hey i feel among the two icici is good, but u first need to make a choice whether u wanna by urself trade in d markets or u want them to trade for u, as in, they will recommend u the scrips.
if u r goona trade by watchin the cnbc analysis of it then well it makes no difference wher u go coz u only need a demat a/c or a mapin no. as it is called so these days. in this case u can opt for ne one.
wheras if u r gonna sit wid them nd discuss bout the future nd wat will give me returns nd all such questions then i suggest u go for some really reputed ones like icici, motilal oswal or may be even sharekhan.
i personally am trading nd i hve an a/c with 'anand rathi'. these ppl r really good, they regularly mail nd post their newsletter containing all d latest news and wich scrips acc to them r gonna increase and also bout ipo's. overal mngt is too good. for me i hve little time to actually go nd sit wid them hence i just trade wid them on the phone....
hope it helped u.......do rply