stephen Darwall. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
doc_232993642.docx
Reports on Ethical Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India and a Proposal for a Globalization Ethic:- A multinational state is a sovereign state which is viewed as comprising two or more nations. Such a state contrasts with a nation-state where a single nation comprises the bulk of the population.
Reports on Ethical Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India and a Proposal for a Globalization Ethic
Executive Summary Multinationals have driven the rapid economic expansion of India at a breathtaking pace. At the same time, India's infrastructure has not kept up with demand, the poor are not able To tap into the economic influx and multinationals have raised locals concerns on what Ethical practices should be driven within the country. India's situation is different from past "outsourcing activity" with the rise of globalization and makes the questions bigger. How multinationals conduct business within India and what should does an ethical framework look like specifically within India and in light of the changes caused by globalization? This paper will look at a proposal for an ethical framework for multinationals doing business in India and will propose a need to inquire and put in place a globalization ethic that will serve today's new business climate. Beyond the normative business ethics of utilitarianism and Kant's theory of the categorical imperative the ethical model of virtue ethics will be applied through the lens of a vocational metaethic. The new ethical framework will also apply Indian tradition in the context of present and past reflection to strive for Justice in the new expansion of India. An additional framework of the ethical model is globalization to ensure that business strives forward but at the same time considers the realities of the market situation. To complete the ethical model the paper analyzes key stakeholders in Indian business, beyond the traditional stakeholders, to give multinationals a framework to weave within the fabric of their organization and help put in place policies and process that reflect the ethical model. The fictional company Transporter, a creator and manufacture of cell phones, provides a "case study" of how the ethical model can take shape within a multinational complex situation in doing business in India.
Page 3
I. Introduction The world is truly flat proclaims the now famous "short" history of the 21st century that explores the new trends and reality of globalization.1 Companies all over India echo the sentiment of a "flat world" and talk about the changes it is making on both Indian and multinationals companies and the larger society. As more and more business flows into India, multinational companies (MNC) need to take a step back and analyze the best way to approach business in a country that has in the past been exploited by outsiders 2 and is cautiously drinking the kool-aid of money as it flows into a country that is bursting from expansion. At the same time that a new generation of entrepreneurial talent has been unleashed,3 "infrastructure, such as roads and power, and public services, such as education and drinking water, are woefully inadequate and limit growth."4 The latest issue of The Economist mentions "it seems incongruous that somebody can own a mobile phone, yet has to waste hours queuing in line for drinking water."5 The chairman of the Confederation of Indian Industries Banmali Agarwala, " ?in [a] answer to a question about business ethics and [the] fact that some CEOs in the U.S. face criminal and civil charges, said Maharashtra is developing a 'code of conduct' in partnership with industry leaders. Whatever framework is developed 'has to be for the public good.'"6 The proposal of an ethical framework is critical to ensuring the continued expansion of multinationals into India's vast potential market. This project will analyze the implications of doing business in India from the perspective of a multinational that needs to grow a market, outsource work, and help a country continue to develop India's infrastructure. First, it will look at how MNCs and Indian companies have
1
Thomas L. Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century (New York: Farrar, Straus and Girox, 2006), 7. 2 Amartya Sen, The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity (New York: Picador, 2005), 139. 3 "India Overheats," The Economist, February 3rd-9th 2007, 11. 4 Ibid. 5 Ibid. 6 Richard Springer, "Maharashtra Cm Reassures Silicon Valley Entrepreneurs," India West, Jul 1 2005.
Page 4
approached doing business in India over the last few years. Next, the paper will look at journal articles on business ethics in order to look at ethical approaches to conducting business. This information will help identify the stakeholders within India that are the MNC responsibility to treat with respect. When the analysis/synthesis is complete, it will help to define the framework of an ethical model in which MNCs can utilize when doing business in India. India also provides a live "case study" in which to develop an ethical model for the future of globalization. The unique situation of India is the experiencing urbanization in a large scale in the era of globalization verse urbanization that happened during the industrial revolution.7 Theshift calls for an urgent re-evaluation of the today's normative business models to embrace and include the larger factors of globalization and multiple stakeholders affected in today's business environment. It should not be about the "haves and have nots" but should be about making profits in an ethical manner that also values contributing to the common good and social well-being of the world.
II. Current Company Practices in India: Insights from the University of San Francisco Study Tour India's business practice has had different effects over the years on Indian business norms. India has experienced everything from the Great Indian Peninsular Railway Campaign in England during the colonial period to current MNCs in today's period of globalization.8 The globalization affects on India are noticeable through the growth within the country and the attitude of today's business both local and foreign. On the University of San Francisco's India Study Tour, the class was able to hear from many voices throughout many different industries in India focusing mainly in the Bangalore area. Companies as well as non-profits visited by the class included: Infosys, JP Morgan Chase, NEXT, Toyota, TIE Bangalore,
7 8
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India, January 5 - January 20, 2007. Nilanjana Bardhan and Padmini Patwardhan, "Multinational Corporations and Public Relations in a Historically Resistant Host Culture," review of Reviewed Item, Journal of Communication Management, no. 3 (2004).
Page 5
Wipro, The Prem Jen Foundation, Cisco, an SOS Children's Village.9 The trip revealed many management practices both good and bad as well as the direction of companies in the future. An issue that was brought up at the TIE Bangalore visit was MNCs currently are focused on increasing profits since a big trend has been outsourcing for lower wages instead of focusing on the community where its business resides.10 Not all businesses are focused on only profits as can be seen by the examples of WiPro with the Prem Jen Foundation for helping schools and Cisco's eGovernance and Networking Academy initiatives. However, even with the inflow of investment, India's poor is still a real and extremely visible problem. During the trip, additional issues/problems bubbled to the forefront as themes facing both national and MNCs. The first theme was around the education and retention of employees in a highly competitive culture. Companies in India face very high demand for recent graduates and skilled workers from both internally and externally (countries such as the US and the EU), driven by the advances of globalization. Although India has 350,000 engineering graduates, each year supply has not keep up with demand. WiPro offers its employees the Wipro University and employs over 100 professors to ensure employees are equipped. Workers loyalty to companies is low especially when a competing firm can offer 50% increases in salary. This practice has created quite a situation in which MNCs that want to establish operations quickly recruit from Indian companies who have invested years of training and education on an employee. The practice has raised the eyebrows of wellrespected Indian business men and women who have pointed to a management problem and an ethical problem. Another theme that was prominent in discussions with many of the businesses within Bangalore was the topic of infrastructure. Cities such as Bangalore and Chennai are "creaking at its seams."11 Companies have created large-scale corporate campuses that are
9
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. 10 Ibid. TIE Bangalore, Jan 15, 2007 11 "Infrastructure Needs Serious Attention in Tn," Businessline (2007).
Page 6
essentially islands. These "islands" consist of their own power, infrastructure, food service etc. while the surrounding city overflows with traffic, housing, people, and in some cases requiring the poor to relocate. Companies at the same time have brought an immense amount good to India, especially in the form of monetary benefit. However, the infrastructure needs of the country cannot go without notice and private industry needs to be part of the solution rather than just seen as the problem.12 As I start to formulate the ethical framework for MNCs doing business in India, I will use a fictional company named Transporter, their business model being the creation of software and hardware for the cell phone industry. Their goal is to provide a low cost handset for emerging markets as well as penetrate more developed markets in the future with a low cost operation model. The company's revenues are currently at $1 billion dollars and they have made healthy profits in developing software that is in most of the world's cell phones. The headquarters of the company is in Canada and the company is on the NASDAQ under the symbol TRPT. Although they are currently in several countries including most of the
European countries as well as China and South Korea they have decided to make a huge push in their strategy to both manufacture in India and engage the ever growing Indian cell phone industry. As the ethical framework develops in this paper, Transporter will allow us to provide examples and nuances that would otherwise be lost if the concepts were strictly discussed in the abstract. First, we will look at developing an ethical framework/model for MNCs conducting business within India.
III. Developing an Ethical Framework "Many multinationals see Asia as a source of opportunity, but it will also give them their greatest challenges in business ethics and corporate social responsibility."13 One of the issues that companies face is what ethical model to use within the business operations. In the past, business ethics discussions centered on two normative approaches to making
12 13
"Public-Private Partnership Is the Way to Build Infrastructure," Businessline (2006). Chandran Nair, "Why Asia Must Look Beyond Profits to Ethics Chandran Nair," Financial Times, Sep 5 2005.
Page 7
ethical decisions in business in the older ethical models of deontology and teleology. Deontology is the belief "?that there are certain sorts of acts that are wrong in themselves, and thus morally unacceptable means to the pursuit of any ends, even ends that are morally admirable, or morally obligatory."14 Kant expressed a derivative of this view in the language of acts.15 Although at first glance this position seems to be a very moral position, it fails to take into account consequences of decisions especially when the decisions are in grey areas of large and complex business problems that do not have a clear right or wrong attached to them. These decisions however could materialize in grave ethical issues if the outcomes are not considered. In an article from The Journal of Business Ethics on the ethical implications of sweatshops, it is concluded that deontology falls short for offering a solution for this very big problem. The article concludes: "Deontology thus fails to offer adequate assistance in enabling individuals to contextualize their decision-making within a range of norms and the parameters of foreseeable consequences."16 Teleology, also known as utilitarianism only focuses on the ultimate outcome and the greatest utility. The philosopher Macintyre "?rejects the enlightenment view of ethics as rational action based on duty or rules (deontological), or the greatest happiness for the largest number (utilitarianism or consequentialism)."17Both normative views are lacking a complete picture of ethical decision-making. A motivation beyond utility and defining attention to character is needed to move past the current stalemates and to move into a model that will help businesses make ethical decisions that are embedded within the fabric of the organization and its people in light of new era of globalization.
14
Nancy Davis, "Contemporary Deontology," in A Companion to Ethics, ed. Peter Singer, Blackwell Companions to Philosophy (Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd., 1993), 205. 15 Ethical Theory and Business, ed. Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie (Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004), 25. 16 Tara J. Radin and Martin Calkins, "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business," Journal of Business Ethics, no. 66 (2006): 264. 17 David Knights and Majella O'Leary, "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other," Journal of Business Ethics, no. 67 (2006): 132.
Page 8
IV. A Vocational "Calling" Metaethic: Wisdom Lessons in Motivation In setting out to define an ethical model, I want to first define the source of inspiration when applying normative ethical approaches to business. Without a source of inspiration or motivation, it is hard to argue for a need for an ethical model beyond legal or profitable concerns. A source of motivation will help provide a reason for performing within an ethical model. The motivation to the framework I am proposing is a metaethic of "calling" or viewing your role in society as a vocation, similar to a profession of a doctor or priest who are both called into actions beyond their own personal gain. A business leader within the organization needs a purpose beyond their work environment that drives them to make ethical decisions or even apply an ethical model.18 Without this motivation or reason why would a business leader want to make good decisions beyond those that would benefit the company's profits? This especially becomes a concern in areas that are not legally binding and fall into seemly grey areas that without an ethical model would drive profits to rule out ethical decisions. These "grey" areas are important because the decisions made within this area can move companies to large-scale unethical behavior and practice, especially in countries that do not have clearly defined laws (i.e. child labor practices within India).19 The question arises on how the first step of the framework will help the fictional company Transporter in its operations within India. The metaethic concept, defined as questions on the meaning of ethics, or "what they are doing when they talk about what they do"20 helps ensure one is really looking at the motivation behind an ethical act or acts. Transporter first needs to have a reason to do an ethical act. Is it purely legal? On the other hand, are business actions motivated by a sense of higher purpose? The concept of calling or vocation gives a motivation that one's purpose as a business and organizational leader is to "?hold
18
Payson Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business," (University of San Francisco, 2005). 19 Augendra Bhukuth and JÈrÙme Ballet, "Is Child Labour a Substitute for Adult Labour?," International Journal of Social Economics 33, no. 8 (2006). 20 Alexander Miller, An Introduction to Contemporary Metaethics (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2003), 2-3.
Page 9
resources, people and capital in trust for many and it is essential that their guiding principles for such stewardship transcend the instrumental and narrowly parochial concerns of their professional positions and practices."21 Unfortunately, in today's business environment organizational leadership does not yet have the respect of a true profession or vocation even though organizations have a large affect on the morals of people and the society.22 This is a key area in the realm of business that needs to change in order to build a more robust framework for ethical decisions. By Transporter applying the concept of vocation as the motivation for the ethical model, it helps provide the motivation for acting ethically beyond the law or solely profits. It helps the leader regard business management in terms of stewardship and stakeholders. Moreover, it moves the motivation beyond any individual person's self gain to something that provides a societal purpose of improvement of the common good. If Transporter's employees embrace the concept of vocational decision making the motivation of thecompany will be ensuring the welfare of all involved. Society and India will be better for this since business leaders are now "social roles, which provide a culture with its moral definitions."23
V. Values: Tempering the Market with Virtue Ethics The normative ethical theory of virtue ethics is the second step within the framework of the proposed business model. This theory is ?"an alternative to the main deontological and consequentialist traditions in modern moral"24 thought and "challenges the autonomous
21
Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach
t22 Business," 10. o "The Ethical Mind: A Conversation with Psychologist Howard Gardner," Harvard Business Review 85, no. 3 (2007): 53. 23 Alasdair MacIntyre, After Virtue (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981), 31. 24 Virtue Ethics, ed. Stephen Darwall (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003), From the Back Cover.
Page 10
self."25 It is "?argued that the recent corporate scandals could be seen as resulting from ethical failures arising from contemporary concerns with material and symbolic success, which reside in an ultimate pre-occupation with the self."26 In contrast to the other normative theories, virtue ethics provides a balance of individual actions with understanding and looking at the ultimate consequences. It aligns more closely with the value-based system of India, explored later. A recent article in the Journal of Business Ethics discusses why virtue ethics can help in business decisions where other normative theories fail: "?our sympathy towards virtue ethics resides in a view of the telos or moral project outlined by MacIntyre as a perfect accompaniment to Levinas's responsibility to the Other. An ethic of responsibility moves us away from a preoccupation with the self towards an indeclinable and unlimited responsibility to the Other, experienced in the face-to-face interaction and driven by an inexhaustive care. In-keeping with the constructionist approach, which we endorse, leadership here is interpretation of the Other and the self in the face-to-face interaction."27 Virtue Ethics is "agent-centered" as compared to other normative business ethics are theories that tend to be "act-centered."28 The system has several principles. The first principle is because "I acknowledge I am far from perfect?I need to ask for advice from someone who knows."29 The second principle is that of "?virtue generate a prescription act honestly, charitably, unjustly - but each vice a prohibition - do not act dishonestly, uncharitably, unjustly."30 This version of ethics "?has always emphasized the importance of moral education, not as the inculcation of rules but as the training of character."31 Instead of just a series of rules, the overall character of the individual is the key concern. One of the potential issue of virtue ethics is that there has not been enough written about applying it to
25 26
Knights and O'Leary, "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other," 134. Ibid. 27 Ibid. 28 Rosalind Hursthouse, "Normative Virtue Ethics," in Virtue Ethics, ed. Stephan Darwall (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003), 185. 29 Ibid., 189. 30 Ibid., 190. 31 Rosalind Hursthouse, Virtue Ethics (Metaphysics Research Lab, SDLI, Stanford University, 2003 [cited February 12 2007]).
Page 11
business ethics since it has been newly re-discovered in the last twenty years. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy highlights why there has been a lack of writings of virtue theory textbooks on ethical theories: Textbooks "?now try to include articles representative of each of the three normative approaches but are often unable to find any virtue ethics article addressing a particular issue. This is sometimes, no doubt, because "the" issue has been set up as a deontologicial/utilitarian debate, but it is often simply because no virtue ethicist has yet written on the topic. However, this area can certainly be expected to grow in the future."32 For purposes of this discussion I will only mention five virtues that can be applied to the context of Transporter when doing business in India: Justice, which was praised by Aristotle as the "first virtue of political life."33 Wisdom is the virtue that helps in identifying stakeholders. Fortitude, the driving force to move forward with courage. Temperance, the virtue of restraining from excess and the love of extremes in decisions and tames the forces of the drive for profit. Charity, which shows compassion on all stakeholders involved.34 How can Transporter express these virtues within the context of business decision? One example is through the virtue of justice. Transporter can apply the virtue principle of "justice" in the view of both the past and present situations in terms of righting wrongs that were committed in the past through exploitation. An example of utilizing the virtue of justice is through the modern day practice of multinationals developing product that are geared towards the poor in quantities and prices they can afford. This allows the poor to contribute in the market that traditionally was not available. At the same time, it allows some of the basics of life to become available. Transporter's vision of a low cost cell phone for all economic levels can help start to provide access to communications, enable
32 33
Ibid. MacIntyre, After Virtue, 244. 34 Johnston, "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business," 21.
Page 12
education information to be available and provide access to market information that can be utilized by rural farmers and commodity type businesses.35 Despite the value that virtue ethics brings to business ethics by focusing on both the actor and action, some issues arise when looking at specific business concerns such as the ethical concerns of a sweatshop. Tara J. Radin and Martin Calkins in their article entitled "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving towards Responsible Global Business" discussed some of the potential downfalls of Virtue Ethics when evaluating business practices such as ethical considerations in international manufacturing or outsourcing: While helpful in providing a mechanism for accounting for the broader impact of sweatshops on people, as individuals and as a group, and while facilitating an understanding of subjective differences and the reasons why people conclude one situation is a sweatshop and another is not, virtue ethics is deficient in a number of key areas and this inhibits virtue ethics from offering a comprehensive treatment of sweatshops. First, it fails to provide firm guidelines for consensus gathering and sanctioning wrong-doers. In addition, while the virtue of justice (an excellence of the soul that distributes to each according to his or her desert) motivates the individual to relate properly to others (and although modern virtue theories consider justice to be the preeminent ''social virtue''), without principles and laws to back it up, justice remains rather toothless and arbitrary. Finally, as a normative moral theory, virtue ethics espouses the development of subjective notions of character and recommends the individual strive toward an ambiguous final good end (telos) of happiness (eudaimo´nia). In doing so, virtue ethics has limited utility and appeal when dealing with international issues such as sweatshops, which bring in highly diverse viewpoints about character and the final end of happiness."36 In this example, it highlights that even virtue ethics along with the other normative theories has its faults. None of the theories are perfect and "?all of them appear vulnerable to manipulation and can be used almost as easily to defend sweatshops as to condemn them. As a result, part of the reason sweatshops continue to exist is that moral philosophy does not offer a robust and uniform argument against them."37 This is the problem of all the
35
David Lehr, Project Market Light (Pml) (Digital Vision Program at Stanford Univeristy, 2006 [cited February 17, 2007); available from http://rdvp.org/fellows/2005-2006/davidl36hr/.e Radin and Calkins, "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business," 264-5. 37 Ibid.: 265.
Page 13
normative business ethic models including virtue ethics viewed in the context of an ethical theory standing alone without a motivation besides rules developed within the model. However, the proposal of this paper considers virtue ethics as the tempering value that follows the motivation of a calling. In addition to motivation of calling and the temperance of virtue ethics the proposed ethical framework looks at justice in considering Indian identity, globalization as the "value" enabler of economic creation between trading nations, and the consideration of stakeholders as a community viewed through the virtue of charity. Within this framework it will help expand the "utility and appeal"38 of utilizing an ethical framework that is applied through the lens of virtue ethics. As Transporter uses the values of virtues to restrain business decisions it helps motivate questions such as: What will my factories working conditions be like? To answer the question first one must ask what is it to be charitable and just? Will I need to have safe working conditions? Justice would demand at least equality to other working standards in more developed countries. VI. Culture Context: Justice and Indian Identity Amartya Sen, The Indian Nobel Peace Prize winner in Economics describes, "attempts from outside India to understand and interpret the country's traditions can be put into at least three distinct categories?exoticist approaches, magisterial approaches and curatorial approaches."39 The first two relate to the imagination in the eyes of romanticism or imperial power.40 The latest is more of an objective observer approach to viewing India. 41 Sen concludes that the best approach to viewing India is to look at a threefold categorization of all three of exoticist, magisterial, and curatorial approaches. 42 All these approaches however, are from the West looking in on India. A MNC faces a tougher question and needs to develop a lens beyond what has happened in the past, whether it is through politics or
38 39
Ibid. Sen, The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity, 141. 40 Ibid., 141-2. 41 Ibid., 142. 42 Ibid.
Page 14
business ventures. Becoming part of the fabric of a country and embracing it from within is key with a healthy tension to the knowledge of the need to also identify with globalization. Friedman's concept of the local culture going global expresses this concept well in the statement: "It is the local which goes global."43 Within the Indian culture context a big concern is the issue of how the poor are affected. This has also been a concern to writers in the past on the negative affects of colonization and its lack of addressing the concerns of the poor at the time.44 Although the question of how to deal with the poor is a reality in most places, India's issue is troubling since the large amount of cash inflow has not necessarily helped the condition of its poor as can bee seen in malnutrition rates of children and other indicators.45 Along with the realities of the present, India's past can help contribute to the present discussion on business ethics. Kautilya's Arthashastra provides inspiration to ethics within India Business in the 4th century BC.46 His ethical based model for the organization touches on organizational structures, leadership requirements and even recommends a value based system similar to one proposed within modern virtue ethics or Aristotelian ethics.47 The Journal Humanomics expresses the almost prophetic nature of Kautilya's system: Not only the Socratic question was asked more than a thousand years earlier in India but also a comprehensive and consistent theory of attaining Moksha was developed, the virtues of truthfulness, compassion, tolerance and non-violence were identified and recommended, and elaborate rules were formulated to lead a virtuous life. Kautilya was way ahead of the Greeks and Adam Smith in offering both morality-based and legality-based approaches to ethics for resolving conflict of interest issues. Moreover, he believed that ethical values and prosperity were interdependent whereas the Greeks thought that prosperity was a threat to the ethical fabric of a society. Similarity, Kautilya recommends a proper mix of security,
43 44
Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century, 508. Simon Gikandi, "Preface: Modernism in the World," Modernism/Modernity 13, no. 3 (2006). 45 Somini Sengupta, "Even Amid Its Wealth, India Finds, Half Its Small Children Are Malnourished," New York Times, Feb 10 2007. 46 N. Siva Kumar and U. S. Rao, "Guidelines for Value Based Management in Kautilya's Arthashastra," Journal of Business Ethics 15, no. 4 (1996). 47 Ibid.
Page 15
servings and strings but above all, ethical grounding and moral incentives to elicit optimum effort.48 As Transporter conducts business within India, culture factors such as history, past abuses of foreign governments and companies, as well as local concerns such as the poor, need to be taken into consideration when formulating business decisions. Keeping the local perspective at the forefront of business decisions in light of the vastness of globalization is key when doing business with India or any country. Considering the values of the country will help Transporter be sensitive to the cultural context and history India posses. Business profit cannot override these factors and if culture and profit collides, Transporter needs to take a step back and work through the issues with dignity and respect of the Indian culture.
VII. "Value" Enabler: Driving Forward with Fortitude in Globalization "Outsourcing is not a good word to use anymore," says the CEO of JP Morgan Chase's India operation. The word creates fear and the charge that protectionism is needed whether in the US, Europe, or Japan. Those affected by the possibilities of outsourcing are rightly concerned. However, with the rise of globalization, it is no longer a question about outsourcing but how will specific countries compete in a "globalized" world. Globalization conjures up glimpses of what Adam Smith was writing about in his Wealth of Nations 300 years ago. He observed, "Scarce any nation has dealt equally and impartially with every sort of industry."49 Modern economics has proven that the trade of two nations or many nations of their expertise creates additional value beyond what already existed. The companies that will benefit the most are those that embrace globalization and redesign their business model to support it or those, such as Infosys, who have been "forced to be a flat world company
48
Balbir S. Sihag, "Kautilya on Ethics and Economics," Humanomics 21, no. 3/4 (2005): 14. 49 Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations (London: George Bell & Sons, 1892), 3.
Page 16
from the start."50 The Journal of Business Ethics proposes an approach to globalization via the concept of a Global Business Citizen (GBC): The GBC approach is a hybrid of these two strategic patterns that takes into account the fact that some situations require a company to take an absolute and uniform policy and other situations necessitate responsiveness and adaptability to local norms or contingencies. In addition, and importantly, GBC explicitly accommodates several levels of ''ethical certainty,'' or the degree to which norms and values match up with behaviors, practices, and customs in a particular locale or across sites.51 However, "?few topics are more intensely debated or generate more contrasting emotions than the merits and costs of globalization, particularly foreign direct investment (FDI) by multinational companies in emerging markets."52 A McKinsey Global Institute study showed a positive economic impact on multinationals when growing business in emerging countries. The study also shows that the local consumer won via better prices and improved living standards when global investment increased, although local companies have had issues.53 concludes: "Today there is a growing backlash against globalization and many observers question whether it has broadly alleviated poverty and increased standards of living. The evidence from our research clearly shows that it can. Rather than holding foreign direct investment at arm's length, developing nations would do better by embracing it and implementing sound policies to get the most from it." 54 The study
50 51
University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. Jeanne M. Logsdon and Donna J. Wood, "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct," Journal of Business Ethics 59, no. 1-2 (2005): 58. 52 Diana Farrell, "The Case for Globalization," The International Economy 18, no. 1 (2004): 52. 53 Ibid. 54 Ibid.: 55.
Page 17
As MNCs increase investment inside these developing countries, they need to be careful not to repeat the failures of the past in other types of movements. Globalization is a value enabler that drives improvement in a country. At the same time, unconstrained globalization could be worse than other past movements. Ethical models AND market rules must restrain globalization in order to govern a more "compassionate capitalism." 55 This type of globalization will not only look at the profits it is generating but also will look at how it can make this profit ethically and at the same time give back to society. When this double bottom line is real, globalization can truly become a "value enabler" for both profits and social impact.
IX. Community Responsibility: Stakeholder Analysis & Synthesis with Considerations of Charity The focus of MNCs for cost cutting is something that needs to change as they consider all the key stakeholders. R. Edward Freeman, in the article entitled "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation" argued for defining the key stakeholders of the corporation as "suppliers, customer, employees, stockholders, and the local community, as well as management in its role as agent for these groups."56 Globalization has caused stakeholders to expand past the boundaries of traditional stakeholders especially since MNCs stretch again several countries and in a sense serve in a larger capacity of governance than some countries.
55
The "compassionate capitalism" discussion has been voiced within Catholic Social Thought in such documents as: "A Decade after Economic Justice for All: Continuing Principles, Changing Context, New Challenges," in National Conference of Catholic Bishops (1995). Other movements have started to address this new type of capitalism such as the Social Entrepreneurship movement in double bottom line ventures of profit and social impact. Many of these ventures are highlighted in a recent PBS program: Marion Rice, "The New Heros," (2006). 56 R. Edward Freeman, "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation," in Ethical Theory and Business, ed. Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie (Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004), 55.
Page 18
Globalization has resulted in more and more nations with diverse cultures and experiences participating in the global economy. It has also seen increased scrutiny of corporate behavior by the communities. Unethical behavior by individuals costs the organizations, stakeholders and society, billions of dollars, not withstanding the social cost of such actions. The rising numbers of corporate misconducts and failures in the recent past have further accentuated the need for a closer look at the issues of managerial ethics. Clearly managers are under increased pressure from stakeholders not only to outperform their competitors but also are expected to do so in an ethical manner.57 Although market dynamics drive business and can bankrupt the company, if the business is not careful, it should not be the sole driving force of decisions in business. Remembering stakeholders in context of the proposed ethical framework outlined will help keep the focus on good ethical decisions within a corporation. As globalization has arisen, more and more groups have started to state their opinion on this matter: Other stakeholders are asking for greater support of human rights, a higher concern for the natural environment, more genuine stakeholder dialogue, and more information about the decisions and impacts of organizations.58 The fictional company Transporter needs to clarify whom their stakeholders are and what concerns are pivotal in order to make sure that the company is moving in an ethical direction. The first sets of stakeholders in Transporter's business are the traditionally defined stakeholders of suppliers, stockholders, customer, employees, and the local community. When making decisions Transporter needs to ensure that all stakeholders are considered. However, three additional stakeholders need consideration by Transporter in the context of India and globalization. The first stakeholders are specifically defined as those at the bottom of the pyramid (BOP) as argued by C. K. Prahalad in his book The Fortune atthe Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits.59 The second group of stakeholders is the Indian companies that are Transporter's affected competition. The third
57
Manjit Monga, "Managers' Moral Reasoning: Evidence from Large Indian Manufacturing Organisations," Journal of Business Ethics 71, no. 2 (2007): 179. 58 Logsdon and Wood, "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct," 55. 59 C. K. Prahalad, The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits (Upper Saddle River: Wharton School Publishing, 2005).
Page 19
set of stakeholders is a subset of Transporters employees who are by shifts in work from one country or region to another. Along with the traditional stakeholders, in the context of India, Transporter needs to consider the BOP as a subset broken out from the local community. This does not just need to be in the context of monetary help for the BOP's needs but in looking for ways to limit their suffering as well as benefit Transporter in both social viewpoints as well as profit. This can be accomplished in many ways such as providing education to the poor to train workers in Transporter's factories. Transporter, as mentioned earlier, can design products,
especially cell phones, that help solved the needs of the poor at an affordable price and enable the BOP to benefit from products specifically designed for them and marketed to them. The second set of stakeholders that Transporter needs to review is its competition within India. The word competition is defined as stakeholders that are by the recruitment practices, hiring, and training competing for resources. Although not traditional defined as stakeholders, India companies are very important in this consideration since unethical practices against them could trigger a more protectionist response and appeal to the Indian government. Transporter should take care to explain its hiring practices, should view hiring in India as long-term investments in training, and not solved by a quick fix of pulling people from companies who have invested years in them. College recruitment and training of people who would not necessarily have the skill sets can help Transporter's reputation as caring for the community instead of only recruting employees by offering money incentives. This also can be accomplished by shifting senior leadership from other regions to establish and train a staff that is focused on a long-term perspective, as can be seen on the latest move from Cisco shifting 20% of its current executives to establish Bangalore as a globalization center.60 The third sets of stakeholders are the workers of Transporter affected by shifts in the business to new regions. As business shifts based on cost or market trends, globalization is
60
"Cisco Puts Executives in India," FinancialWire (2007).
Page 20
causing "the emergence of [a] completely new social, political, and business model." 61 Workers affected by layoffs or skill-set changes will face the global impact of the world were jobs can be done from almost anywhere without worrying about location. Transporter needs to view its employees as more than just resources and constantly consider the longterm benefits of firing in one region and hiring in a lower cost region. If job shifting is necessary, employees need treatment with respect and the focus of the company should be on retraining their employees for the next phase of skill-sets that will propel the company for the future. This will not only create loyalty of the employees to the company but will help Transporter nurture a reputation with host governments that it can be trusted. The case applies to both economically mature nations as well as India in the future. Transporter can break the trends and instill in the company a framework that helps the company maintain an ethical standard with it stakeholders. This should not only be talked about but MUST be lived out by its organizational leaders as well as engrained within it policies and processes. This action will ensure the organization itself has an ethical framework to guide the decision makers to first ask if they do not know how to make an ethical decisions and second nurture the virtues needed to ensure ethical business practices in India and the globalized world at large.
IX. Business Action: Framework for Multinationals Doing Business in India The framework proposed in this paper is a holistic approach to large decision-making, as well as a process/policy guideline for operations. Wisdom of ones vocation or calling drives the motivation of the system to consider virtues that provide a grid in which to function. Virtue Ethics provide temperance to know if decisions are ethical and consider them in reflection to ones individual action as well as the results of the actions. Justice is reflected when considered in the Indian context in making decisions: honoring culture on one hand and being mindful of past exploitation to ensure it does not happen again. Fortitude drives a
61
Friedman, The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century, 48.
Page 21
company
to
embrace
globalization as the business model of the future that will enable the world to experience economic prosperity like is has never known before in the past. The embracing of
globalization allows for the extension of the market to dominate transactions were
companies are responsible if un-ethical practice occurs. The key to tempering the market forces is by considering all stakeholders with charity, An Ethical Framework for Multinationals Conducting Business in India
including the poor, other India companies, and one's global workforce. This charity is not
in the context of a "free handout" but in an understanding that a business should not only make a profit but should also consider a double bottom line of social impact and improvement. Returning to Transporter, one last time: when applying this ethical model it provides a structure to answer questions that are beyond the mere yes or no. It will help Transporter forge forward in the new era of globalization while considering the local Indian perspective.
X. Future Trends& Implications: Globalization Ethic What are the future trends and implications of a new type of ethical framework? The first is that a company must embrace guidelines of some sort in order to avoid the potential
Page 22
pitfalls of recent and past companies. This model will not create a perfect framework but recreates the tools needed to counteract what MacIntyre laments "there seems to be no rational way of securing moral agreement in our culture."62 As India expands, a new ethical approach to globalization is critically necessary. This is especially true since India is a democratic and market driven economy and there is not an "artificial" moral guide (i.e. the government) that monitors one behavior not defined by the law.63 The model, although applied to the context of India, is applicable to future movement of MNC's business operations to new centers of business. There are limitations to any model or framework. A MNC must think through how the globalization ethic framework interlocks and entwines in the fabric of the companies' culture and applied through the policies and processes of their company to ensure ethical decisions and virtues are at the heart of the company. Organizational leaders must model this and hold their people to this standard in order to ensure a company can reflect true ethical virtues. The challenge is real and is necessary in order to temper the abuse of the past and forge ahead with a new globalization ethic64 modeled by MNCs in the new era of expansion into the India nation and into a new era of ethical companies.
62 63
MacIntyre, After Virtue, 6. "Europe: Do as I Say--or as I Do?; Charlemagne," The Economist 382, no. 8516 (2007). 64 Declaration toward a Global Ethic (Parliament of the World's Religion, 1993 [cited February 28, 2007); available from http://www.weltethos.org/dat_eng/index_e.htm. The concept of a Global Ethic was originally proposed by Hans Kung and the Parliament of the World's Religions for the focus on religious tolerance. This paper proposes using the concept and expanding it to the era of globalization, in addition to the rest of the proposed framework.
Page 23
XI. Bibliography "A Decade after Economic Justice for All: Continuing Principles, Changing Context, New Challenges." In National Conference of Catholic Bishops, 1995. Bardhan, Nilanjana, and Padmini Patwardhan. "Multinational Corporations and Public Relations in a Historically Resistant Host Culture." Review of Reviewed Item. Journal of Communication Management, no. 3 (2004). Bhukuth, Augendra, and JÈrÙme Ballet. "Is Child Labour a Substitute for Adult Labour?" International Journal of Social Economics 33, no. 8 (2006): 594. "Cisco Puts Executives in India." FinancialWire (2007): 1. Davis, Nancy. "Contemporary Deontology." In A Companion to Ethics, edited by Peter Singer. Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd., 1993. Declaration toward a Global Ethic. 1993. In, Parliament of the World's Religion, http://www.weltethos.org/dat_eng/index_e.htm. (accessed February 28, 2007. Ethical Theory and Business. Edited by Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004. "Europe: Do as I Say--or as I Do?; Charlemagne." The Economist 382, no. 8516 (2007): 46. Farrell, Diana. "The Case for Globalization." The International Economy 18, no. 1 (2004): 52. Freeman, R. Edward. "A Stakeholder Theory of the Modern Corporation." In Ethical Theory and Business, edited by Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie, 55-74. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Prentice Hall, 2004. Friedman, Thomas L. The World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century. New York: Farrar, Straus and Girox, 2006. Gikandi, Simon. "Preface: Modernism in the World." Modernism/Modernity 13, no. 3 (2006): 419. Hursthouse, Rosalind. "Normative Virtue Ethics." In Virtue Ethics, edited by Stephan Darwall. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003. ———. 2003. Virtue Ethics. In Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Metaphysics Research Lab, SDLI, Stanford University. (accessed February 12, 2007). "India Overheats." The Economist, February 3rd-9th 2007. "Infrastructure Needs Serious Attention in Tn." Businessline (2007): 1.
Page 24
Johnston, Payson. "Business and Organizational Leadership as a Vocation: A Renewed Approach to Business." University of San Francisco, 2005. Knights, David, and Majella O'Leary. "Leadership, Ethics and Responsibility to the Other." Journal of Business Ethics, no. 67 (2006): 125-37. Kumar, N. Siva, and U. S. Rao. "Guidelines for Value Based Management in Kautilya's Arthashastra." Journal of Business Ethics 15, no. 4 (1996): 415. Lehr, David. 2006. Project Market Light (Pml). In, Digital Vision Program at Stanford Univeristy, http://rdvp.org/fellows/2005-2006/david-lehr/. (accessed February 17, 2007. Logsdon, Jeanne M., and Donna J. Wood. "Global Business Citizenship and Voluntary Codes of Ethical Conduct." Journal of Business Ethics 59, no. 1-2 (2005): 55. MacIntyre, Alasdair. After Virtue. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1981. Miller, Alexander. An Introduction to Contemporary Metaethics. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2003. Monga, Manjit. "Managers' Moral Reasoning: Evidence from Large Indian Manufacturing Organisations." Journal of Business Ethics 71, no. 2 (2007): 179. Nair, Chandran. "Why Asia Must Look Beyond Profits to Ethics Chandran Nair." Financial Times, Sep 5 2005, 13. Prahalad, C. K. The Fortune at the Bottom of the Pyramid: Eradicating Poverty through Profits. Upper Saddle River: Wharton School Publishing, 2005. "Public-Private Partnership Is the Way to Build Infrastructure." Businessline (2006): 1. Radin, Tara J., and Martin Calkins. "The Struggle against Sweatshops: Moving Towards Responsible Global Business." Journal of Business Ethics, no. 66 (2006): 261-72. Rice, Marion. "The New Heros." 2006. Sen, Amartya. The Argumentative Indian: Wrings on Indian History, Culture and Identity. New York: Picador, 2005. Sengupta, Somini. "Even Amid Its Wealth, India Finds, Half Its Small Children Are Malnourished." New York Times, Feb 10 2007, 7. Sihag, Balbir S. "Kautilya on Ethics and Economics." Humanomics 21, no. 3/4 (2005): 1. Smith, Adam. Wealth of Nations. London: George Bell & Sons, 1892.
Page 25
Springer, Richard. "Maharashtra Cm Reassures Silicon Valley Entrepreneurs." India - West, Jul 1 2005, A1. "The Ethical Mind: A Conversation with Psychologist Howard Gardner." Harvard Business Review 85, no. 3 (2007): 51-6. University of San Francisco, Overseas Study Tour: India. January 5 - January 20, 2007. Virtue Ethics. Edited by Stephen Darwall. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
doc_232993642.docx