Description
In this particular brief criteria around the entrepreneurial concepts and practical field based knowledge.
Entrepreneur
FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
THOMAS C. KINNEAR
The entrepreneurial concepts and practical field-based
knowledge that Zell Lurie-focused Ross students
are exposed to, create graduates for placement with
innovative, entrepreneurial companies and with
venture capital firms. Within these pages you can
explore a sampling of businesses that Ross School
students have been creating and some of their bold
new ideas. Thank you for your continued support
and participation. It is through the continued engage-
ment of business and investment leaders, as well
as our alumni community, that we are able to prepare
our students for entrepreneurial success.
IN THIS ISSUE
Awards & Scholarships
Action Based Learning Initiatives
Wolverine Venture Fund
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Internships
Business Plan Competitions
Dare to Dream Student Start-up Grants
EMAP - Entrepreneurial Multidisciplinary
Action Projects
Entrepreneurial & Venture Capital Courses
Entrepreneur & Venture Club Highlights
Entrepalooza Symposium
Michigan Growth Capital Symposium
Student Showcase
Zell Lurie Institute/Center for Venture Capital
& Private Equity Finance Year-in-Review
FALL 2007/WINTER 2008
www.zli.bus.umich.edu
& V e n t u r e C a p i t a l
Awards & Scholarships: Celebrating Outstanding
Entrepreneurial Student Leaders at Ross
The following awards were made possible through the generosity of Ron and Eileen
Weiser. Recipients were selected based in part on their ambassadorship, passion for
entrepreneurship and academic excellence.
Entrepreneur of the Year Award for an MBA - $1,000
Heath Silverman’s (MBA ’08) ever burgeoning entrepreneurial mind found many outlets for the application
and development of new business ideas as he moved through the process of earning his MBA. Silverman
took the opportunity to further his entrepreneurial knowledge and experience through his participation as
co-president of the Entrepreneur & Venture Club, chair of the Entrepalooza symposium, a member of the
Frankel Commercialization Fund, a Michigan Business Challenge winner, and as a recipient of a Dare to
Dream grant.
Merrill Guerra (MBA ’08) took the reins to realize her dream and launched RealKidz Clothing while earning
her degree. She credits her summer internship experience at a start-up company, SpiritShop founded by
Todd Sullivan (MBA ’05), as having provided her with a large part of the foundation for her launch. Her
business launch efforts were further supported through enrollment in a new venture creation course,
receiving a Dare to Dream grant, and participation in the Michigan Business Challenge.
Cause-Based Entrepreneurial Leadership Award - $1,000
Chris Genteel (MBA ’08) took his passion for driving forward new ideas and creating enterprise to win a
Dare to Dream grant and participate in the Michigan Business Challenge during his first year at Ross.
That passion combined with his tremendous leadership skills also saw the creation of the Arts Enterprise
Club which joins Ross students with students at the School of Music, Theatre and Dance to explore
new careers by working in a cross-disciplinary manner. As a graduate of Ross, Chris envisions and is
fostering the development necessary for the Club to become a national organization.
Entrepreneur of the Year Award for a BBA - $500 each
Jared Ailstock and Mark Thompson (BBAs ’08) will have extraordinary impact on the business world
bringing to it their entrepreneurial spirit and vision for new business creation. As a sophomore Jared was
involved in developing the business plan for Red Baron Rocks for which he won first place at the
Nebraska business plan competition. During his senior year, Mark Thompson partnered with Jared to
develop VidFlips. Mark had conceived the idea for the company several years ago and led a team of
BBAs to develop a full business plan for it. The team presented VidFlips at this year’s Michigan Business
Challenge and placed in the semi-finals.
A
w
a
r
d
s
&
S
c
h
o
l
a
r
s
h
i
p
s
Jared Ailstock & Mark Thompson Merrill Guerra Heath Silverman
pp.2-
A
w
a
r
d
s
&
S
c
h
o
l
a
r
s
h
i
p
s
Scholarships
The following scholarship recipients proved
themselves both in the classroom and as
entrepreneurial leaders. Each recipient main-
tained a meritorious GPA while succeeding
in previous or ongoing entrepreneurial activity.
Samuel Zell Scholarship Awards
$10,000
Joseph Ferencz, MBA ’09
Katie Miller, MBA ’09
Marcin Wojtczak, MBA ’09
$5,000
Jennifer Anderson, MBA ’08
Ryan Baxter, MBA ’08
Jason Dishlip, MBA ’08
Robert Fetter, MBA ’08
Vanessa Frey, MBA ’08
Adam Litle, MBA ’08
Aaron Nelson, MBA/MA ’09
Heath Silverman, MBA ’08
Vikram Vaishya, MBA ’08
Zell & Erb Institute Entrepreneurial
Scholars
$5,000
Brewster Boyd, MBA/MS ’09
Michael Edison, MBA/MS ’09
Matt Garratt, MBA/MS ’09
Zell & NPM Entrepreneurial
Nonprofit Scholars
$5,000
Chris Genteel, MBA ’08
Rabindar Subbian, MBA/MSW ’08
Mitchell A. Mondry Scholarship
Awards
$5,000
Punit Chiniwalla, MBA ’08
Merrill Guerra, MBA ’08
Institute Scholar
Elisabeth Smith, MBA ’09
Scholarship Recipients:
(Top Row) Joseph Ferencz, Robert Fetter, Chris Genteel, Rabindar Subbian,
Brewster Boyd, Aaron Nelson, Adam Litle, Matt Garratt (Middle Row) Punit
Chiniwalla, Heath Silverman, Katie Miller, Elisabeth Smith, Ryan Baxter,
Vikram Vaishya (Front Row) Jennifer Anderson, Vanessa Frey, Merrill Guerra,
Michael Edison, Jason Dishlip
3
W
o
l
v
e
r
i
n
e
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
F
i
m
d
Wolverine Venture Fund: Student Managed Fund Fuels
Entrepreneurial Enterprise by Making Six Strategic Investments
Created in 1997, the Wolverine Venture Fund (WVF) continues to be the only completely student directed
venture fund associated with a business school. The $3.5 million venture capital fund, administered by
the Zell Lurie Institute, takes the business-development process to the next level by making early-stage
and follow-on investments in young companies in the healthcare, high technology, and clean tech industries.
The WVF students undertake rigorous due diligence in support of the Fund’s investment decisions. At
this time, the Fund has active investments in ten firms. During the ’07-’08 academic year, the WVF made
three new investments: Accord Biomaterials, Quantum Learning Technologies, and IntelePeer; and three
follow-on investments: Direct Flow Medical, Nanocerox, and Mobius Microsystems.
Accord Biomaterials Inc. is a Michigan-based company that focuses upon the development of catalytic
nitric oxide coatings for blood-contacting medical devices. These coatings address serious complications
related to clotting and altered healing with technology licensed from the University of Michigan.
Direct Flow Medical is a California-based medical device that is developing a stentless system for the
percutaneous replacement of the aortic heart valve.
IntelePeer is a California-based VoIP managed-service provider offering global peering infrastructure,
network interoperability, industry-leading quality of service, and advanced VoIP-enabled applications.
Mobius Microsystems is a California and Michigan-based company that empowers integrated circuit
designers and manufacturers to achieve previously unattainable levels of analog and mixed-signal integration
across all process technologies.
Nanocerox is a Michigan-based company that produces mixed metal oxide nanoscale ceramic powders.
These materials have a wide variety of applications, including military armor, laser lighting components,
sensors, and anti-counterfeiting.
Quantum Learning Technologies is a Michigan-based online educational community that enables children
to reach their academic potential by embedding scientifically-based educational activities in engaging,
interactive programs that incorporate computer game design techniques.
Venture Fund Management
Thirty-five MBA students manage the Fund, supported by Tom Kinnear, the Fund’s Managing Director,
and a nine member advisory board of professional venture capitalists and entrepreneurs. Collectively, the
students bring to the table broad-based experience in fields such as biotechnology, software, investment
banking, intellectual property law, semiconductors, software, chemical engineering, marketing, and
medical devices. The Fund typically provides $50,000 to $200,000 in seed and first-stage funding
rounds and co-investing in partnership with institutional venture capital firms.
“My participation in the Wolverine Venture Fund has been the highlight of my action-based learning
experience at the Ross School of Business. Evaluating potential investments has fostered continuous
learning through interaction with the fund advisors and with talented, motivated students. Most impor-
tantly, the WVF has helped me develop judgment by analyzing deals in a rigorous and structured manner
and leading decisions resulting in real investments.”
-Munish Gandhi, MBA ’07
Wolverine Venture Fund Student and
Advisory Board Members
pp.4-
W
o
l
v
e
r
i
n
e
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
F
i
m
d
Wolverine Venture Fund Investment Activity
Portfolio Investments Investment Partners
Quantum Learning Technologies April 2008 RPM Ventures
Accord Biomaterials April 2008 Arboretum Ventures, Sigvion Capital
IntelePeer January 2008 EDF Ventures, Kennet Venture Partners, IVA Fund,
Vogen Fund, Black Steel Investments
Direct Flow Medical March 2005, September 2007 EDF Ventures, Spray Ventures,
Johnson & Johnson Development,
Foundation Medical Partners, Vantage Point,
ePlanet
HandyLab Inc. August 2000, November 2001, EDF Ventures, Arboretum Ventures, Ardesta,
June 2002, May 2004, December 2005 Pfizer Ventures
SilverPop Systems August 2000 Draper Fisher Jurvetson
Mobius Microsystems, April 2004, November 2007 Waypoint Ventures, Angel Funds, Menlo Ventures,
Foundation Ventures
Nanocerox, Inc. November 2005, December 2006, Angel Funds
May 2008
NanoBio March 2006 Angel Funds, Perseus LLC
Rhevision Technology March 2006 EDF Ventures, In-Q-Tel Ventures
Fund Award Recipients
Catherine Lee and Vikram Vaishya (MBAs ’08) were honored with the David Shelby Award for their outstanding
leadership of the Fund, in honor of the WVF’s first alumni manager and co-founder, David Shelby.
Wolverine Venture Fund
Student Members
MBAs ’08
Ryan Baxter
Erin Cready
Shantanu Dhamija
David Forsythe
John Gearen (MBA/MS ’08)
Karl Kyriss
Catherine Lee
Eugene Lee
Jing Liang
Adam Litle (MBA/JD ’08)
Shripal Meghani
Kati Prause
Deborah Robbins
Sahana Shetty
Puneet Singh
Vikram Vaishya
Devi Vijayakumari
Sriram Viji
Christopher Wilson
Jason Yang
MBAs ’09
Justin Adams
Julia Choi
Meghan Cuddihy (Ph.D. Candidate)
Anne Delaney
Himayat Khan
Jeffrey Lebrun (MBA/MS ’09)
Joseph Malcoun (MBA/MS ’09)
Josh Mandel-Brehm
Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
Seema Prasad
Nate Schmid
Renata Soares (MBA/MS ’09)
Nathaniel Troup
Christopher Whitehead
Advisory Board
Peter Adriaens, UofM College of Engineering
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures – Alumni Fund Manager
William Johnson, Consultant/Venture Investor
Timothy Mayleben, ElMa Advisors
Timothy Petersen, Arboretum Ventures
Mina Patel Sooch, Apjohn Ventures
Donald Walker, Arbor Partners
Steven Weinstein, Prism Venture Partners
Marc Weiser, RPM Ventures
Faculty/Staff
Thomas Kinnear, Faculty Advisor
Carolyn Maguire, Administrator
5
F
r
a
n
k
e
l
C
o
m
m
e
r
c
i
a
l
i
z
a
t
i
o
n
F
u
n
d
Frankel Commercialization Fund: Student Run Fund
Invests Pre-Seed Money in Two Firms
The Frankel Commercialization Fund is continually seeking opportunities to help jumpstart new companies
in Michigan. Established in 2005, the Fund is believed to be the only student venture capital fund of its
kind with a focus on the commercialization of ideas and development of new companies. Tom Porter,
executive-in-residence at the Zell Luire Institute, serves as the Fund’s director.
The Fund is organized into student teams that function as independently financed venture capital compa-
nies providing very early-stage investing. These teams seek out scientific discoveries and inventions with
commercialization potential at the College of Engineering and the School of Medicine. Once these ideas
have been identified and evaluated, the teams may invest pre-seed money to move the concepts to the
point where they are ready for early-stage venture-capital investment.
Additional mentoring is provided through the Fund’s advisory board comprised of venture capitalists, entre-
preneurs, industry experts and CEOs. Student members of the Fund learn a great deal about technology
commercialization and investment due diligence by working with these companies. They remain actively
involved in monitoring the company’s progress, providing guidance and ensuring the company is adhering
to its milestones to advancing the growth of the company.
This year the Fund announced its first two investments in Arbor Photonics (November 2007) and
BeholzTech Inc. (May 2008).
Arbor Photonics is an Ann Arbor, Michigan-based company that has developed a novel, scalable, optical
fiber technology that enables high-power fiber lasers to be used in a variety of new materials-processing
applications in the automotive, electronics and aerospace industries while offering a lower-cost replacement
to existing bulky laser systems.
BeholzTech Inc. is a Flint, Michigan-based company that effectively coats polyolefin plastics, making them
easier to modify and adhere to other materials. Polyolefins are tiny plastic pellets that are used to make
thousands of products we use everyday.
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Student Members
Health Care
Dan Chagnovich, MBA Eve
Andrew Charnik, MBA ’09
Travis Coy, MBA ’08
Delara Godrej, MBA Eve
Andrew Hastings, MBA ’08
Phil Kowalczyk, MBA ’09
Satchin Master, MBA ’08
Chris Mortis, MBA Eve
Dan Saddawi-Konefka, MBA/MD ’09
Michael Tarasev, MBA Eve
Cleantech
Brewster Boyd, ERB MBA/MS ’09
Laura Bruce, ERB MBA/MS ’10
Siobhan Doherty, ERB MBA/MS ’10
Mike Hartley, ERB MBA/MS ’09
Technology
Mark Birac, MBA Eve
Punit Chiniwalla, MBA ’08
Jason Dishlip, MBA’08
Mike Edison, MBA/ERB ’08
Jessica Goldberg, MBA ’09
Brian Katzman, MBA/ERB ’10
Tom Porter, Andrew Churnite, Laura Bruce, and
Brian Katzman
Student and Advisory Board Members of the Frankel Commercialization Fund
pp.6-
Internships: In the ‘Trenches’ with Entrepreneurs and
Venture Capitalists
The Marcel Gani Summer Internship program places students ‘in the trenches’ with entrepreneurs and inves-
tors at startup companies and venture capital firms from across the U.S. This spring the Institute placed and
funded 19 graduate and undergraduate students among 17 host companies, including seven venture capital
firms. Students typically spend up to 14 weeks in this full-immersion experience where they participate in a
company’s planning and execution, and in an investment firm’s due diligence process for potential investments.
In turn, firms benefit from the students’ management expertise and strategic recommendations they otherwise
might not obtain.
“In addition to the operational experience, I can directly apply the knowledge that I have gained while
matriculating the business program at Ross. Notable classes and experiences include, Corporate Strategy,
Marketing, Valuation, New Venture Creation, and Venture Finance from the Wolverine Venture Fund. I plan
to apply my knowledge to help facilitate ProNAI’s success in obtaining funding and in developing a cancer
agent to treat patients in the future.” – Christopher Whitehead, MBA ’09
Internship Placements 2008
Company Intern
Amherst Fund, LLC – Michigan David Lin, MBA Eve
Apjohn Ventures Fund, LP – Michigan Zakaria Shaikh, MBA ’09
Arboretum Ventures – Michigan Naomita Yadav, MBA ’09
Ascendant Solutions – Texas Bryan Mortenson, MBA ’09
Dusoto – Michigan Christopher Robart, MBA ’09
ePack Corps – Michigan Akshai Rao, MBA ’08
Fry Farms – Ohio Kate Appel, MBA ’10
Inovo – Michigan Manisha Tayal, MBA ’08
MacBeedon Partners, LLC – Michigan Richard Roman, BBA ’10
Mozergy – Michigan Tony Gross, MBA ’08; Jeff Lebrun, MBA ’09
*in partnership with the William Davidson
Instititute and Erb Instititute
Plymouth Venture Partners – Michigan Brewster Boyd, MBA /MS ’09
Project Freestyle – Michigan Michael Parke, BBA ’08
ProNai Therapeutics Chris Whitehead, MBA ’09
Seneca Partners – Michigan Niket Gandhi, MBA ’09
U-M Office of Tech Transfer – Michigan Ian Dailey, MBA ’09;
Natasha Thomas, MBA Eve
uRefer – Michigan Nick Mekas, BBA ’10
Venture Investors – Michigan Michael Tarasev, MBA ’08
7
Katie Miller, MBA ’09
Dinesh Narayan, MBA ’09
Alex Robart, MBA ’09
Heath Silverman, MBA ’08
Advisory Board
Medical Technology/Life Sciences Board
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures
Mary R. Flack, NanoBio
Larry Hagerty, RLP Technologies (sub. of RL Polk)
Michael P. Kurek, Biotechnology Business Consultants
Roger Newton, Investor
Lisa Shapiro, Shapiro Solutions Inc.
Shelby Solomon, Ingenix, Inc.
Technology Board
Jim Adox, Venture Investors
Tony Grover, RPM Ventures
David Hartmann, Arbor Blue, LLC
Al Kortesoya, Formerly Capgemini/Ernst & Young
Chuck Salley, Investor
Gerard P. Spencer, Retired Partner Arthur Andersen
Member-at-Large
Ken Nisbet, U-M Office of Technology Transfer
I
n
t
e
r
n
s
h
i
p
s
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
2008 Michigan Business Challenge
The University of Michigan Business Plan Competition
The Michigan Business Challenge engages students
from across campus through multiple rounds of
competition in which they develop their business
ideas into a sound business plan. The competition
awards over $40,000 in prize money. The competi-
tion process is supported through training and feed-
back offered by judges. In 2007, 36 teams entered
the three-month long contest with the opportunity
to present their business in four rounds of competi-
tion for awards of up to $15,000 in prize money.
25th Pryor-Hale Award for Best Business - $15,000
Outstanding Presentation - $2,500
Army Property: Offers a secure, online, multi-user
inventory management system for individuals in the
Armed Forces to organize, delegate, and account
for military equipment.
Team: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard, Parren James,
Ben Kozma, and Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
Runner-up for Best Business - $5,000
Williamson Award for Outstanding Business and
Engineering Team - $5,000
Erb Award for Sustainability - $5,000
Potentia: Manufacturers a micro fabricated battery-
replacement component to generate power in wireless
sensors by harnessing naturally occurring energy.
Team: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08),
Rishiraj Das (MBA ’08), and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
Outstanding Presentation - $2,500
Best Written Plan - $2,500
Semi-finalist - $500
Hitchsters: Operates a service that connects travel-
ers going to and from major metropolitan airports
so that they can share a cab, split the fare, and
shrink their carbon footprint.
Team: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08),
Jason Lin (MBA ’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
Finalists - $1,000
ePack Corp: Provides a high volume, high yield,
batch mode micro-device packaging for MEMS
manufacturers.
Team: Razi Haque (MBA ’08),
Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08),
Sang Woo Lee, and Michael Urcan (MBA ’08)
Competitions: Combining Entrepreneurial Leadership
Skills and Knowledge with the Ability to Drive Results
With financial support and mentoring from the Institute, undergraduate and graduate
students are encouraged to hone their skills, test new business concepts, expand their
networks and win cash awards by competing in the University’s Michigan Business
Challenge and Quick Pitch Competition, as well as intercollegiate business plan, case
and venture capital competitions.
Org Org: Offers an internet tool for organizations to
communicate with their members and for members
to define their interests in the organization while
networking with and discovering other organizations.
Team: Jennifer Anderson, Abhishek Gopalka,
Lauren Rosenthal, Heath Silverman, and Sriram Viji
(MBAs ’08)
Semi-finalists - $500
Audiallo: Designs biology-inspired, audio processing
technology which targets the hearing-aid and high-end
audio markets.
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
BCCJ Biodiesel: Sells biodiesel fuel reformulated
from waste grease collected from local restaurants
or other food establishments.
Team: James Bucher (Ph.D. ’09), Meghan Cuddihy
(Ph.D. Candidate), and Edward Jan (Ph.D. ’09)
VidFlips: Combines aspects of Facebook, JumpCut,
YouTube, and iMovie in a new online product for
users to record events in a personalized manner.
Team: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), Richard Lam and
Mark Thompson (BBAs ’08)
Michigan Business Challenge Judges
Jim Adox, Venture Investors; Jack Ahrens, TGap
Ventures; Jim Baker, Michigan Technology
University; Anthony Blanchard, Deloitte and
Touche; Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures; Amy Cell,
Ann Arbor SPARK; Cindy Crawford, Ross School of
Business; John Cunningham, Innoventures; Mike
Davis, Wolverine Capital Partners; Art DeMonte,
SummitTech BD; Charles Fry, Fry Farms; Jan
Garfinkle, Arboretum Ventures; Mary Sue Hoffman,
MI-SBTDC; Tom Kinnear, Ross School of Business;
Nancy Kotzian, Ross School of Business; Karl
LaPeer, Peninsula Capital Partners; Andy Lawlor,
Ross School of Business; Rod Lowe, Tecra
Systems; Andy McColm, University of Michigan;
Len Middleton, Ross School of Business; Scott
Olson, Ann Arbor SPARK; Monique Oxender, Ford
Motor Company; David Peralta, NanoBio; Mark
Petroff, Marketing Associates; Chuck Salley, Ann
Arbor SPARK; Larry Schmitt, Inovo; Phil Tepley,
MI-SBTDC; Don Walker, Arbor Partners; Walt
Young, Plymouth Venture Partners.
pp.8-
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
Intercollegiate Business Plan, Case
and Venture Capital Competitions
Consideration for competition sponsorship is given
to participating teams of the Michigan Business
Challenge as well as to teams who have demonstrated
a clear intent to launch their business. In 2008 the
Institute sponsored and coached 16 teams in 16
competitions. Teams representing the University of
Michigan were rewarded $103,250 in prize money.
Ball State University
Nascent 500 Business Plan Challenge (March 28)
VidFlips: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), and Andrew Baron,
Alice Chen, Tara Colli, Richard Lam and Mark
Thompson (BBAs ’08)
$1,500
Boise State University
Northwest Venture Championship (March 6)
Project Freestyle: Aly Juma (BS ’08), Brent Medema
(BS ’08), Chris Mwakasisi (BS ’09) and Michael
Parke (BS ’08)
Carnegie Mellon
McGinnis Venture Competition (March 13)
ePack Corp: Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08), Sang
Woo Lee and Akshai Rao(MBA ’08)
Blaze: Michael Tarasev (MBA ’08)
$5,000
Northwestern University
ABI Corporate Restructuring Competition (November 9)
Rishi Das (MBA ’08), Himayat Khan (MBA ’09), James
Lynch (MBA ’09) and Shripal Meghani (MBA ’08)
Rice University
Business Plan Competition (April 3)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$6,500
San Diego University
Venture Challenge (March 27)
Audiallo: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
$3,500
University of Cincinnati
Spirit of Enterprise Competition (February 28)
Army Property: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard and
Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
$10,000
University of Colorado
Venture Capital Investment Competition (February 8)
Ryan Baxter, Nathan Bosco, Punit Chiniwalla, David
Forsythe and Catherine Lee (MBAs ’08)
$500
(Top) Judges: David Peralta, Larry Schmitt, Walt Young, Scott Olson, Mary Sue
Hoffman and Len Middleton (Middle) Judges: Rod Lowe, Jim Baker, Chuck Salley,
Amy Cell, Phil Tepley, Andy McColm and Andy Lawlor (Bottom) Judges: (Back
Row) John Cunningham, David Gard, Jack Ahrens, Jim Adox, Don Walker (Front Row)
Karl LaPeer, Mike Davis, Charles Fry, Art DeMonte, Monique Oxender, Cindy Crawford,
Anthony Blanchard, Jan Garfinkle and Mark Petroff
(Top) Hitchsters: Sriram Viji, Catherine Lee and Jason Lin
(Middle) Army Property: Ambra Heard, Sherman Powell and Ben Kozma
(Bottom) Potentia: Tzeno Galchev (PhD), Ruba Borno (PhD) and Rishiraj Das
9
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
University of Colorado
Clean Tech Venture Challenge (February 27)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das
(MBA ’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$15,000
Forest Eye: Brewster Boyd (MBA/MS ’08)
$10,000
Cymergy: Harsh Nahar (MBA ’08)
$5,000
EnDep: Arie Jongejan and Tom Leahy (MBA/MSs ’10)
$2,000
University of Louisville
Cardinal Challenge (February 22)
Slow Kitchen Post: Robert Fetter (MBA ’08) and
Glenn Tarcea (MBA ’09)
$750
University of Manitoba
Stuart Clark Venture Challenge (April 3)
Org Org: Jennifer Anderson, Abhishek Gopalka,
Lauren Rosenthal, Heath Silverman, and Sriram Viji
(MBAs ’08)
University of Nebraska
New Ventures World Competition (April 10)
$500
VidFlips: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), Andrew Baron,
Alice Chen, Tara Colli, Richard Lam and Mark
Thompson (BBAs ’08)
Hitchsters: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08), Jason Lin
(MBA ’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
$1,500
University of North Carolina
Social Venture Capital Investment Competition
(March 28)
Jennifer Anderson, Erin McCready, Andy Davis
(MBAs ’08), Nina Henning (MS/MBA ’09) and
Vikram Vaishya ’08)
$1,000
University of San Francisco
International Business Plan Competition (April 24)
GIDEON: Mark Birac, Katie Miller (MBAs ’09) and
Ankit Shah (MBA Eve)
$1,000
University of Texas – Austin
Idea to Product Competition (November 1)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das
(MBA ’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$2,500
University of Texas – Austin
MOOT CORP Competition (April 30)
ePack Corp: Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08),
Sang Woo Lee and Akshai Rao(MBA ’08)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$2,000
Wake Forest University
The Elevator Competition (March 28)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$5,000
KLI African Business Plan Competition (December 14)
Mozergy: focuses their business operations in Mozam-
bique, and specifically on the cultivation and produc-
tion of Jatropha, a hearty and drought-resistant plant.
The plant has significant potential as an alternative
energy feedstock for biodiesel.
Tony Gross (MBA/MS ’08), Mike Hartley,
Jeff LeBrun and Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09s)
$10,000
Walmart Better Living Business Challenge (April 18)
Mozergy: Tony Gross (MBA/MS ’08), Mike Hartley,
Jeff LeBrun and Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09s)
$20,000
2008 University of Michigan
Quick Pitch Competition
The seventh annual competition was held in January
2008 in conjunction with the annual FuturTech
Forum. Competitors from across the University had
three minutes to deliver their elevator pitch to con-
vince a panel of venture capitalists of their businesses’
pending success. The competition was hosted by
the Entrepreneur and Venture Club.
First Place - $1,250
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08), and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
Second Place - $500
RealKidz Clothing: Merrill Guerra (MBA ’09)
Third Place - $250
Audiallo: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
pp.10-
Assessment Grants - $1,500 each
Fall 2007
Audiallo
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA’09)
GIDEON: Develops CAD software for the design
simulation and visualization of nano-systems made
from structural DNA nanotechnology.
Team: Mark Birac (MBA ’09) and Ankit Shah (MBA ’07)
Home Counting: Offers quantitatively accurate
male fertility testing at home.
Team: Brian Burstein (MBA ’09) and David Lorch
(PhD ’08)
Indian Medical Group:
Provides overseas medical tourism services.
Team: Sharad Gupta and Sateesh Srinivasan
(MBAs ’09)
Innovet
Team: Rohan Mendonza (MBA ’09)
Neupharma Microdevices:
Manufactures and sells neural probes.
Team: Cory Costley (MBA ’08), Matt Gibson (PhD
’10) and John Seymour (PhD ’08)
Productive Kitchens: Develops innovative restaurant
equipment to provide increased kitchen productivity
in industrial kitchens.
Team: Babu Sambamoorthy (MBA ’08) and Israel
Vicars (BS ’08)
Sustainable Food Service: Distributes environmen-
tally-friendly food products and services.
Team: Mary Lemmer (BBA ’10) and Vanshika Vij
(BA ’09)
Winter 2008
A2Secure: Offers a secure service to store sensitive
information for user’s online activity.
Team: Paul Gruber and Yogev Shimony (MBAs ’09)
ELAN: Connects schools in India with local donors
to create a large selection of funding options.
Team: Swapnil Deopurkar and Shara Senior (MBA ’08)
Integration Grants
Fall 2007
ArmyProperty.com ($10,000): Offers an online
inventory management system for individuals in the
Armed Forces to organize and account for military
equipment.
Team: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard, Parren James,
Ben Kozma, and Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
ePack Corp ($10,000): Provides MEMS packaging
for semiconductor manufacturers.
Team: Jay Stewart Mitchell (PhD ’07) and Akshai
Rao (MBA ’08)
MSignS ($10,000): English to sign language portable
device
Team: Michael Barfuss (MBA ’08), Jason Gilbert, and
JudyYu (PhD ’08)
Slow Kitchen Post ($5,000): Operates an internet
service to deliver artisan food to customers’ homes.
Team: Robert Fetter (MBA ’08)
Winter 2008
Audiallo ($10,000): Designs biology-inspired, audio
processing technology which targets the hearing-aid
and high-end audio markets.
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
Hitchsters ($5,000): Operates a service that connects
travelers going to and from airports so that they can
share a cab and split the fare.
Team: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08), Jason Lin (MBA
’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
Innovet ($10,000): Develops medical devices and
provides services for veterinary orthopedic applications.
Team: Rohan Mendonza (MBA ’09)
Mozergy ($5,000): Offers sustainable biodiesel feed-
stock to produce sustainable carbon-neutral biodiesel.
Team: Jeff LeBrun (MBA/MA ’09), Tony Gross (MBA/
MS ’08), Mike Hartley, Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09)
Dare to Dream Grants for Student Start-ups
Students who wish to develop their own entrepreneurial business concepts and work
toward the launch of their business may apply each fall and winter term for Dare to
Dream grants of up to $10,000. Dare to Dream grants are awarded in three phases: the
opportunity-identification phase where a potential business idea is identified, the assessment
phase where that concept is explored to see if it ‘has legs’; and the integration phase
where a solid business plan is created around the validated concept. The program provided
$101,000 in grant funding to students during the 2007-2008 academic year.
D
a
r
e
t
o
D
r
e
a
m
G
r
a
n
t
s
11
D
a
r
e
t
o
D
r
e
a
m
G
r
a
n
t
s
Healthy Lunches: Offers home and school delivered
lunches selected by parents.
Team: Zakaria Shaikh & Jeremy Sullivan (MBAs ’09)
I2: Offers design services to homeowners making
quality improvements on a modest budget.
Team: Jessica Goldberg (MBA ’09) and Katie Miller
(MBA/March ’10)
Michigan Watersports: Offers an indoor wake-
boarding water sports park.
Team: Victoria Miretti (BBA ’08) and Eduardo
Serrano (B.M.E. ’10)
Natural Sequestration Company: Sequesters carbon
dioxide emissions waste to large scale emitters and
creates a glucose byproduct to sell.
Team: Justin Felt (MBA/MS ’08)
Project Freestyle: Offers online tools to provide
organizational and marketing solutions for soccer
businesses.
Team: Aly Juma, Brent Medema, Chris Mwakasisi
(B.S.s ’08), Michael Parke (BBA ’08)
SecondEye: Provides software for automated reads of
medical images similar to spell-check for radiologists.
Team: Brian Burstein (MBA ’09) and Ted Way (Ph.D. ’08)
Travelamp: Provides nightlife information to
travelers abroad.
Team: Alexander Robart and Christopher Robart
(MBAs ’09)
Z2 Technologies: Computer-assisted dental implan-
tology services and computer-generated surgical
guides to provide ideal implant placement assistance.
Team: Dan Zetu (MBA ’09)
Opportunity Grants - $500 each
Fall 2007
General Aerodynamics: Analyze performance of
helicopter rotors and propellers
Team: James Cho (MSE ’08)
Haniwa Raptor Security Systems: Digital recording
system triggered by RFID hits for security firms.
Team: David Gaucher (MBA ’09)
Hearing Protection Indicator: Safety glasses that
indicate when hearing protection is needed.
Team: Robert Littrell (PhD’09)
i2: Mass market architectural services.
Team: Katie Miller (MBA/MArch ’10)
Maxim Investments: Investment funds that get
maximum tax efficiency.
Team: Maxim Yutsis (MBA ’08)
pp.12-
Modern Portfolio Auctions: Auction services for
individual or combination bid lots.
Team: Miles Putnam (MA)
Second Eye: CAD highlights of areas on CT scans
on which radiologists should focus.
Team: Ted Way (PhD ’08)
SensoWear: Fabric that senses change in tempera-
ture, pH, etc for sportswear and military uniforms.
Team: Edward Jan and Meghan Cuddihy (PhDs ’09)
Winter 2008
BLA Technologies: Tracks spatial coordinates.
Team: Ben Avidar (B.S.E. ’10) and Brian Pogrund (B.A. ’11)
City Cycles: Provides companies with support, such
as locker rooms, to encourage bicycling commuters.
Team: John Alexander, Tom Leahy, David Wolpa,
and Andrew Zrike (MBAs ’09)
Fontis Medical: Delivers large molecule drugs
through the skin with a patch.
Team: Matt Gibson, TK Kozai (Ph.D. ’10), and Erin
Purcell (Ph.D. ’08)
Grad Student Net: Share access to expensive tech-
nology and supplies.
Team: Channing Huntington and Prashant
Padmanabhan (Ph.D. ’11)
High Efficiency Thin Film: Solar cell thin film to
make solar energy more accessible.
Team: Tao Ling, Weiming Wang (Ph.D.s ’10), Jun
Yang, and Meng Zhang (Ph.D.s ’08)
Moduline Technologies: External re-sealable con-
nector for implantation within the body.
Team: Bryan Callow, Daniel Greenwald, Diana
Koordi, and Jeffery Meng (M.S.E. ’08)
Pure Ultra: Improves gel polymers for sensitive
applications such as ultrasounds.
Team: Fong Ming Hooi (Ph.D. ’10)
Residential Energy Solutions: Provides roof-mounted
Vertical Axis Wind Turbine for residential and small
business use.
Team: Glenn McDonald and Qian Xin Weng (Ph.D. ’10)
Taglium: Develops cutting fluid.
Team: Faheem Gill and Vijay Parthasarathy (MBA ’10)
Waste Agents: Advises businesses about the energy
value of their waste streams.
Team: Thomas Gilbert (Ph.D. ’09)
13
Entrepreneurial Studies & Venture Capital Finance:
Part of a Strong General Management Curriculum
The Ross School of Business, hand-in-hand with the Institute and its Center for Venture
Capital & Private Equity Finance, actively engages the nation’s most successful entrepreneurs
and offers an outstanding faculty comprising both academic researchers and practitioners in
entrepreneurship and venture capital.
Entrepreneurial Studies & Venture Capital Finance Course Electives
Bringing Reality into the Classroom
David J. Brophy, Director, Center for Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance: Professor of Finance
Real people. Real deals. Real outcomes. That’s what sets David Brophy’s courses in venture capital, private
equity and entrepreneurial finance apart from those at other leading business schools. “All the cases I
present are real cases, and everything I do in class is rooted in my personal involvement with investors
and entrepreneurs,” explains Brophy, who has played a formidable role in company-building as an adviser to
both start-ups and venture funds for nearly 30 years. “Students get more insightful treatment plus access
to real information and real people who were involved in the deals. Students can follow up as much as
they want and even make connections for future jobs.” As the founder of the annual Michigan Growth
Capital Symposium in 1979, which focuses on early-stage venture capital, Brophy pioneered an event that
has been emulated by institutions around the world. Brophy maintains close contact with recent and past
graduates who have fanned out across the entrepreneurial and investment communities. “My objective over
the years has been to make this business known to our students and to make it possible for them to get
involved in it as a career,” he says.
Entrepreneurial Multidisciplinary Action Projects:
MBAs Executing High-Level Management Assignments at Start-up Companies
As part of the Michigan MBA program, first year students are assigned to multidisciplinary action projects
at sponsoring companies, including several opportunities at entrepreneurial startups. Over a seven-week
period, the MAP teams execute high-level management assignments, such as developing business plans,
identifying new product opportunities and formulating strategies for market entry.
Entrepreneurial MAP
Company Hosts – 2008
MyWire.com - California
Project: Conduct research and analyze media industry trends and key competitors’ offerings.
MBA Team: Andrew Charnik, Julia Choi, Edward Cox, John Finger, Rahul Pal, Joshua Zane
Lion Cells Inc. - California
Project: Market assessment for electric displacement of small gas engines for the U.S., Europe, and Asia regions.
MBA Team: Heather Dobbins, Joshua Katz, Jeffrey LeBrun, Anthony Lupa, Siddharth Sinha
F
a
c
u
l
t
y
&
C
o
u
r
s
e
s
Urban Entrepreneurship
Enterprise Systems Strategy
Financing Research Commercialization
Private Equity Finance
Venture Capital Finance
Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance in
Transitional Economies
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Wolverine Venture Fund
Driving the Innovation Process
Entrepreneurial Management
Entrepreneurial Turnaround Management
Entrepreneurship via Acquisitions
Family Business
Intellectual Property and Competitive Strategy
Managing the Growth of New Ventures
New Venture Creation
Real Estate Fundamentals
Service Innovation Management
(Top)
Private Equity Course
Graduate Students
(Bottom)
David Brophy, Alan Gelband,
David Evans
13
pp.14-
Michigan Entrepreneur & Venture Club
2007-2008 Club Officers
MBAs ’08
Jennifer Anderson, Co-President
Heath Silverman, Co-President
Eugene Lee, Co-Vice President,
Venture Capital & Private Equity
Mike Lung, Co-Vice President,
Venture Capital & Private Equity
Ari Sznajder, Co-Vice President, Entrepreneurship
Shara Senior, Co-Vice President, Entrepreneurship
Shikhin Agarwal, Vice President, Finance
Jason Townsend, Evening MBA Relations
Ian Dailey, Director of Membership
Harsh Nahar, Treasurer
Kunal Mahajan, Technology Chair
2007-2008
Events and Guest Speakers
September 9 – EVC Kickoff Meeting
September 21 – Dare to Dream Information Meeting
This information session described the Dare to Dream
grants available to students, the application for each
grant, and the deliverables to obtain each grant.
September 18 – Mingle and Match
Students with entrepreneurial interests informally min-
gled with students who already had a business concept
with the goal of creating teams to form a business.
September 19 – EVC Speaker Series
Chetna Sinha, Mann Deshi Bank.
September 21 – EVC Speaker Series
Dan Patchen, Cargill Emerging Business Accelerator
September 21 – Entrepalooza 2007
This annual entrepreneurship symposium featured
four panel discussions, three breakout networking
sessions; and two keynote speakers: Samuel Zell,
Chairman of Equity Group Investments, and Kevin
O’Connor, Co-founder and former CEO & Chairman
of DoubleClick, Inc.; O’Connor Ventures. At the
symposium, Mr. Zell was presented with the Alumni
Entrepreneur of the Year Award.
September 21 – Post Symposium Student
Luncheon & Career Fair
The lunch and learn session brought together busi-
ness students with entrepreneurial alumni.
Participating alumni included Josh Botkin (MBA
’06) of Space Weather Forecasting Technologies;
Michael Edison (MBA/MS ’08) of Well-House Home
& Building Supply; Merrill Guerra (MBA ’08) of
RealKidz, Inc.; Robert Mazur (MBA ’03) of B.A. Maze,
Inc. (PurrFect Opener); Todd Sullivan (MBA ’05) of
SpiritShop, Inc.; and Michael Tarasev (MBA ’08), of
Blaze Medical Devices. Alumni shared their experienc-
es and the resources they tapped to launch while earn-
ing their degree.
During the career fair students networked with repre-
sentatives from entrepreneurial companies, including:
Cleantech Network, DevHive, Ghostly International +
Spectral Sound, Healthcare Data Solutions, Mandy
and Pandy, OtoMedicine Inc., Primerica Financial
Services, and uRturn.com.
September 24 – EVC Speaker Series
Amy Cell from Ann Arbor SPARK and Wes Huffstutter
from the Office of Technology Transfer spoke to stu-
dents about how to get involved in entrepreneurship in
the Ann Arbor community and the University at large.
September 26 – EVC Speaker Series
Mike Rohlfsen, Cargill Environmental Finance
September 28 – EVC Whirlyball
EVC celebrated Dare to Dream submissions with a
Whirlyball event.
September 29 – Michigan Business Challenge
Information Session
October 1 – EVC Speaker Series
Sam Valenti, Ghostly International,
co-sponsored by the Arts Enterprise Club.
October 5 – EVC Speaker Series
Camille Jayne, The Jayne Group
October 11 – EVC Speaker Series
Mike O’Connell, Pavilion Winery
October 12 – Michigan Business Challenge
Information Session
Students interested in participating in the 2008
Michigan Business Challenge attended this information
session to learn the details of the application process,
the format of each round, and the deliverables required.
October – Private Equity Student Panel
October 26 – West Coast Forum VC Panel, California
October 30 – Mingle and Match Business Networking
October 31 – EVC Halloween Happy Hour
Happy hour to celebrate Halloween at Mitch’s
M
i
c
h
i
g
a
n
E
n
t
r
e
p
r
e
n
e
u
r
&
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
C
l
u
b
14
15
November 12 – EVC Speaker Series
Nathan Burrell, the Honey Project
November 16 – Marcel Gani Internship Student Panel
2007 Marcel Gani summer interns discussed their
experiences working for start-up companies and ven-
ture capital firms and answered questions about the
internship process.
December 7 – Social Enterprise Education Event
Co-hosted with Net Impact and the Emerging Markets Club.
December 12 – EOY Pizza Party / Study Break
January 8 – Marcel Gani Internship Program
Information Session
Students learned how to apply for or host an internship
with an entrepreneurial company or a venture capital
firm. Mini-internships through Ann Arbor SPARK were
also presented for students who wanted to receive
entrepreneurial experience in the weeks before their for-
mal internship began. Students with their own business
ideas were encouraged to attend in order to hear about
summer opportunities to further develop their business.
January 9 – Global Social Venture Competition
Information and Prep Session
Co-hosted with Net Impact and the Emerging Markets Club.
January 16 – Dare to Dream Grant Program
Information Session
January 23 – EVC Speaker Series
Maria Leal, Coopa Roca
January 24 – Marcel Gani Internship Host Reception
January 25 – Quick Pitch Competition at FuturTech
FuturTech, the University of Michigan’s business and
technology conference, brought together the Ross
School of Business, the College of Engineering, the
School of Information, and major corporations from
around the world. The Quick Pitch competition was
held in conjunction with the conference.
January 27 – Mingle and Match with Ann Arbor SPARK
Co-hosted by Ann Arbor SPARK
March 4 – Whirlyball
EVC members met for the last social event of the season
and the new 2008-09 club officers were introduced.
April 8 – EVC Speaker Series
Fadi Ghandour, Aramex International
Executive Leaders Provide
Entrepreneurial Consulting
Students met with these executive leaders one-on-
one for the opportunity to receive feedback on their
start-up issues and the challenges they faced in
developing their businesses.
Participating Executives:
October 10 - Jonn Behrman, Entrepreneur
October 11 - Adam Borden, Founder & Managing
Director, Bradmer Foods
November 7 - Tim Petersen, Managing Partner,
Arboretum Ventures
November 10 - Charles Fry, CEO, Fry Farms
M
i
c
h
i
g
a
n
E
n
t
r
e
p
r
e
n
e
u
r
&
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
C
l
u
b
Entreplaooza 2007: Anybody Can Do It
The full spectrum of entrepreneurial activity, from start-ups on a shoestring to private equity mega-deals,
was put into perspective by well-known entrepreneurs, venture capitalists and business executives during
Entrepalooza 2007: Anybody Can Do It. The annual symposium presented by the Samuel Zell and Robert
H. Lurie Institute for Entrepreneurial Studies and the student-led Entrepreneur and Venture Club at the
Stephen M. Ross School of Business was held September 21 at the Michigan League on the University of
Michigan campus and drew 350 attendees from the University and business communities.
Keynote Speaker: Samuel Zell, Chairman, Equity Group Investments
Samuel Zell, a University of Michigan alumnus, founding benefactor of the Institute and the chairman of
Equity Group Investments in Chicago, received the 2007 Entrepreneur of the Year Award from Zell Lurie
executive director Thomas C. Kinnear. Sporting a Chicago Cubs baseball cap-a nod to his $8.2 billion
buyout offer for the Tribune Co., which has owned the Major League franchise team since 1981-Zell, 65,
delivered a blow-by-blow recounting of the events that lead up to his record-setting $40 billion sale of
Equity Office Properties Trust to New York-based Blackstone Group LP last February. He also offered his
current assessment of the financial markets in the wake of the subprime-mortgage meltdown.
The Blackstone-Equity Office transaction, disclosed Feb. 7, represented the days of enormous unfettered
liquidities, unlimited and undisciplined syndication, and the creation of new entities called collateralized loan
obligations and collateralized debt obligations, which pooled a series of debt and created a cascade of “sliding
pieces” that obfuscated risk, Zell said. “Much of the constipation that exists in the debt market today reflects
uncertainty in how you deal with these new entities when there are problems,” he explained. Until these
issues and structures live through some “difficult times,” their role in the future will be unclear, he predicted.
On a reassuring note, Zell said: “I really don’t believe the current environment is quite as catastrophic as
everybody would suggest. The amount of liquidity that existed six or eight weeks ago still exists today.” That
absolute amount of liquidity, he added, will not change until the world grows enough to better use and
absorb the level of capital it has created over the last 10 years.
“I don’t think we have a liquidity crisis,” Zell argued.” I think what we have is a confidence crisis, and I think
we will get through this with moderate damage over the next three to six months.”
Turning his attention to the Office Equity Properties Trust deal, which he described as “a paradigm of what
was happening at the peak of this frenzy,” Zell recapped the financial engineering in which Blackstone put
up $3 billion in equity, investment banks put up $5 billion of bridge equity, and $32 billion of debt was created.
He reported Blackstone has sold 75% of the assets and has retained 25%, and estimated the private equity
firm will earn for their investors a 60% internal rate of return on their investments. “You wouldn’t think
anyone would be so dumb as to sell something to somebody who is going to make a 60% profit on what
you’re selling,” Zell said. “But if you learn anything from what I have to say this morning, it is that there is an
enormous difference between absolute return and internal rate of return. As time moves forward, under-
standing that distinction is definitely going to separate the men from the boys.”
Continuing, Zell explained, “Somebody came to me and said, ‘I’ll take a $40 billion risk for which I’m willing
to accept $2 billion and my theoretical profit, if I succeed.’ The way I count that, it’s something like a 5%
return for the risk taken. From my point of view, I’m fully prepared to basically pay somebody 5% and deliver
$40 billion any day of the week.” He told his audience that the battle for control of the nation’s largest
office building owner began at the end of 2005 and encompassed a heated bidding war between Blackstone
and Vornado Realty Trust, as well as strategic negotiations over the share price and break-up fee. “Our
philosophy was very simple,” Zell explained. “What we really wanted to do was to create an auction with
a floor.” The events culminated in a so-called “godfather offer” from Blackstone that no public company
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Samuel Zell & Tom Kinnear Panel: Venture Capital
Jim Adox
pp.16-
could responsibly refuse and, ultimately, became the biggest leveraged buyout in history.
Zell wound up his narrative, saying, “It’s all about certainty, about eliminating the options and about intelli-
gently assessing risk as it should be.” He candidly admitted that the Blackstone-Office Equity transaction
could not have been done today, because the risk premiums have widened out dramatically and the availabil-
ity of capital is constrained. “The market today is relatively paralyzed and is trying to assess and identify the
new definitions of risk,” he said. “There is no shortage of liquidity; in fact, there is a surplus of liquidity that
will exist in 2007 and for a number of years. I think the current situation will end up being relatively benign.
The result, when it’s all said and done, is that debt will end up in a more stable, more conservative financial
environment, which is nothing but A-1 for our country.” Zell observed that the U.S. is growing and will con-
tinue to grow. The dramatic growth occurring outside the U.S., and the fact that the U.S. is less pressured to
be the engine of growth, is a very positive thing, he concluded.
During the morning, four concurrent panel discussions examined strategies for launching new businesses on
the cheap, growing start-ups, investing and pursuing career paths in venture capital and applying “intrapre-
neurship” and innovation across industries.
Panel: Build, Fund & Grow Winning Start-Ups
At the “Build, Fund & Grow Winning Start-ups” panel, successful entrepreneurs and venture capitalists discussed
the building blocks of new companies and strategies for overcoming common hurdles. “The ability to recruit and
retain people is essential for any CEO,” remarked Jennifer Baird, president and CEO of Accuri Cytometers Inc.
“Look for individuals who have your same values, work ethic and goals, but complementary skill sets. You don’t
want clones of yourself.” Richard Sheridan, president and CEO of Menlo Innovations, recommended that newly
minted CEOs work at recruiting and extending their networks 24/7, even when they are not hiring.
The panelists agree that attracting the necessary talent when a new company’s financial resources are slim
or nonexistent can be a challenge. “We generally didn’t pay people much at the beginning,” recalled David
Hartmann, founder and president of Arbor Blue. “As a CEO, you want to attract people who don’t need a lot
of pay, but who get excited about the adventure.” He characterized the state of Michigan as a great place to
launch “real companies with real products and real customers,” in part because it has a large pool of skilled
labor and many engineering and manufacturing resources. Hartmann also underscored the importance of
selecting board members and advisers who can bring “in the trenches” experience to a young company and
help it move forward.
In terms of funding, Baird acknowledged that it is very difficult for first-timers to “jump straight into the VC
world,” so she advised looking for federal grants and angel investors with discretionary money to invest. “You
should try to identify one key lead investor who knows other investors and will bring them along,” she said.
Baird also cautioned against “founder-itis,” a condition that prevents company founders and founding board
members from stepping aside and allowing the influx of new talent when it’s needed at different stages of
development. Sheridan urged entrepreneurs to weigh the pros and cons of pursuing venture capital money.
“Don’t take it, if you don’t need it,” he said. “VC money comes with a great deal of responsibility.”
Panel: Venture Capital Investing & Careers
The panelists shared their ideas about cultivating customers. “The best way to start a company is with a
customer rather than with an idea,” Hartmann argued. “Make time for sales calls every day. If you can find a
kingpin customer in your market and tip him over, you are on your way.” Baird urged CEOs to get customers
involved from the very beginning. “Along the way, we involved a lot of customers in the development of our
product and they became the champions for it,” she remarked.
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Panel: Launching on the Cheap
Brad Keywell, Parijat Gandhi, Barrett Davie
Panel: Winning Start-ups
Richard Sheridan, David Hartmann, Michael Callas, Jennifer Baird
17
At the “Venture Capital Investing & Careers” panel, venture capital fund managers revealed some of the
criteria they utilize in creating portfolios of companies. “You choose an industry, pick a stage and then
focus on a geographical area,” said Mina Sooch, founder and general partner of Apjohn Ventures. She told
the audience that her activities as a venture capitalist fall into four different categories: looking for and
sourcing deals, working with her existing portfolio companies to help them advance, running the opera-
tions of her VC firm and raising money from pension funds, endowments, and private investors who must
be convinced they will receive a good return. “You need skill sets to cover all four areas,” she noted. “It’s
not just about doing deals.”
Jim Adox, managing director of Venture Investors, observed that the number of venture funds in existence
today is only half of what it was at the peak of the dot-com bubble in 2000-2001 when 1,200 funds
were doing deals. Tom Wasserman, managing director of Constellation Ventures, argued that expectations
got out of whack in that highly charged environment. “A lot of guys came in with a lot of money,” he said.
“They invested it, built a little bit and sold quickly. People forgot that you have to grow a company. If
you’re looking for a quick exit, go to Vegas.”
The panelists agreed that the path to venture capital is more of a random walk than a straight sprint.
Mahendra Ramsinghani, senior vice resident of Plymouth Venture Partners, suggested that individuals
seeking to break into the VC industry hone their skills in modeling and financial forecasting, develop expertise in
a specialized domain such as clean technology, acquire an operational background and raise their awareness of
macro trends and leading companies in their chosen sector. Adox said, “Every VC partnership is different, so
you have to understand what value you bring to that partnership and how you match up with what the partner-
ship is looking for.” He also noted the importance of the EQ, or “emotional quotient,” which involves working
constructively with other people. Wasserman stressed the overarching need for building relationships and
networks through “spidering out” of your existing personal and professional circle of contacts. The panelists
predicted the next big trends in venture capital would include a focus on clean technology, the Web 2.0,
biotech and health care products, and increased fund investments in China and India.
Keynote Speaker: Kevin O’Connor, Co-Founder & Former CEO & Chairman, Doubleclick;
O’Connor Ventures
The morning session of Entrepalooza 2007 culminated with some tips for increasing the chances of entre-
preneurial success from keynote speaker Kevin O’Connor, the co-founder and former CEO and chairman of
DoubleClick Inc. and currently the head of O’Connor Ventures. “The odds are against you,” O’Connor told
his audience, but added that entrepreneurs have a better chance of succeeding if they identify a problem
and find a way to solve it 10 times better than their competitors or at one-tenth the cost. “Trends always
start very slowly and end bigger,” he remarked, pointing to the success of Google, which eventually sur-
passed the success of earlier search engine firms. O’Connor recommended brainstorming to generate lots
of ideas, then culling and focusing on the best three and vetting those to assure no one else has already
developed them.
As a venture investor, he said he likes a short, tightly focused business plan with a sexy executive sum-
mary that will grab his attention. He also steers away from early-stage ventures, preferring companies that
already have built and sold their products. O’Connor advised entrepreneurs to approach relatives and
angel investors for money, to hire “smart athletes” with overall intelligence rather than people with specific
skills, and to be willing to work 100 hours a week. “So, the odds may be against you, but the rewards at
the end of the day definitely outweigh those odds,” he concluded.
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Kevin O’Connor Tim Faley & Wesley Hufstutter
pp.18-
Michigan Growth Capital Symposium:
Draws Investors from Across the U.S.
With Michigan’s economy struggling under the cloud of a subprime mortgage and housing foreclosure crisis,
coupled with slowing business activity and mounting job losses, the 2008 Michigan Growth Capital
Symposium offered an optimistic outlook for the state’s eventual recovery. The annual two-day event, now in
its 27th year, attracted nearly 400 participants to the Marriott Eagle Crest Conference Center in Ypsilanti,
Michigan, on May 14 and 15. Seven panels of experts drawn from the entrepreneurial, venture investing, legal
and government sectors discussed a wide range of issues, and 30 promising early stage companies made
presentations. Two keynote speakers, Alan G. Walton of Oxford Bioscience Partners and Kenneth R. Pelowski
of Pinnacle Ventures, offered their views of biotechnology and venture investing opportunities, respectively,
and both received the Leaders and Best Award.
“Per square foot, there is more enthusiasm and positive thinking about Michigan and the Midwest here than
anywhere else in 500 square miles,” observed Dr. David J. Brophy, director and founder of the symposium
and professor of finance at the Stephen M. Ross School of Business at the University of Michigan. Innovation,
hard work and financing provided the rallying point for this year’s symposium and demonstrated an alignment
of entrepreneurial enterprise and venture capital, he noted.
The event was presented by the Center for Venture Capital and Private Equity Finance of the Samuel Zell and
Robert H. Lurie Institute for Entrepreneurial Studies at the Ross School of Business.
Keynote Speaker: Alan G. Walton, Senior General Partner, Oxford Bioscience Partners
The sequencing of the human and other genomes, and the development of associated technologies, have been
the driving force behind the meteoric rise of biotechnology, said Alan G. Walton, the senior general partner in
Oxford Bioscience Partners, a life sciences venture capital firm with offices on the East and West coasts. Over
the span of his distinguished career, the English-born Walton has pioneered advancements in biotechnology as
a scientific researcher, university professor, U.S. Presidential science advisor, biotech company founder and
now, venture capital investor. He was presented with the Leaders and Best Award by MGCS founder and
Ross School finance professor David J. Brophy in recognition of his accomplishments.
During his keynote remarks, Walton predicted that biotechnology advancements will bring major changes in
four key areas over the next 50 years. “Most major human diseases will be treated, controlled or prevented by
biotechology products and methods,” Walton said. “Most of the world’s food supply will be more plentiful,
nutritious and disease resistant through biotech products.” He also predicted that a significant portion of the
world’s energy will come from genetic engineering and that molecular computers will be based on biological
molecules. “My prediction is that this will be the biotechnology century,” he said.
From a venture investing perspective, Walton observed there are two key investment strategies in the biotech-
nology sector. “One is to come up with the newest, latest and best thinking that is enabling technology, or you
can head down the public route, although the public isn’t interested in technology and doesn’t understand it,”
he said. “Oxford’s strategy has been to try to come up with revolutionary technologies.” Last year, Oxford
funded and sold a new technology called RNAI developed by Sirna; a rapid gene sequencing methodology
developed by Solexa, an English biotech firm; and an ultra-rapid vaccine formation company. “Although we
have a lot of failures, these huge sales of new technology have been the mantra at Oxford,” Walton said.
He noted that biotechnology has a history of four-year cycles. “Right now, in 2008, we have no IPOs, and
companies are running out of cash,” he said. “Things are looking a little bit grim. But if you believe the
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Alan Walton Energy Panel Members Life Sciences Panel Members
19
cycling, then at the end of the year and into 2009, biotech is set to come back again. I hope that gives us a
little bit of enthusiasm.” Although major technological breakthroughs in commercial bioscience have been
largely hidden from the public in the last few years, Walton said he anticipates these advances will inevitably
cause an economic shift to those centers where these technologies are employed. Commenting on the most
likely commercial successes in the energy side of the biotech equation, he dismissed the hydrogen highway as
“dreaming” and said, “Unfortunately, we’ll have to go to non-corn-based ethanol in the short run and use that
until we can build nuclear reactors that will take over, as they have in France and Japan.”
Panel: Creating A Clean Tech Cluster In Michigan And The Midwest
Michigan’s skilled workforce, plentiful natural resources, strong research community and deep manufacturing
expertise in the automotive and chemical industries provide a solid platform for creating a thriving clean tech
sector, said a panel of private and public technology investment managers and economic development leaders.
“We think there are three or four major sectors that present opportunities,” said Ananth Ananthasubramaniam,
manager of technology investments for DTE Energy, which has invested $100 million in the alternative energy
space. The “greening of the grid” will stimulate a growing market for renewable energy sources, such solar,
wind and biomass, he said, and increased concern about energy efficiency, management and storage will drive
new technologies in those areas. Alternative fuels also offer great possibilities for innovative companies and
forward-thinking venture investors. Through its Centers of Energy Excellence initiative, the Michigan Economic
Development Corporation is striving to grow a clean tech industry cluster by attracting high-potential compa-
nies to Michigan, connecting them with the right partners and then brokering the deals, explained Douglas
Parks, vice president of new market development. Colin South, president of Mascoma Corp., which focuses on
cellulosic ethanol production, reported that the supply chain and knowledge base in Michigan initially attracted
his company to the state. To move the needle toward clean tech, the panelists said, will require a variety of
financing sources and combinations, including venture capital, asset investment and the public markets.
Companies seeking venture capital dollars will need to identify disruptive technologies that are sustainable and
offer more than incremental improvements over existing ones, advised Mike Melnick of CMEA Ventures. He
said that the management team’s capabilities and the scalability of the market also must be considered.
Panel: Investment In Life Science Companies
Establishing strong investment partnerships is critical for entrepreneurial companies in the highly competitive
life sciences sector, but this can be challenging. “As the CEO, you are going to be raising money all the time,”
observed Douglas Onsi of HealthCare Ventures. “Don’t give up the first time some investor passes, but be
realistic. Think about how your company creates value and then go to the places where people recognize that
value.” Robert More, a partner at Domain Associates, advised entrepreneurs to focus on their particular area of
expertise and to work initially through local channels in the venture investing community. “You’d better be the
best at what you do, because you’re competing globally now, not regionally,” he said. “Know the kind of deals
a venture capital firm is doing and find out who your deal champion is going to be before you go to that first
meeting.” Venture capital firms considering investments in nontraditional geographical areas typically look for
entrepreneurs who can execute well on a plan and convey a desire to collaborate on a project, said Nina
Kjellson of InterWest Partners. “It’s important to align the interests of the investor and the inventor,” she
explained. “I also encourage entrepreneurs, scientists and institutions that help entrepreneurs to think through
the early team building and to consider how this enterprise will scale from two or three people to a successful
company.” In cases where there is not be a good fit with venture investors, Kjellson suggested exploring alter-
native funding sources, such as foundations, grant-making nonprofit organizations and government agencies.
Panel: Venture Capital Investment Strategy
Venture capital investments play an important role in the diversification of overall investment portfolios, but
fund managers often differ on their selection criteria and allocation strategies. “Venture investing fits me and
what I like to do,” said Michael Jandernoa, who straddles both sides of the investment fence as the former
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Preparing for Venture Financing Panel Members Acquirers View Panel Members Presenting Company
pp.20-
CEO of the Michigan-based drug manufacturer Perrigo Company and now as the co-founder of both Bridge
Street Capital Partners and Grand Angels. “In Michigan, we have a tremendous history of entrepreneurs and
many young people with great ideas. If we can give them the proper financial support and guidance, it will
increase their chances for success.” While fund performance is critical, Jose Fernandez of StepStone indicated
his firm is willing to consider first-time funds, if the emerging manager has had sufficient work experience
and can show a differentiated strategy and access to deal flow. However, he cautioned managers about glossing
over mistakes and using creative marketing to hide any shortfalls when talking to investment firms. Kevin
Fedewa of the State of Michigan Retirement System reported that declining fund sizes have resulted in “a pretty
big hit to our exposure to venture.” Although most of the venture funds in which he invests are on the East and
West coasts, he noted that general partners are starting to fly to Michigan and the Midwest. Jon Norris of SVB
Capital said he sees great opportunities to get involved with early stage funds in the Midwest, despite recent
turmoil in the economic environment. “We’re seeing some interesting plays and becoming more active in providing
banking services on both the VC and PE sides,” he said.
Keynote Speaker: Kenneth R. Pelowski, Founder and Managing Partner, Pinnacle Ventures
In venture capital investing, the top firms tend to produce the majority of industry profits and are able to
perpetuate their high-flying success through repeat business, said Kenneth R. Pelowski, the founder and
managing partner of Pinnacle Ventures, a Palo Alto, California-based private venture capital fund. “From 1997
to 2004, 50 venture investing firms, representing 4% of 1,200 firms, produced 77% of the profits in the
industry,” he said. “Of those, 20 to 25 firms, only 2%, produced almost 80% of the profits. What’s more,
those top 50 firms have increased their share of the pot. I believe this trend will continue.”
This top-heavy scenario presents an interesting dilemma for companies in Michigan that want to get connected
with one of those top 25 firms, Pelowski observed. “It’s possible, but it’s not easy,” he said, noting that some
bright spots appear on the horizon. “I believe there is more activity in Michigan than most people are aware of,
and certainly there are some well-known exits. There is starting to be some recognition in Silicon Valley of
what we call high quality deals and exits in the state. That’s really important, because without it, it’s really hard
to attract capital.” Pelowski, who grew up in Michigan and received his electrical engineering undergraduate
degree and MBA from the University of Michigan, also noted that University research efforts and state initiatives,
such as the Michigan 21st Century Investment Fund, are helping to move things in the right direction. “I owe a
lot to the University and the state, because I was educated and trained here,” he said. “I have expertise in
startups and venture capital that I think will help the University take world-class research and commercialize it,
which will help the state’s economy as well.”
Pelowski, who is now launching his fifth startup, outlined what it takes to present and to successfully receive
capital from some of the premier venture firms in the country. “It starts with really good technology,” he said.
“And that technology has to have differentiation, be protected and create barriers. But what really matters most
is that a company has to make a great product — not a good product, not a nice feature extension of a prod-
uct, but a great product. And it has to have a big market — a billion a year. Below $500 million, it is not going
to be ready, and from $500 million to a billion, it’s possibly ready.” Without these large opportunities, Pelowski
said, the venture capital community cannot make the returns it needs. People who have proven experience as
entrepreneurs, he added, are also an important part of the equation. “One of the greatest risk factors we have in a
deal is a first-time CEO,” he said. “It’s a huge ‘con’ in our analysis because the risk of their raising capital is huge.”
Looking forward, Pelowski predicted that the trend toward venture investing in the health care and energy areas
will play out well in Michigan, in part because the University has doubled its research spending in those two
areas and the state is known for its core competencies in alternative energy, transportation and health care.
“What we see — and thus what we think is the opportunity and why we come here — is a huge intersection,
for the first time in my lifetime, of what Michigan is good at and what is important or interesting to the venture
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Venture Capital Panel Members Ken Pelowski & David Brophy Emerging Tech Panel Members
21
community. I think that’s a huge opportunity for the state.” At the conclusion of his remarks, Pelowski was pre-
sented with the Leaders and Best Award by MGCS founder and Ross School finance professor David J. Brophy.
Panel: Emerging Technologies And Opportunities
Emerging technologies offer a nearly unlimited horizon of entrepreneurial and venture investing opportunities,
but tapping into that deep pool of possibilities requires creative thinking, perseverance and the right synergies,
said a panel of industry experts. “We invest in early stage companies with really disruptive technologies,” said
Annette Finsterbusch of Applied Ventures, who has focused on plays in energy storage, energy conversion and
solar and non-solar fuel cells. With a background in software, business advisor and investor John Lovitt said
he looks for products that represent the marriage of different technologies to solve some problem or to capture
the “explosion of knowledge.” After 35 years at Johnson Controls, Thomas Dougherty believes many opportu-
nities can be leveraged from the automotive sector where his new startup company, Monolith Engines, is
developing specialized batteries and capacitors for use in electric and hybrid cars. Although rising gas prices
will likely foster more creativity, Dougherty expressed concern about the long lead times for product develop-
ment and the “missing conduit” to get new products through tier 1 and 2 suppliers to OEM manufacturers.
Andrew Basile Jr., a West Coast attorney, said that Michigan firms could get more traction by sticking with
secondary and tertiary entrepreneurial activities, such as service companies. “I’ve concluded that we [in
Michigan] are not poised to exploit the Silicon Valley model of new company creation,” he said. “We need to
have smaller companies doing smaller deals.” In addition to utilizing the existing expertise in the automotive
industry, he suggested new ventures might capitalize on opportunities associated with aging Baby Boomers by
focusing on the personalized delivery of health care services into homes.
Panel: Preparing Your Company For Its Initial Venture Financing
Seeking venture financing may or may not be the right decision for an entrepreneurial company, said panelists
who represented both the giving and receiving ends of the deal making. Although the infusion of capital may
benefit an early stage venture, “there is no free lunch,” cautioned Doug Camitta of the law firm Pepper
Hamilton. “How you run the company will change when you sign up with a venture capitalist. There will be
oversight and information reporting requirements.” Serial entrepreneur Vinay Gupta, who is now on his fifth
startup, Janeeva, said the decision often depends on whether a great deal of money is required to bootstrap a
new venture and whether the entrepreneur is willing to give up equity in return for venture financing. Rand
Mueller, the CEO and co-founder of Guidepoint Systems, said he used venture capital financing in half of the
13 companies he has started thus far. “Find the money guy who understands your business and vision, and be
sure you have good chemistry with them,” he advised. “Some fit, some don’t.” Venture capitalists, on the other
hand, are looking for good deals that will pay off for their own investors. “Can your business be sold for $250
million?” asked Jeff Bocan of Beringea. “VCs want to make 10 times their money back, so that’s the point
where a deal becomes attractive.” Getting in the door of a venture capital firm is often the hardest first step,
however. “This is a people business,” Camitta said. “To get into a VC firm, figure out whom you want to meet
and who knows that person and can introduce you.” Dave Fachetti of Globespan Capital Partners advised
entrepreneurs to investigate other factors such as sector expertise, fund cycle and recent deals to determine
how their company would fit into the venture firm’s investment mix.
Panel: Lessons From The Trenches: The Outlook For U.S. Venture Capital
Faced with overheated competition in Silicon Valley and other research corridors and triangles, venture capital
investors are turning their attention to Michigan and the Midwest, a panel of venture investors said. “We don’t
want to compete on the basis of term sheets with wonderful firms along Boston’s 128 Corridor because deals
are too high priced,” said Jeanne Sullivan, a general partner of StarVest Partners in New York City. “We want
to look for companies in underserved areas where people are looking for investors. We’re seeking strong entre-
preneurial and operating experience that comes out of the technology area.” Koleman Karleski of Chrysalis
Ventures, which has offices in Kentucky and Ohio, observed there is a mismatch between investment activity
and assets in the middle part of the U.S., where 22 or 23 states receive only 15% of the venture capital dol-
lars. “That’s the reason we’re here,” he said. Although venture investors are now more willing to travel to the
Midwest from the East and West coasts in search of the best companies, many prefer to partner with locally
based venture capital firms. “We like to have a strong local partner on the ground here, especially when we’re
investing in an early stage venture,” said Alison de Bord of San Francisco-based Alta Partners. David Parsigian,
a partner at the law firm of Honigman Miller Schwartz and Cohn, noted that “things are a lot different in
Michigan than they were five years ago.” The more widespread availability of capital is helping to spur the
growth of firms that can help entrepreneurial companies, he said, adding, “We have great critical mass grow-
ing in our region.” One of the biggest challenges facing venture capital firms is defining their sector focus. “At
the end of the day, we’re all trying to figure out where the puck is headed and how to carve out some sub-sec-
tor,” Karleski said. “Being diversified helps us to avoid pitfalls.”
pp.22-
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
23
Turning Business Dreams
into Reality
Michael Edison, MBA/MS ’08
I came to Michigan to pursue a dual master’s degree
in business and natural resources and environment
through the Erb Institute for Global Sustainable
Enterprise. My interest in entrepreneurship was
piqued by the realization that new business ideas and
models will be needed to create a more sustainable
future. Through the Zell Lurie Institute, my partner
and I received a $2,500 Dare to Dream grant to help
us develop our concept for a “green” building prod-
ucts store. We honed our business plan and pitch at
the Michigan Business Challenge and received help-
ful feedback. As a Marcel Gani intern with Energy
Conversion Devices, I sharpened my skills in evalu-
ating the market potential, financing options and
resources needed to launch new businesses in the
renewable energy technologies industry.
Maya Patel, BBA ’08
I transferred to the Ross School of Business from
the College of Literature, Science and the Arts in my
junior year. I was attracted to the Ross School by its
structured coursework, excellent career counseling
and helpful workshops on resume writing and inter-
view techniques. My decision was also impacted by
the many success stories I’d heard about people who
have graduated from the School. Over the summer, I
landed a Marcel Gani Internship at GoKnow!, an Ann
Arbor-based, K-12 educational software company,
where I helped to formulate and implement its first
real sales-marketing plan. This experience gave me
an insider’s view of the challenges faced by a small
entrepreneurial company.
Mike Lung, MBA ’08
The opportunity to serve on the Wolverine Venture
Fund initially attracted me to Michigan’s Ross
School of Business. Over the past year, I have
learned how to evaluate new businesses, as well
as the process venture funds utilize to source new
deals. My WVF background enabled me to land
a Marcel Gani Internship at Plymouth Venture
Partners, an Ann Arbor-based mezzanine fund, where
I am performing investment due diligence and
financial analysis. My internship has broadened my
investment skill set and career options, and will
help me secure a full-time position in traditional or
alternative investments after I graduate.
S
t
u
d
e
n
t
S
h
o
w
c
a
s
e
Excitement about Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Investment continues to flourish at Michigan.
Students who wish to learn more about the Institute and its Center for Venture Capital and Private
Equity Finance may schedule an office hours appointment with a staff member online at www.zli.bus.
umich.edu. Business leaders who would like to become involved as a mentor, tap the unique skill-set of
our students for a project, or participate in an upcoming event, may contact us at [email protected]
for further information on how to get involved.
ADVISORY BOARD
Keith Alessi, Westmoreland Coal Company
Eugene Applebaum, Arbor Investments Group
John Barfield, The Bartech Group, Inc.
Jonn Behrman, Serial Entrepreneur
D. Theodore Berghorst, Vector Securities International, LLC
Paul Brentlinger, Morgenthaler Ventures
Kenneth Buckfire, Miller Buckfire & Co., LLC
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures, LP
Dwight Carlson, Coherix, Inc.
Thomas Darden Jr., Reliant Equity Investors
Hal Davis, Entrepreneur & Investor
Richard Eidswick, Arbor Partners
Stanley Frankel, Frankel Associates
Marcel Gani, Santa Clara University
Jan Garfinkle, Arboretum Ventures
Michael Hallman, The Hallman Group
John Kennedy, Autocam Corporation
Bradley Keywell, Echo Global Logistics, LLC
Hans Koch, K2K Development, LLC
Ann Lurie, Lurie Investments
Steven McKean, Acceller, Inc.
Clyde E. McKenzie, Tellurex Corporation
Mitch Mondry, M Group, Inc.
Marvin Parnes, University of Michigan
Richard Rogel, Tomay, Inc.
Michael Staebler, Pepper Hamilton, LLP
Maria A. Thompson, T/J Technologies
Samuel Valenti III, Valenti Capital
Ronald N. Weiser, Ambassador, McKinley Associates, Inc.
Jeffrey Williams, HandyLab, Inc.
Warren P. Williamson, Skye Management
Samuel Zell, Equity Group Investments
Thomas Zurbuchen, University of Michigan
701 Tappan Street
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1234
(734) 615-4419
www.zli.bus.umich.edu
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Robert J. Dolan President, Zell Lurie Institute
Thomas Kinnear (ex-officio), Department of Marketing
Timothy Faley (ex-officio)
David Brophy Department of Finance
Michael Gordon Department of Business Information Technology
Andy Lawlor Department of Strategy
Len Middleton Department of Strategy
James Price Department of Entrepreneurial Studies
STAFF
Thomas Kinnear, Executive Director
Timothy Faley, Managing Director
David J. Brophy, Center for Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance
Thomas S. Porter, Executive in Residence
Mary Nickson, Communications Manager, M Entrepreneur Editor
Paul Kirsch, Program Manager
Rachel Ulrich, Program Coordinator
Marybeth Davis, Program Assistant
Carolyn Maguire, Administrator
doc_759502537.pdf
In this particular brief criteria around the entrepreneurial concepts and practical field based knowledge.
Entrepreneur
FROM THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
THOMAS C. KINNEAR
The entrepreneurial concepts and practical field-based
knowledge that Zell Lurie-focused Ross students
are exposed to, create graduates for placement with
innovative, entrepreneurial companies and with
venture capital firms. Within these pages you can
explore a sampling of businesses that Ross School
students have been creating and some of their bold
new ideas. Thank you for your continued support
and participation. It is through the continued engage-
ment of business and investment leaders, as well
as our alumni community, that we are able to prepare
our students for entrepreneurial success.
IN THIS ISSUE
Awards & Scholarships
Action Based Learning Initiatives
Wolverine Venture Fund
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Internships
Business Plan Competitions
Dare to Dream Student Start-up Grants
EMAP - Entrepreneurial Multidisciplinary
Action Projects
Entrepreneurial & Venture Capital Courses
Entrepreneur & Venture Club Highlights
Entrepalooza Symposium
Michigan Growth Capital Symposium
Student Showcase
Zell Lurie Institute/Center for Venture Capital
& Private Equity Finance Year-in-Review
FALL 2007/WINTER 2008
www.zli.bus.umich.edu
& V e n t u r e C a p i t a l
Awards & Scholarships: Celebrating Outstanding
Entrepreneurial Student Leaders at Ross
The following awards were made possible through the generosity of Ron and Eileen
Weiser. Recipients were selected based in part on their ambassadorship, passion for
entrepreneurship and academic excellence.
Entrepreneur of the Year Award for an MBA - $1,000
Heath Silverman’s (MBA ’08) ever burgeoning entrepreneurial mind found many outlets for the application
and development of new business ideas as he moved through the process of earning his MBA. Silverman
took the opportunity to further his entrepreneurial knowledge and experience through his participation as
co-president of the Entrepreneur & Venture Club, chair of the Entrepalooza symposium, a member of the
Frankel Commercialization Fund, a Michigan Business Challenge winner, and as a recipient of a Dare to
Dream grant.
Merrill Guerra (MBA ’08) took the reins to realize her dream and launched RealKidz Clothing while earning
her degree. She credits her summer internship experience at a start-up company, SpiritShop founded by
Todd Sullivan (MBA ’05), as having provided her with a large part of the foundation for her launch. Her
business launch efforts were further supported through enrollment in a new venture creation course,
receiving a Dare to Dream grant, and participation in the Michigan Business Challenge.
Cause-Based Entrepreneurial Leadership Award - $1,000
Chris Genteel (MBA ’08) took his passion for driving forward new ideas and creating enterprise to win a
Dare to Dream grant and participate in the Michigan Business Challenge during his first year at Ross.
That passion combined with his tremendous leadership skills also saw the creation of the Arts Enterprise
Club which joins Ross students with students at the School of Music, Theatre and Dance to explore
new careers by working in a cross-disciplinary manner. As a graduate of Ross, Chris envisions and is
fostering the development necessary for the Club to become a national organization.
Entrepreneur of the Year Award for a BBA - $500 each
Jared Ailstock and Mark Thompson (BBAs ’08) will have extraordinary impact on the business world
bringing to it their entrepreneurial spirit and vision for new business creation. As a sophomore Jared was
involved in developing the business plan for Red Baron Rocks for which he won first place at the
Nebraska business plan competition. During his senior year, Mark Thompson partnered with Jared to
develop VidFlips. Mark had conceived the idea for the company several years ago and led a team of
BBAs to develop a full business plan for it. The team presented VidFlips at this year’s Michigan Business
Challenge and placed in the semi-finals.
A
w
a
r
d
s
&
S
c
h
o
l
a
r
s
h
i
p
s
Jared Ailstock & Mark Thompson Merrill Guerra Heath Silverman
pp.2-
A
w
a
r
d
s
&
S
c
h
o
l
a
r
s
h
i
p
s
Scholarships
The following scholarship recipients proved
themselves both in the classroom and as
entrepreneurial leaders. Each recipient main-
tained a meritorious GPA while succeeding
in previous or ongoing entrepreneurial activity.
Samuel Zell Scholarship Awards
$10,000
Joseph Ferencz, MBA ’09
Katie Miller, MBA ’09
Marcin Wojtczak, MBA ’09
$5,000
Jennifer Anderson, MBA ’08
Ryan Baxter, MBA ’08
Jason Dishlip, MBA ’08
Robert Fetter, MBA ’08
Vanessa Frey, MBA ’08
Adam Litle, MBA ’08
Aaron Nelson, MBA/MA ’09
Heath Silverman, MBA ’08
Vikram Vaishya, MBA ’08
Zell & Erb Institute Entrepreneurial
Scholars
$5,000
Brewster Boyd, MBA/MS ’09
Michael Edison, MBA/MS ’09
Matt Garratt, MBA/MS ’09
Zell & NPM Entrepreneurial
Nonprofit Scholars
$5,000
Chris Genteel, MBA ’08
Rabindar Subbian, MBA/MSW ’08
Mitchell A. Mondry Scholarship
Awards
$5,000
Punit Chiniwalla, MBA ’08
Merrill Guerra, MBA ’08
Institute Scholar
Elisabeth Smith, MBA ’09
Scholarship Recipients:
(Top Row) Joseph Ferencz, Robert Fetter, Chris Genteel, Rabindar Subbian,
Brewster Boyd, Aaron Nelson, Adam Litle, Matt Garratt (Middle Row) Punit
Chiniwalla, Heath Silverman, Katie Miller, Elisabeth Smith, Ryan Baxter,
Vikram Vaishya (Front Row) Jennifer Anderson, Vanessa Frey, Merrill Guerra,
Michael Edison, Jason Dishlip
3
W
o
l
v
e
r
i
n
e
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
F
i
m
d
Wolverine Venture Fund: Student Managed Fund Fuels
Entrepreneurial Enterprise by Making Six Strategic Investments
Created in 1997, the Wolverine Venture Fund (WVF) continues to be the only completely student directed
venture fund associated with a business school. The $3.5 million venture capital fund, administered by
the Zell Lurie Institute, takes the business-development process to the next level by making early-stage
and follow-on investments in young companies in the healthcare, high technology, and clean tech industries.
The WVF students undertake rigorous due diligence in support of the Fund’s investment decisions. At
this time, the Fund has active investments in ten firms. During the ’07-’08 academic year, the WVF made
three new investments: Accord Biomaterials, Quantum Learning Technologies, and IntelePeer; and three
follow-on investments: Direct Flow Medical, Nanocerox, and Mobius Microsystems.
Accord Biomaterials Inc. is a Michigan-based company that focuses upon the development of catalytic
nitric oxide coatings for blood-contacting medical devices. These coatings address serious complications
related to clotting and altered healing with technology licensed from the University of Michigan.
Direct Flow Medical is a California-based medical device that is developing a stentless system for the
percutaneous replacement of the aortic heart valve.
IntelePeer is a California-based VoIP managed-service provider offering global peering infrastructure,
network interoperability, industry-leading quality of service, and advanced VoIP-enabled applications.
Mobius Microsystems is a California and Michigan-based company that empowers integrated circuit
designers and manufacturers to achieve previously unattainable levels of analog and mixed-signal integration
across all process technologies.
Nanocerox is a Michigan-based company that produces mixed metal oxide nanoscale ceramic powders.
These materials have a wide variety of applications, including military armor, laser lighting components,
sensors, and anti-counterfeiting.
Quantum Learning Technologies is a Michigan-based online educational community that enables children
to reach their academic potential by embedding scientifically-based educational activities in engaging,
interactive programs that incorporate computer game design techniques.
Venture Fund Management
Thirty-five MBA students manage the Fund, supported by Tom Kinnear, the Fund’s Managing Director,
and a nine member advisory board of professional venture capitalists and entrepreneurs. Collectively, the
students bring to the table broad-based experience in fields such as biotechnology, software, investment
banking, intellectual property law, semiconductors, software, chemical engineering, marketing, and
medical devices. The Fund typically provides $50,000 to $200,000 in seed and first-stage funding
rounds and co-investing in partnership with institutional venture capital firms.
“My participation in the Wolverine Venture Fund has been the highlight of my action-based learning
experience at the Ross School of Business. Evaluating potential investments has fostered continuous
learning through interaction with the fund advisors and with talented, motivated students. Most impor-
tantly, the WVF has helped me develop judgment by analyzing deals in a rigorous and structured manner
and leading decisions resulting in real investments.”
-Munish Gandhi, MBA ’07
Wolverine Venture Fund Student and
Advisory Board Members
pp.4-
W
o
l
v
e
r
i
n
e
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
F
i
m
d
Wolverine Venture Fund Investment Activity
Portfolio Investments Investment Partners
Quantum Learning Technologies April 2008 RPM Ventures
Accord Biomaterials April 2008 Arboretum Ventures, Sigvion Capital
IntelePeer January 2008 EDF Ventures, Kennet Venture Partners, IVA Fund,
Vogen Fund, Black Steel Investments
Direct Flow Medical March 2005, September 2007 EDF Ventures, Spray Ventures,
Johnson & Johnson Development,
Foundation Medical Partners, Vantage Point,
ePlanet
HandyLab Inc. August 2000, November 2001, EDF Ventures, Arboretum Ventures, Ardesta,
June 2002, May 2004, December 2005 Pfizer Ventures
SilverPop Systems August 2000 Draper Fisher Jurvetson
Mobius Microsystems, April 2004, November 2007 Waypoint Ventures, Angel Funds, Menlo Ventures,
Foundation Ventures
Nanocerox, Inc. November 2005, December 2006, Angel Funds
May 2008
NanoBio March 2006 Angel Funds, Perseus LLC
Rhevision Technology March 2006 EDF Ventures, In-Q-Tel Ventures
Fund Award Recipients
Catherine Lee and Vikram Vaishya (MBAs ’08) were honored with the David Shelby Award for their outstanding
leadership of the Fund, in honor of the WVF’s first alumni manager and co-founder, David Shelby.
Wolverine Venture Fund
Student Members
MBAs ’08
Ryan Baxter
Erin Cready
Shantanu Dhamija
David Forsythe
John Gearen (MBA/MS ’08)
Karl Kyriss
Catherine Lee
Eugene Lee
Jing Liang
Adam Litle (MBA/JD ’08)
Shripal Meghani
Kati Prause
Deborah Robbins
Sahana Shetty
Puneet Singh
Vikram Vaishya
Devi Vijayakumari
Sriram Viji
Christopher Wilson
Jason Yang
MBAs ’09
Justin Adams
Julia Choi
Meghan Cuddihy (Ph.D. Candidate)
Anne Delaney
Himayat Khan
Jeffrey Lebrun (MBA/MS ’09)
Joseph Malcoun (MBA/MS ’09)
Josh Mandel-Brehm
Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
Seema Prasad
Nate Schmid
Renata Soares (MBA/MS ’09)
Nathaniel Troup
Christopher Whitehead
Advisory Board
Peter Adriaens, UofM College of Engineering
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures – Alumni Fund Manager
William Johnson, Consultant/Venture Investor
Timothy Mayleben, ElMa Advisors
Timothy Petersen, Arboretum Ventures
Mina Patel Sooch, Apjohn Ventures
Donald Walker, Arbor Partners
Steven Weinstein, Prism Venture Partners
Marc Weiser, RPM Ventures
Faculty/Staff
Thomas Kinnear, Faculty Advisor
Carolyn Maguire, Administrator
5
F
r
a
n
k
e
l
C
o
m
m
e
r
c
i
a
l
i
z
a
t
i
o
n
F
u
n
d
Frankel Commercialization Fund: Student Run Fund
Invests Pre-Seed Money in Two Firms
The Frankel Commercialization Fund is continually seeking opportunities to help jumpstart new companies
in Michigan. Established in 2005, the Fund is believed to be the only student venture capital fund of its
kind with a focus on the commercialization of ideas and development of new companies. Tom Porter,
executive-in-residence at the Zell Luire Institute, serves as the Fund’s director.
The Fund is organized into student teams that function as independently financed venture capital compa-
nies providing very early-stage investing. These teams seek out scientific discoveries and inventions with
commercialization potential at the College of Engineering and the School of Medicine. Once these ideas
have been identified and evaluated, the teams may invest pre-seed money to move the concepts to the
point where they are ready for early-stage venture-capital investment.
Additional mentoring is provided through the Fund’s advisory board comprised of venture capitalists, entre-
preneurs, industry experts and CEOs. Student members of the Fund learn a great deal about technology
commercialization and investment due diligence by working with these companies. They remain actively
involved in monitoring the company’s progress, providing guidance and ensuring the company is adhering
to its milestones to advancing the growth of the company.
This year the Fund announced its first two investments in Arbor Photonics (November 2007) and
BeholzTech Inc. (May 2008).
Arbor Photonics is an Ann Arbor, Michigan-based company that has developed a novel, scalable, optical
fiber technology that enables high-power fiber lasers to be used in a variety of new materials-processing
applications in the automotive, electronics and aerospace industries while offering a lower-cost replacement
to existing bulky laser systems.
BeholzTech Inc. is a Flint, Michigan-based company that effectively coats polyolefin plastics, making them
easier to modify and adhere to other materials. Polyolefins are tiny plastic pellets that are used to make
thousands of products we use everyday.
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Student Members
Health Care
Dan Chagnovich, MBA Eve
Andrew Charnik, MBA ’09
Travis Coy, MBA ’08
Delara Godrej, MBA Eve
Andrew Hastings, MBA ’08
Phil Kowalczyk, MBA ’09
Satchin Master, MBA ’08
Chris Mortis, MBA Eve
Dan Saddawi-Konefka, MBA/MD ’09
Michael Tarasev, MBA Eve
Cleantech
Brewster Boyd, ERB MBA/MS ’09
Laura Bruce, ERB MBA/MS ’10
Siobhan Doherty, ERB MBA/MS ’10
Mike Hartley, ERB MBA/MS ’09
Technology
Mark Birac, MBA Eve
Punit Chiniwalla, MBA ’08
Jason Dishlip, MBA’08
Mike Edison, MBA/ERB ’08
Jessica Goldberg, MBA ’09
Brian Katzman, MBA/ERB ’10
Tom Porter, Andrew Churnite, Laura Bruce, and
Brian Katzman
Student and Advisory Board Members of the Frankel Commercialization Fund
pp.6-
Internships: In the ‘Trenches’ with Entrepreneurs and
Venture Capitalists
The Marcel Gani Summer Internship program places students ‘in the trenches’ with entrepreneurs and inves-
tors at startup companies and venture capital firms from across the U.S. This spring the Institute placed and
funded 19 graduate and undergraduate students among 17 host companies, including seven venture capital
firms. Students typically spend up to 14 weeks in this full-immersion experience where they participate in a
company’s planning and execution, and in an investment firm’s due diligence process for potential investments.
In turn, firms benefit from the students’ management expertise and strategic recommendations they otherwise
might not obtain.
“In addition to the operational experience, I can directly apply the knowledge that I have gained while
matriculating the business program at Ross. Notable classes and experiences include, Corporate Strategy,
Marketing, Valuation, New Venture Creation, and Venture Finance from the Wolverine Venture Fund. I plan
to apply my knowledge to help facilitate ProNAI’s success in obtaining funding and in developing a cancer
agent to treat patients in the future.” – Christopher Whitehead, MBA ’09
Internship Placements 2008
Company Intern
Amherst Fund, LLC – Michigan David Lin, MBA Eve
Apjohn Ventures Fund, LP – Michigan Zakaria Shaikh, MBA ’09
Arboretum Ventures – Michigan Naomita Yadav, MBA ’09
Ascendant Solutions – Texas Bryan Mortenson, MBA ’09
Dusoto – Michigan Christopher Robart, MBA ’09
ePack Corps – Michigan Akshai Rao, MBA ’08
Fry Farms – Ohio Kate Appel, MBA ’10
Inovo – Michigan Manisha Tayal, MBA ’08
MacBeedon Partners, LLC – Michigan Richard Roman, BBA ’10
Mozergy – Michigan Tony Gross, MBA ’08; Jeff Lebrun, MBA ’09
*in partnership with the William Davidson
Instititute and Erb Instititute
Plymouth Venture Partners – Michigan Brewster Boyd, MBA /MS ’09
Project Freestyle – Michigan Michael Parke, BBA ’08
ProNai Therapeutics Chris Whitehead, MBA ’09
Seneca Partners – Michigan Niket Gandhi, MBA ’09
U-M Office of Tech Transfer – Michigan Ian Dailey, MBA ’09;
Natasha Thomas, MBA Eve
uRefer – Michigan Nick Mekas, BBA ’10
Venture Investors – Michigan Michael Tarasev, MBA ’08
7
Katie Miller, MBA ’09
Dinesh Narayan, MBA ’09
Alex Robart, MBA ’09
Heath Silverman, MBA ’08
Advisory Board
Medical Technology/Life Sciences Board
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures
Mary R. Flack, NanoBio
Larry Hagerty, RLP Technologies (sub. of RL Polk)
Michael P. Kurek, Biotechnology Business Consultants
Roger Newton, Investor
Lisa Shapiro, Shapiro Solutions Inc.
Shelby Solomon, Ingenix, Inc.
Technology Board
Jim Adox, Venture Investors
Tony Grover, RPM Ventures
David Hartmann, Arbor Blue, LLC
Al Kortesoya, Formerly Capgemini/Ernst & Young
Chuck Salley, Investor
Gerard P. Spencer, Retired Partner Arthur Andersen
Member-at-Large
Ken Nisbet, U-M Office of Technology Transfer
I
n
t
e
r
n
s
h
i
p
s
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
2008 Michigan Business Challenge
The University of Michigan Business Plan Competition
The Michigan Business Challenge engages students
from across campus through multiple rounds of
competition in which they develop their business
ideas into a sound business plan. The competition
awards over $40,000 in prize money. The competi-
tion process is supported through training and feed-
back offered by judges. In 2007, 36 teams entered
the three-month long contest with the opportunity
to present their business in four rounds of competi-
tion for awards of up to $15,000 in prize money.
25th Pryor-Hale Award for Best Business - $15,000
Outstanding Presentation - $2,500
Army Property: Offers a secure, online, multi-user
inventory management system for individuals in the
Armed Forces to organize, delegate, and account
for military equipment.
Team: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard, Parren James,
Ben Kozma, and Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
Runner-up for Best Business - $5,000
Williamson Award for Outstanding Business and
Engineering Team - $5,000
Erb Award for Sustainability - $5,000
Potentia: Manufacturers a micro fabricated battery-
replacement component to generate power in wireless
sensors by harnessing naturally occurring energy.
Team: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08),
Rishiraj Das (MBA ’08), and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
Outstanding Presentation - $2,500
Best Written Plan - $2,500
Semi-finalist - $500
Hitchsters: Operates a service that connects travel-
ers going to and from major metropolitan airports
so that they can share a cab, split the fare, and
shrink their carbon footprint.
Team: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08),
Jason Lin (MBA ’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
Finalists - $1,000
ePack Corp: Provides a high volume, high yield,
batch mode micro-device packaging for MEMS
manufacturers.
Team: Razi Haque (MBA ’08),
Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08),
Sang Woo Lee, and Michael Urcan (MBA ’08)
Competitions: Combining Entrepreneurial Leadership
Skills and Knowledge with the Ability to Drive Results
With financial support and mentoring from the Institute, undergraduate and graduate
students are encouraged to hone their skills, test new business concepts, expand their
networks and win cash awards by competing in the University’s Michigan Business
Challenge and Quick Pitch Competition, as well as intercollegiate business plan, case
and venture capital competitions.
Org Org: Offers an internet tool for organizations to
communicate with their members and for members
to define their interests in the organization while
networking with and discovering other organizations.
Team: Jennifer Anderson, Abhishek Gopalka,
Lauren Rosenthal, Heath Silverman, and Sriram Viji
(MBAs ’08)
Semi-finalists - $500
Audiallo: Designs biology-inspired, audio processing
technology which targets the hearing-aid and high-end
audio markets.
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
BCCJ Biodiesel: Sells biodiesel fuel reformulated
from waste grease collected from local restaurants
or other food establishments.
Team: James Bucher (Ph.D. ’09), Meghan Cuddihy
(Ph.D. Candidate), and Edward Jan (Ph.D. ’09)
VidFlips: Combines aspects of Facebook, JumpCut,
YouTube, and iMovie in a new online product for
users to record events in a personalized manner.
Team: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), Richard Lam and
Mark Thompson (BBAs ’08)
Michigan Business Challenge Judges
Jim Adox, Venture Investors; Jack Ahrens, TGap
Ventures; Jim Baker, Michigan Technology
University; Anthony Blanchard, Deloitte and
Touche; Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures; Amy Cell,
Ann Arbor SPARK; Cindy Crawford, Ross School of
Business; John Cunningham, Innoventures; Mike
Davis, Wolverine Capital Partners; Art DeMonte,
SummitTech BD; Charles Fry, Fry Farms; Jan
Garfinkle, Arboretum Ventures; Mary Sue Hoffman,
MI-SBTDC; Tom Kinnear, Ross School of Business;
Nancy Kotzian, Ross School of Business; Karl
LaPeer, Peninsula Capital Partners; Andy Lawlor,
Ross School of Business; Rod Lowe, Tecra
Systems; Andy McColm, University of Michigan;
Len Middleton, Ross School of Business; Scott
Olson, Ann Arbor SPARK; Monique Oxender, Ford
Motor Company; David Peralta, NanoBio; Mark
Petroff, Marketing Associates; Chuck Salley, Ann
Arbor SPARK; Larry Schmitt, Inovo; Phil Tepley,
MI-SBTDC; Don Walker, Arbor Partners; Walt
Young, Plymouth Venture Partners.
pp.8-
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
Intercollegiate Business Plan, Case
and Venture Capital Competitions
Consideration for competition sponsorship is given
to participating teams of the Michigan Business
Challenge as well as to teams who have demonstrated
a clear intent to launch their business. In 2008 the
Institute sponsored and coached 16 teams in 16
competitions. Teams representing the University of
Michigan were rewarded $103,250 in prize money.
Ball State University
Nascent 500 Business Plan Challenge (March 28)
VidFlips: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), and Andrew Baron,
Alice Chen, Tara Colli, Richard Lam and Mark
Thompson (BBAs ’08)
$1,500
Boise State University
Northwest Venture Championship (March 6)
Project Freestyle: Aly Juma (BS ’08), Brent Medema
(BS ’08), Chris Mwakasisi (BS ’09) and Michael
Parke (BS ’08)
Carnegie Mellon
McGinnis Venture Competition (March 13)
ePack Corp: Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08), Sang
Woo Lee and Akshai Rao(MBA ’08)
Blaze: Michael Tarasev (MBA ’08)
$5,000
Northwestern University
ABI Corporate Restructuring Competition (November 9)
Rishi Das (MBA ’08), Himayat Khan (MBA ’09), James
Lynch (MBA ’09) and Shripal Meghani (MBA ’08)
Rice University
Business Plan Competition (April 3)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$6,500
San Diego University
Venture Challenge (March 27)
Audiallo: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
$3,500
University of Cincinnati
Spirit of Enterprise Competition (February 28)
Army Property: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard and
Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
$10,000
University of Colorado
Venture Capital Investment Competition (February 8)
Ryan Baxter, Nathan Bosco, Punit Chiniwalla, David
Forsythe and Catherine Lee (MBAs ’08)
$500
(Top) Judges: David Peralta, Larry Schmitt, Walt Young, Scott Olson, Mary Sue
Hoffman and Len Middleton (Middle) Judges: Rod Lowe, Jim Baker, Chuck Salley,
Amy Cell, Phil Tepley, Andy McColm and Andy Lawlor (Bottom) Judges: (Back
Row) John Cunningham, David Gard, Jack Ahrens, Jim Adox, Don Walker (Front Row)
Karl LaPeer, Mike Davis, Charles Fry, Art DeMonte, Monique Oxender, Cindy Crawford,
Anthony Blanchard, Jan Garfinkle and Mark Petroff
(Top) Hitchsters: Sriram Viji, Catherine Lee and Jason Lin
(Middle) Army Property: Ambra Heard, Sherman Powell and Ben Kozma
(Bottom) Potentia: Tzeno Galchev (PhD), Ruba Borno (PhD) and Rishiraj Das
9
C
o
m
p
e
t
i
t
i
o
n
s
University of Colorado
Clean Tech Venture Challenge (February 27)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das
(MBA ’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$15,000
Forest Eye: Brewster Boyd (MBA/MS ’08)
$10,000
Cymergy: Harsh Nahar (MBA ’08)
$5,000
EnDep: Arie Jongejan and Tom Leahy (MBA/MSs ’10)
$2,000
University of Louisville
Cardinal Challenge (February 22)
Slow Kitchen Post: Robert Fetter (MBA ’08) and
Glenn Tarcea (MBA ’09)
$750
University of Manitoba
Stuart Clark Venture Challenge (April 3)
Org Org: Jennifer Anderson, Abhishek Gopalka,
Lauren Rosenthal, Heath Silverman, and Sriram Viji
(MBAs ’08)
University of Nebraska
New Ventures World Competition (April 10)
$500
VidFlips: Jared Ailstock (BA ’08), Andrew Baron,
Alice Chen, Tara Colli, Richard Lam and Mark
Thompson (BBAs ’08)
Hitchsters: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08), Jason Lin
(MBA ’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
$1,500
University of North Carolina
Social Venture Capital Investment Competition
(March 28)
Jennifer Anderson, Erin McCready, Andy Davis
(MBAs ’08), Nina Henning (MS/MBA ’09) and
Vikram Vaishya ’08)
$1,000
University of San Francisco
International Business Plan Competition (April 24)
GIDEON: Mark Birac, Katie Miller (MBAs ’09) and
Ankit Shah (MBA Eve)
$1,000
University of Texas – Austin
Idea to Product Competition (November 1)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das
(MBA ’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$2,500
University of Texas – Austin
MOOT CORP Competition (April 30)
ePack Corp: Jay Stewart Mitchell (Ph.D. ’08),
Sang Woo Lee and Akshai Rao(MBA ’08)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$2,000
Wake Forest University
The Elevator Competition (March 28)
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08) and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
$5,000
KLI African Business Plan Competition (December 14)
Mozergy: focuses their business operations in Mozam-
bique, and specifically on the cultivation and produc-
tion of Jatropha, a hearty and drought-resistant plant.
The plant has significant potential as an alternative
energy feedstock for biodiesel.
Tony Gross (MBA/MS ’08), Mike Hartley,
Jeff LeBrun and Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09s)
$10,000
Walmart Better Living Business Challenge (April 18)
Mozergy: Tony Gross (MBA/MS ’08), Mike Hartley,
Jeff LeBrun and Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09s)
$20,000
2008 University of Michigan
Quick Pitch Competition
The seventh annual competition was held in January
2008 in conjunction with the annual FuturTech
Forum. Competitors from across the University had
three minutes to deliver their elevator pitch to con-
vince a panel of venture capitalists of their businesses’
pending success. The competition was hosted by
the Entrepreneur and Venture Club.
First Place - $1,250
Potentia: Ruba Borno (Ph.D. ’08), Rishiraj Das (MBA
’08), and Tzeno Galchev (Ph.D. ’09)
Second Place - $500
RealKidz Clothing: Merrill Guerra (MBA ’09)
Third Place - $250
Audiallo: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
pp.10-
Assessment Grants - $1,500 each
Fall 2007
Audiallo
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA’09)
GIDEON: Develops CAD software for the design
simulation and visualization of nano-systems made
from structural DNA nanotechnology.
Team: Mark Birac (MBA ’09) and Ankit Shah (MBA ’07)
Home Counting: Offers quantitatively accurate
male fertility testing at home.
Team: Brian Burstein (MBA ’09) and David Lorch
(PhD ’08)
Indian Medical Group:
Provides overseas medical tourism services.
Team: Sharad Gupta and Sateesh Srinivasan
(MBAs ’09)
Innovet
Team: Rohan Mendonza (MBA ’09)
Neupharma Microdevices:
Manufactures and sells neural probes.
Team: Cory Costley (MBA ’08), Matt Gibson (PhD
’10) and John Seymour (PhD ’08)
Productive Kitchens: Develops innovative restaurant
equipment to provide increased kitchen productivity
in industrial kitchens.
Team: Babu Sambamoorthy (MBA ’08) and Israel
Vicars (BS ’08)
Sustainable Food Service: Distributes environmen-
tally-friendly food products and services.
Team: Mary Lemmer (BBA ’10) and Vanshika Vij
(BA ’09)
Winter 2008
A2Secure: Offers a secure service to store sensitive
information for user’s online activity.
Team: Paul Gruber and Yogev Shimony (MBAs ’09)
ELAN: Connects schools in India with local donors
to create a large selection of funding options.
Team: Swapnil Deopurkar and Shara Senior (MBA ’08)
Integration Grants
Fall 2007
ArmyProperty.com ($10,000): Offers an online
inventory management system for individuals in the
Armed Forces to organize and account for military
equipment.
Team: Angelo Adams, Ambra Heard, Parren James,
Ben Kozma, and Sherman Powell (MBAs ’08)
ePack Corp ($10,000): Provides MEMS packaging
for semiconductor manufacturers.
Team: Jay Stewart Mitchell (PhD ’07) and Akshai
Rao (MBA ’08)
MSignS ($10,000): English to sign language portable
device
Team: Michael Barfuss (MBA ’08), Jason Gilbert, and
JudyYu (PhD ’08)
Slow Kitchen Post ($5,000): Operates an internet
service to deliver artisan food to customers’ homes.
Team: Robert Fetter (MBA ’08)
Winter 2008
Audiallo ($10,000): Designs biology-inspired, audio
processing technology which targets the hearing-aid
and high-end audio markets.
Team: Aaron Nelson (MBA/MA ’09)
Hitchsters ($5,000): Operates a service that connects
travelers going to and from airports so that they can
share a cab and split the fare.
Team: Catherine Lee (MBA ’08), Jason Lin (MBA
’09), and Sriram Viji (MBA ’08)
Innovet ($10,000): Develops medical devices and
provides services for veterinary orthopedic applications.
Team: Rohan Mendonza (MBA ’09)
Mozergy ($5,000): Offers sustainable biodiesel feed-
stock to produce sustainable carbon-neutral biodiesel.
Team: Jeff LeBrun (MBA/MA ’09), Tony Gross (MBA/
MS ’08), Mike Hartley, Ali Moazed (MBA/MS ’09)
Dare to Dream Grants for Student Start-ups
Students who wish to develop their own entrepreneurial business concepts and work
toward the launch of their business may apply each fall and winter term for Dare to
Dream grants of up to $10,000. Dare to Dream grants are awarded in three phases: the
opportunity-identification phase where a potential business idea is identified, the assessment
phase where that concept is explored to see if it ‘has legs’; and the integration phase
where a solid business plan is created around the validated concept. The program provided
$101,000 in grant funding to students during the 2007-2008 academic year.
D
a
r
e
t
o
D
r
e
a
m
G
r
a
n
t
s
11
D
a
r
e
t
o
D
r
e
a
m
G
r
a
n
t
s
Healthy Lunches: Offers home and school delivered
lunches selected by parents.
Team: Zakaria Shaikh & Jeremy Sullivan (MBAs ’09)
I2: Offers design services to homeowners making
quality improvements on a modest budget.
Team: Jessica Goldberg (MBA ’09) and Katie Miller
(MBA/March ’10)
Michigan Watersports: Offers an indoor wake-
boarding water sports park.
Team: Victoria Miretti (BBA ’08) and Eduardo
Serrano (B.M.E. ’10)
Natural Sequestration Company: Sequesters carbon
dioxide emissions waste to large scale emitters and
creates a glucose byproduct to sell.
Team: Justin Felt (MBA/MS ’08)
Project Freestyle: Offers online tools to provide
organizational and marketing solutions for soccer
businesses.
Team: Aly Juma, Brent Medema, Chris Mwakasisi
(B.S.s ’08), Michael Parke (BBA ’08)
SecondEye: Provides software for automated reads of
medical images similar to spell-check for radiologists.
Team: Brian Burstein (MBA ’09) and Ted Way (Ph.D. ’08)
Travelamp: Provides nightlife information to
travelers abroad.
Team: Alexander Robart and Christopher Robart
(MBAs ’09)
Z2 Technologies: Computer-assisted dental implan-
tology services and computer-generated surgical
guides to provide ideal implant placement assistance.
Team: Dan Zetu (MBA ’09)
Opportunity Grants - $500 each
Fall 2007
General Aerodynamics: Analyze performance of
helicopter rotors and propellers
Team: James Cho (MSE ’08)
Haniwa Raptor Security Systems: Digital recording
system triggered by RFID hits for security firms.
Team: David Gaucher (MBA ’09)
Hearing Protection Indicator: Safety glasses that
indicate when hearing protection is needed.
Team: Robert Littrell (PhD’09)
i2: Mass market architectural services.
Team: Katie Miller (MBA/MArch ’10)
Maxim Investments: Investment funds that get
maximum tax efficiency.
Team: Maxim Yutsis (MBA ’08)
pp.12-
Modern Portfolio Auctions: Auction services for
individual or combination bid lots.
Team: Miles Putnam (MA)
Second Eye: CAD highlights of areas on CT scans
on which radiologists should focus.
Team: Ted Way (PhD ’08)
SensoWear: Fabric that senses change in tempera-
ture, pH, etc for sportswear and military uniforms.
Team: Edward Jan and Meghan Cuddihy (PhDs ’09)
Winter 2008
BLA Technologies: Tracks spatial coordinates.
Team: Ben Avidar (B.S.E. ’10) and Brian Pogrund (B.A. ’11)
City Cycles: Provides companies with support, such
as locker rooms, to encourage bicycling commuters.
Team: John Alexander, Tom Leahy, David Wolpa,
and Andrew Zrike (MBAs ’09)
Fontis Medical: Delivers large molecule drugs
through the skin with a patch.
Team: Matt Gibson, TK Kozai (Ph.D. ’10), and Erin
Purcell (Ph.D. ’08)
Grad Student Net: Share access to expensive tech-
nology and supplies.
Team: Channing Huntington and Prashant
Padmanabhan (Ph.D. ’11)
High Efficiency Thin Film: Solar cell thin film to
make solar energy more accessible.
Team: Tao Ling, Weiming Wang (Ph.D.s ’10), Jun
Yang, and Meng Zhang (Ph.D.s ’08)
Moduline Technologies: External re-sealable con-
nector for implantation within the body.
Team: Bryan Callow, Daniel Greenwald, Diana
Koordi, and Jeffery Meng (M.S.E. ’08)
Pure Ultra: Improves gel polymers for sensitive
applications such as ultrasounds.
Team: Fong Ming Hooi (Ph.D. ’10)
Residential Energy Solutions: Provides roof-mounted
Vertical Axis Wind Turbine for residential and small
business use.
Team: Glenn McDonald and Qian Xin Weng (Ph.D. ’10)
Taglium: Develops cutting fluid.
Team: Faheem Gill and Vijay Parthasarathy (MBA ’10)
Waste Agents: Advises businesses about the energy
value of their waste streams.
Team: Thomas Gilbert (Ph.D. ’09)
13
Entrepreneurial Studies & Venture Capital Finance:
Part of a Strong General Management Curriculum
The Ross School of Business, hand-in-hand with the Institute and its Center for Venture
Capital & Private Equity Finance, actively engages the nation’s most successful entrepreneurs
and offers an outstanding faculty comprising both academic researchers and practitioners in
entrepreneurship and venture capital.
Entrepreneurial Studies & Venture Capital Finance Course Electives
Bringing Reality into the Classroom
David J. Brophy, Director, Center for Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance: Professor of Finance
Real people. Real deals. Real outcomes. That’s what sets David Brophy’s courses in venture capital, private
equity and entrepreneurial finance apart from those at other leading business schools. “All the cases I
present are real cases, and everything I do in class is rooted in my personal involvement with investors
and entrepreneurs,” explains Brophy, who has played a formidable role in company-building as an adviser to
both start-ups and venture funds for nearly 30 years. “Students get more insightful treatment plus access
to real information and real people who were involved in the deals. Students can follow up as much as
they want and even make connections for future jobs.” As the founder of the annual Michigan Growth
Capital Symposium in 1979, which focuses on early-stage venture capital, Brophy pioneered an event that
has been emulated by institutions around the world. Brophy maintains close contact with recent and past
graduates who have fanned out across the entrepreneurial and investment communities. “My objective over
the years has been to make this business known to our students and to make it possible for them to get
involved in it as a career,” he says.
Entrepreneurial Multidisciplinary Action Projects:
MBAs Executing High-Level Management Assignments at Start-up Companies
As part of the Michigan MBA program, first year students are assigned to multidisciplinary action projects
at sponsoring companies, including several opportunities at entrepreneurial startups. Over a seven-week
period, the MAP teams execute high-level management assignments, such as developing business plans,
identifying new product opportunities and formulating strategies for market entry.
Entrepreneurial MAP
Company Hosts – 2008
MyWire.com - California
Project: Conduct research and analyze media industry trends and key competitors’ offerings.
MBA Team: Andrew Charnik, Julia Choi, Edward Cox, John Finger, Rahul Pal, Joshua Zane
Lion Cells Inc. - California
Project: Market assessment for electric displacement of small gas engines for the U.S., Europe, and Asia regions.
MBA Team: Heather Dobbins, Joshua Katz, Jeffrey LeBrun, Anthony Lupa, Siddharth Sinha
F
a
c
u
l
t
y
&
C
o
u
r
s
e
s
Urban Entrepreneurship
Enterprise Systems Strategy
Financing Research Commercialization
Private Equity Finance
Venture Capital Finance
Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance in
Transitional Economies
Frankel Commercialization Fund
Wolverine Venture Fund
Driving the Innovation Process
Entrepreneurial Management
Entrepreneurial Turnaround Management
Entrepreneurship via Acquisitions
Family Business
Intellectual Property and Competitive Strategy
Managing the Growth of New Ventures
New Venture Creation
Real Estate Fundamentals
Service Innovation Management
(Top)
Private Equity Course
Graduate Students
(Bottom)
David Brophy, Alan Gelband,
David Evans
13
pp.14-
Michigan Entrepreneur & Venture Club
2007-2008 Club Officers
MBAs ’08
Jennifer Anderson, Co-President
Heath Silverman, Co-President
Eugene Lee, Co-Vice President,
Venture Capital & Private Equity
Mike Lung, Co-Vice President,
Venture Capital & Private Equity
Ari Sznajder, Co-Vice President, Entrepreneurship
Shara Senior, Co-Vice President, Entrepreneurship
Shikhin Agarwal, Vice President, Finance
Jason Townsend, Evening MBA Relations
Ian Dailey, Director of Membership
Harsh Nahar, Treasurer
Kunal Mahajan, Technology Chair
2007-2008
Events and Guest Speakers
September 9 – EVC Kickoff Meeting
September 21 – Dare to Dream Information Meeting
This information session described the Dare to Dream
grants available to students, the application for each
grant, and the deliverables to obtain each grant.
September 18 – Mingle and Match
Students with entrepreneurial interests informally min-
gled with students who already had a business concept
with the goal of creating teams to form a business.
September 19 – EVC Speaker Series
Chetna Sinha, Mann Deshi Bank.
September 21 – EVC Speaker Series
Dan Patchen, Cargill Emerging Business Accelerator
September 21 – Entrepalooza 2007
This annual entrepreneurship symposium featured
four panel discussions, three breakout networking
sessions; and two keynote speakers: Samuel Zell,
Chairman of Equity Group Investments, and Kevin
O’Connor, Co-founder and former CEO & Chairman
of DoubleClick, Inc.; O’Connor Ventures. At the
symposium, Mr. Zell was presented with the Alumni
Entrepreneur of the Year Award.
September 21 – Post Symposium Student
Luncheon & Career Fair
The lunch and learn session brought together busi-
ness students with entrepreneurial alumni.
Participating alumni included Josh Botkin (MBA
’06) of Space Weather Forecasting Technologies;
Michael Edison (MBA/MS ’08) of Well-House Home
& Building Supply; Merrill Guerra (MBA ’08) of
RealKidz, Inc.; Robert Mazur (MBA ’03) of B.A. Maze,
Inc. (PurrFect Opener); Todd Sullivan (MBA ’05) of
SpiritShop, Inc.; and Michael Tarasev (MBA ’08), of
Blaze Medical Devices. Alumni shared their experienc-
es and the resources they tapped to launch while earn-
ing their degree.
During the career fair students networked with repre-
sentatives from entrepreneurial companies, including:
Cleantech Network, DevHive, Ghostly International +
Spectral Sound, Healthcare Data Solutions, Mandy
and Pandy, OtoMedicine Inc., Primerica Financial
Services, and uRturn.com.
September 24 – EVC Speaker Series
Amy Cell from Ann Arbor SPARK and Wes Huffstutter
from the Office of Technology Transfer spoke to stu-
dents about how to get involved in entrepreneurship in
the Ann Arbor community and the University at large.
September 26 – EVC Speaker Series
Mike Rohlfsen, Cargill Environmental Finance
September 28 – EVC Whirlyball
EVC celebrated Dare to Dream submissions with a
Whirlyball event.
September 29 – Michigan Business Challenge
Information Session
October 1 – EVC Speaker Series
Sam Valenti, Ghostly International,
co-sponsored by the Arts Enterprise Club.
October 5 – EVC Speaker Series
Camille Jayne, The Jayne Group
October 11 – EVC Speaker Series
Mike O’Connell, Pavilion Winery
October 12 – Michigan Business Challenge
Information Session
Students interested in participating in the 2008
Michigan Business Challenge attended this information
session to learn the details of the application process,
the format of each round, and the deliverables required.
October – Private Equity Student Panel
October 26 – West Coast Forum VC Panel, California
October 30 – Mingle and Match Business Networking
October 31 – EVC Halloween Happy Hour
Happy hour to celebrate Halloween at Mitch’s
M
i
c
h
i
g
a
n
E
n
t
r
e
p
r
e
n
e
u
r
&
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
C
l
u
b
14
15
November 12 – EVC Speaker Series
Nathan Burrell, the Honey Project
November 16 – Marcel Gani Internship Student Panel
2007 Marcel Gani summer interns discussed their
experiences working for start-up companies and ven-
ture capital firms and answered questions about the
internship process.
December 7 – Social Enterprise Education Event
Co-hosted with Net Impact and the Emerging Markets Club.
December 12 – EOY Pizza Party / Study Break
January 8 – Marcel Gani Internship Program
Information Session
Students learned how to apply for or host an internship
with an entrepreneurial company or a venture capital
firm. Mini-internships through Ann Arbor SPARK were
also presented for students who wanted to receive
entrepreneurial experience in the weeks before their for-
mal internship began. Students with their own business
ideas were encouraged to attend in order to hear about
summer opportunities to further develop their business.
January 9 – Global Social Venture Competition
Information and Prep Session
Co-hosted with Net Impact and the Emerging Markets Club.
January 16 – Dare to Dream Grant Program
Information Session
January 23 – EVC Speaker Series
Maria Leal, Coopa Roca
January 24 – Marcel Gani Internship Host Reception
January 25 – Quick Pitch Competition at FuturTech
FuturTech, the University of Michigan’s business and
technology conference, brought together the Ross
School of Business, the College of Engineering, the
School of Information, and major corporations from
around the world. The Quick Pitch competition was
held in conjunction with the conference.
January 27 – Mingle and Match with Ann Arbor SPARK
Co-hosted by Ann Arbor SPARK
March 4 – Whirlyball
EVC members met for the last social event of the season
and the new 2008-09 club officers were introduced.
April 8 – EVC Speaker Series
Fadi Ghandour, Aramex International
Executive Leaders Provide
Entrepreneurial Consulting
Students met with these executive leaders one-on-
one for the opportunity to receive feedback on their
start-up issues and the challenges they faced in
developing their businesses.
Participating Executives:
October 10 - Jonn Behrman, Entrepreneur
October 11 - Adam Borden, Founder & Managing
Director, Bradmer Foods
November 7 - Tim Petersen, Managing Partner,
Arboretum Ventures
November 10 - Charles Fry, CEO, Fry Farms
M
i
c
h
i
g
a
n
E
n
t
r
e
p
r
e
n
e
u
r
&
V
e
n
t
u
r
e
C
l
u
b
Entreplaooza 2007: Anybody Can Do It
The full spectrum of entrepreneurial activity, from start-ups on a shoestring to private equity mega-deals,
was put into perspective by well-known entrepreneurs, venture capitalists and business executives during
Entrepalooza 2007: Anybody Can Do It. The annual symposium presented by the Samuel Zell and Robert
H. Lurie Institute for Entrepreneurial Studies and the student-led Entrepreneur and Venture Club at the
Stephen M. Ross School of Business was held September 21 at the Michigan League on the University of
Michigan campus and drew 350 attendees from the University and business communities.
Keynote Speaker: Samuel Zell, Chairman, Equity Group Investments
Samuel Zell, a University of Michigan alumnus, founding benefactor of the Institute and the chairman of
Equity Group Investments in Chicago, received the 2007 Entrepreneur of the Year Award from Zell Lurie
executive director Thomas C. Kinnear. Sporting a Chicago Cubs baseball cap-a nod to his $8.2 billion
buyout offer for the Tribune Co., which has owned the Major League franchise team since 1981-Zell, 65,
delivered a blow-by-blow recounting of the events that lead up to his record-setting $40 billion sale of
Equity Office Properties Trust to New York-based Blackstone Group LP last February. He also offered his
current assessment of the financial markets in the wake of the subprime-mortgage meltdown.
The Blackstone-Equity Office transaction, disclosed Feb. 7, represented the days of enormous unfettered
liquidities, unlimited and undisciplined syndication, and the creation of new entities called collateralized loan
obligations and collateralized debt obligations, which pooled a series of debt and created a cascade of “sliding
pieces” that obfuscated risk, Zell said. “Much of the constipation that exists in the debt market today reflects
uncertainty in how you deal with these new entities when there are problems,” he explained. Until these
issues and structures live through some “difficult times,” their role in the future will be unclear, he predicted.
On a reassuring note, Zell said: “I really don’t believe the current environment is quite as catastrophic as
everybody would suggest. The amount of liquidity that existed six or eight weeks ago still exists today.” That
absolute amount of liquidity, he added, will not change until the world grows enough to better use and
absorb the level of capital it has created over the last 10 years.
“I don’t think we have a liquidity crisis,” Zell argued.” I think what we have is a confidence crisis, and I think
we will get through this with moderate damage over the next three to six months.”
Turning his attention to the Office Equity Properties Trust deal, which he described as “a paradigm of what
was happening at the peak of this frenzy,” Zell recapped the financial engineering in which Blackstone put
up $3 billion in equity, investment banks put up $5 billion of bridge equity, and $32 billion of debt was created.
He reported Blackstone has sold 75% of the assets and has retained 25%, and estimated the private equity
firm will earn for their investors a 60% internal rate of return on their investments. “You wouldn’t think
anyone would be so dumb as to sell something to somebody who is going to make a 60% profit on what
you’re selling,” Zell said. “But if you learn anything from what I have to say this morning, it is that there is an
enormous difference between absolute return and internal rate of return. As time moves forward, under-
standing that distinction is definitely going to separate the men from the boys.”
Continuing, Zell explained, “Somebody came to me and said, ‘I’ll take a $40 billion risk for which I’m willing
to accept $2 billion and my theoretical profit, if I succeed.’ The way I count that, it’s something like a 5%
return for the risk taken. From my point of view, I’m fully prepared to basically pay somebody 5% and deliver
$40 billion any day of the week.” He told his audience that the battle for control of the nation’s largest
office building owner began at the end of 2005 and encompassed a heated bidding war between Blackstone
and Vornado Realty Trust, as well as strategic negotiations over the share price and break-up fee. “Our
philosophy was very simple,” Zell explained. “What we really wanted to do was to create an auction with
a floor.” The events culminated in a so-called “godfather offer” from Blackstone that no public company
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Samuel Zell & Tom Kinnear Panel: Venture Capital
Jim Adox
pp.16-
could responsibly refuse and, ultimately, became the biggest leveraged buyout in history.
Zell wound up his narrative, saying, “It’s all about certainty, about eliminating the options and about intelli-
gently assessing risk as it should be.” He candidly admitted that the Blackstone-Office Equity transaction
could not have been done today, because the risk premiums have widened out dramatically and the availabil-
ity of capital is constrained. “The market today is relatively paralyzed and is trying to assess and identify the
new definitions of risk,” he said. “There is no shortage of liquidity; in fact, there is a surplus of liquidity that
will exist in 2007 and for a number of years. I think the current situation will end up being relatively benign.
The result, when it’s all said and done, is that debt will end up in a more stable, more conservative financial
environment, which is nothing but A-1 for our country.” Zell observed that the U.S. is growing and will con-
tinue to grow. The dramatic growth occurring outside the U.S., and the fact that the U.S. is less pressured to
be the engine of growth, is a very positive thing, he concluded.
During the morning, four concurrent panel discussions examined strategies for launching new businesses on
the cheap, growing start-ups, investing and pursuing career paths in venture capital and applying “intrapre-
neurship” and innovation across industries.
Panel: Build, Fund & Grow Winning Start-Ups
At the “Build, Fund & Grow Winning Start-ups” panel, successful entrepreneurs and venture capitalists discussed
the building blocks of new companies and strategies for overcoming common hurdles. “The ability to recruit and
retain people is essential for any CEO,” remarked Jennifer Baird, president and CEO of Accuri Cytometers Inc.
“Look for individuals who have your same values, work ethic and goals, but complementary skill sets. You don’t
want clones of yourself.” Richard Sheridan, president and CEO of Menlo Innovations, recommended that newly
minted CEOs work at recruiting and extending their networks 24/7, even when they are not hiring.
The panelists agree that attracting the necessary talent when a new company’s financial resources are slim
or nonexistent can be a challenge. “We generally didn’t pay people much at the beginning,” recalled David
Hartmann, founder and president of Arbor Blue. “As a CEO, you want to attract people who don’t need a lot
of pay, but who get excited about the adventure.” He characterized the state of Michigan as a great place to
launch “real companies with real products and real customers,” in part because it has a large pool of skilled
labor and many engineering and manufacturing resources. Hartmann also underscored the importance of
selecting board members and advisers who can bring “in the trenches” experience to a young company and
help it move forward.
In terms of funding, Baird acknowledged that it is very difficult for first-timers to “jump straight into the VC
world,” so she advised looking for federal grants and angel investors with discretionary money to invest. “You
should try to identify one key lead investor who knows other investors and will bring them along,” she said.
Baird also cautioned against “founder-itis,” a condition that prevents company founders and founding board
members from stepping aside and allowing the influx of new talent when it’s needed at different stages of
development. Sheridan urged entrepreneurs to weigh the pros and cons of pursuing venture capital money.
“Don’t take it, if you don’t need it,” he said. “VC money comes with a great deal of responsibility.”
Panel: Venture Capital Investing & Careers
The panelists shared their ideas about cultivating customers. “The best way to start a company is with a
customer rather than with an idea,” Hartmann argued. “Make time for sales calls every day. If you can find a
kingpin customer in your market and tip him over, you are on your way.” Baird urged CEOs to get customers
involved from the very beginning. “Along the way, we involved a lot of customers in the development of our
product and they became the champions for it,” she remarked.
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Panel: Launching on the Cheap
Brad Keywell, Parijat Gandhi, Barrett Davie
Panel: Winning Start-ups
Richard Sheridan, David Hartmann, Michael Callas, Jennifer Baird
17
At the “Venture Capital Investing & Careers” panel, venture capital fund managers revealed some of the
criteria they utilize in creating portfolios of companies. “You choose an industry, pick a stage and then
focus on a geographical area,” said Mina Sooch, founder and general partner of Apjohn Ventures. She told
the audience that her activities as a venture capitalist fall into four different categories: looking for and
sourcing deals, working with her existing portfolio companies to help them advance, running the opera-
tions of her VC firm and raising money from pension funds, endowments, and private investors who must
be convinced they will receive a good return. “You need skill sets to cover all four areas,” she noted. “It’s
not just about doing deals.”
Jim Adox, managing director of Venture Investors, observed that the number of venture funds in existence
today is only half of what it was at the peak of the dot-com bubble in 2000-2001 when 1,200 funds
were doing deals. Tom Wasserman, managing director of Constellation Ventures, argued that expectations
got out of whack in that highly charged environment. “A lot of guys came in with a lot of money,” he said.
“They invested it, built a little bit and sold quickly. People forgot that you have to grow a company. If
you’re looking for a quick exit, go to Vegas.”
The panelists agreed that the path to venture capital is more of a random walk than a straight sprint.
Mahendra Ramsinghani, senior vice resident of Plymouth Venture Partners, suggested that individuals
seeking to break into the VC industry hone their skills in modeling and financial forecasting, develop expertise in
a specialized domain such as clean technology, acquire an operational background and raise their awareness of
macro trends and leading companies in their chosen sector. Adox said, “Every VC partnership is different, so
you have to understand what value you bring to that partnership and how you match up with what the partner-
ship is looking for.” He also noted the importance of the EQ, or “emotional quotient,” which involves working
constructively with other people. Wasserman stressed the overarching need for building relationships and
networks through “spidering out” of your existing personal and professional circle of contacts. The panelists
predicted the next big trends in venture capital would include a focus on clean technology, the Web 2.0,
biotech and health care products, and increased fund investments in China and India.
Keynote Speaker: Kevin O’Connor, Co-Founder & Former CEO & Chairman, Doubleclick;
O’Connor Ventures
The morning session of Entrepalooza 2007 culminated with some tips for increasing the chances of entre-
preneurial success from keynote speaker Kevin O’Connor, the co-founder and former CEO and chairman of
DoubleClick Inc. and currently the head of O’Connor Ventures. “The odds are against you,” O’Connor told
his audience, but added that entrepreneurs have a better chance of succeeding if they identify a problem
and find a way to solve it 10 times better than their competitors or at one-tenth the cost. “Trends always
start very slowly and end bigger,” he remarked, pointing to the success of Google, which eventually sur-
passed the success of earlier search engine firms. O’Connor recommended brainstorming to generate lots
of ideas, then culling and focusing on the best three and vetting those to assure no one else has already
developed them.
As a venture investor, he said he likes a short, tightly focused business plan with a sexy executive sum-
mary that will grab his attention. He also steers away from early-stage ventures, preferring companies that
already have built and sold their products. O’Connor advised entrepreneurs to approach relatives and
angel investors for money, to hire “smart athletes” with overall intelligence rather than people with specific
skills, and to be willing to work 100 hours a week. “So, the odds may be against you, but the rewards at
the end of the day definitely outweigh those odds,” he concluded.
E
n
t
r
e
p
a
l
o
o
z
a
2
0
0
7
Kevin O’Connor Tim Faley & Wesley Hufstutter
pp.18-
Michigan Growth Capital Symposium:
Draws Investors from Across the U.S.
With Michigan’s economy struggling under the cloud of a subprime mortgage and housing foreclosure crisis,
coupled with slowing business activity and mounting job losses, the 2008 Michigan Growth Capital
Symposium offered an optimistic outlook for the state’s eventual recovery. The annual two-day event, now in
its 27th year, attracted nearly 400 participants to the Marriott Eagle Crest Conference Center in Ypsilanti,
Michigan, on May 14 and 15. Seven panels of experts drawn from the entrepreneurial, venture investing, legal
and government sectors discussed a wide range of issues, and 30 promising early stage companies made
presentations. Two keynote speakers, Alan G. Walton of Oxford Bioscience Partners and Kenneth R. Pelowski
of Pinnacle Ventures, offered their views of biotechnology and venture investing opportunities, respectively,
and both received the Leaders and Best Award.
“Per square foot, there is more enthusiasm and positive thinking about Michigan and the Midwest here than
anywhere else in 500 square miles,” observed Dr. David J. Brophy, director and founder of the symposium
and professor of finance at the Stephen M. Ross School of Business at the University of Michigan. Innovation,
hard work and financing provided the rallying point for this year’s symposium and demonstrated an alignment
of entrepreneurial enterprise and venture capital, he noted.
The event was presented by the Center for Venture Capital and Private Equity Finance of the Samuel Zell and
Robert H. Lurie Institute for Entrepreneurial Studies at the Ross School of Business.
Keynote Speaker: Alan G. Walton, Senior General Partner, Oxford Bioscience Partners
The sequencing of the human and other genomes, and the development of associated technologies, have been
the driving force behind the meteoric rise of biotechnology, said Alan G. Walton, the senior general partner in
Oxford Bioscience Partners, a life sciences venture capital firm with offices on the East and West coasts. Over
the span of his distinguished career, the English-born Walton has pioneered advancements in biotechnology as
a scientific researcher, university professor, U.S. Presidential science advisor, biotech company founder and
now, venture capital investor. He was presented with the Leaders and Best Award by MGCS founder and
Ross School finance professor David J. Brophy in recognition of his accomplishments.
During his keynote remarks, Walton predicted that biotechnology advancements will bring major changes in
four key areas over the next 50 years. “Most major human diseases will be treated, controlled or prevented by
biotechology products and methods,” Walton said. “Most of the world’s food supply will be more plentiful,
nutritious and disease resistant through biotech products.” He also predicted that a significant portion of the
world’s energy will come from genetic engineering and that molecular computers will be based on biological
molecules. “My prediction is that this will be the biotechnology century,” he said.
From a venture investing perspective, Walton observed there are two key investment strategies in the biotech-
nology sector. “One is to come up with the newest, latest and best thinking that is enabling technology, or you
can head down the public route, although the public isn’t interested in technology and doesn’t understand it,”
he said. “Oxford’s strategy has been to try to come up with revolutionary technologies.” Last year, Oxford
funded and sold a new technology called RNAI developed by Sirna; a rapid gene sequencing methodology
developed by Solexa, an English biotech firm; and an ultra-rapid vaccine formation company. “Although we
have a lot of failures, these huge sales of new technology have been the mantra at Oxford,” Walton said.
He noted that biotechnology has a history of four-year cycles. “Right now, in 2008, we have no IPOs, and
companies are running out of cash,” he said. “Things are looking a little bit grim. But if you believe the
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Alan Walton Energy Panel Members Life Sciences Panel Members
19
cycling, then at the end of the year and into 2009, biotech is set to come back again. I hope that gives us a
little bit of enthusiasm.” Although major technological breakthroughs in commercial bioscience have been
largely hidden from the public in the last few years, Walton said he anticipates these advances will inevitably
cause an economic shift to those centers where these technologies are employed. Commenting on the most
likely commercial successes in the energy side of the biotech equation, he dismissed the hydrogen highway as
“dreaming” and said, “Unfortunately, we’ll have to go to non-corn-based ethanol in the short run and use that
until we can build nuclear reactors that will take over, as they have in France and Japan.”
Panel: Creating A Clean Tech Cluster In Michigan And The Midwest
Michigan’s skilled workforce, plentiful natural resources, strong research community and deep manufacturing
expertise in the automotive and chemical industries provide a solid platform for creating a thriving clean tech
sector, said a panel of private and public technology investment managers and economic development leaders.
“We think there are three or four major sectors that present opportunities,” said Ananth Ananthasubramaniam,
manager of technology investments for DTE Energy, which has invested $100 million in the alternative energy
space. The “greening of the grid” will stimulate a growing market for renewable energy sources, such solar,
wind and biomass, he said, and increased concern about energy efficiency, management and storage will drive
new technologies in those areas. Alternative fuels also offer great possibilities for innovative companies and
forward-thinking venture investors. Through its Centers of Energy Excellence initiative, the Michigan Economic
Development Corporation is striving to grow a clean tech industry cluster by attracting high-potential compa-
nies to Michigan, connecting them with the right partners and then brokering the deals, explained Douglas
Parks, vice president of new market development. Colin South, president of Mascoma Corp., which focuses on
cellulosic ethanol production, reported that the supply chain and knowledge base in Michigan initially attracted
his company to the state. To move the needle toward clean tech, the panelists said, will require a variety of
financing sources and combinations, including venture capital, asset investment and the public markets.
Companies seeking venture capital dollars will need to identify disruptive technologies that are sustainable and
offer more than incremental improvements over existing ones, advised Mike Melnick of CMEA Ventures. He
said that the management team’s capabilities and the scalability of the market also must be considered.
Panel: Investment In Life Science Companies
Establishing strong investment partnerships is critical for entrepreneurial companies in the highly competitive
life sciences sector, but this can be challenging. “As the CEO, you are going to be raising money all the time,”
observed Douglas Onsi of HealthCare Ventures. “Don’t give up the first time some investor passes, but be
realistic. Think about how your company creates value and then go to the places where people recognize that
value.” Robert More, a partner at Domain Associates, advised entrepreneurs to focus on their particular area of
expertise and to work initially through local channels in the venture investing community. “You’d better be the
best at what you do, because you’re competing globally now, not regionally,” he said. “Know the kind of deals
a venture capital firm is doing and find out who your deal champion is going to be before you go to that first
meeting.” Venture capital firms considering investments in nontraditional geographical areas typically look for
entrepreneurs who can execute well on a plan and convey a desire to collaborate on a project, said Nina
Kjellson of InterWest Partners. “It’s important to align the interests of the investor and the inventor,” she
explained. “I also encourage entrepreneurs, scientists and institutions that help entrepreneurs to think through
the early team building and to consider how this enterprise will scale from two or three people to a successful
company.” In cases where there is not be a good fit with venture investors, Kjellson suggested exploring alter-
native funding sources, such as foundations, grant-making nonprofit organizations and government agencies.
Panel: Venture Capital Investment Strategy
Venture capital investments play an important role in the diversification of overall investment portfolios, but
fund managers often differ on their selection criteria and allocation strategies. “Venture investing fits me and
what I like to do,” said Michael Jandernoa, who straddles both sides of the investment fence as the former
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Preparing for Venture Financing Panel Members Acquirers View Panel Members Presenting Company
pp.20-
CEO of the Michigan-based drug manufacturer Perrigo Company and now as the co-founder of both Bridge
Street Capital Partners and Grand Angels. “In Michigan, we have a tremendous history of entrepreneurs and
many young people with great ideas. If we can give them the proper financial support and guidance, it will
increase their chances for success.” While fund performance is critical, Jose Fernandez of StepStone indicated
his firm is willing to consider first-time funds, if the emerging manager has had sufficient work experience
and can show a differentiated strategy and access to deal flow. However, he cautioned managers about glossing
over mistakes and using creative marketing to hide any shortfalls when talking to investment firms. Kevin
Fedewa of the State of Michigan Retirement System reported that declining fund sizes have resulted in “a pretty
big hit to our exposure to venture.” Although most of the venture funds in which he invests are on the East and
West coasts, he noted that general partners are starting to fly to Michigan and the Midwest. Jon Norris of SVB
Capital said he sees great opportunities to get involved with early stage funds in the Midwest, despite recent
turmoil in the economic environment. “We’re seeing some interesting plays and becoming more active in providing
banking services on both the VC and PE sides,” he said.
Keynote Speaker: Kenneth R. Pelowski, Founder and Managing Partner, Pinnacle Ventures
In venture capital investing, the top firms tend to produce the majority of industry profits and are able to
perpetuate their high-flying success through repeat business, said Kenneth R. Pelowski, the founder and
managing partner of Pinnacle Ventures, a Palo Alto, California-based private venture capital fund. “From 1997
to 2004, 50 venture investing firms, representing 4% of 1,200 firms, produced 77% of the profits in the
industry,” he said. “Of those, 20 to 25 firms, only 2%, produced almost 80% of the profits. What’s more,
those top 50 firms have increased their share of the pot. I believe this trend will continue.”
This top-heavy scenario presents an interesting dilemma for companies in Michigan that want to get connected
with one of those top 25 firms, Pelowski observed. “It’s possible, but it’s not easy,” he said, noting that some
bright spots appear on the horizon. “I believe there is more activity in Michigan than most people are aware of,
and certainly there are some well-known exits. There is starting to be some recognition in Silicon Valley of
what we call high quality deals and exits in the state. That’s really important, because without it, it’s really hard
to attract capital.” Pelowski, who grew up in Michigan and received his electrical engineering undergraduate
degree and MBA from the University of Michigan, also noted that University research efforts and state initiatives,
such as the Michigan 21st Century Investment Fund, are helping to move things in the right direction. “I owe a
lot to the University and the state, because I was educated and trained here,” he said. “I have expertise in
startups and venture capital that I think will help the University take world-class research and commercialize it,
which will help the state’s economy as well.”
Pelowski, who is now launching his fifth startup, outlined what it takes to present and to successfully receive
capital from some of the premier venture firms in the country. “It starts with really good technology,” he said.
“And that technology has to have differentiation, be protected and create barriers. But what really matters most
is that a company has to make a great product — not a good product, not a nice feature extension of a prod-
uct, but a great product. And it has to have a big market — a billion a year. Below $500 million, it is not going
to be ready, and from $500 million to a billion, it’s possibly ready.” Without these large opportunities, Pelowski
said, the venture capital community cannot make the returns it needs. People who have proven experience as
entrepreneurs, he added, are also an important part of the equation. “One of the greatest risk factors we have in a
deal is a first-time CEO,” he said. “It’s a huge ‘con’ in our analysis because the risk of their raising capital is huge.”
Looking forward, Pelowski predicted that the trend toward venture investing in the health care and energy areas
will play out well in Michigan, in part because the University has doubled its research spending in those two
areas and the state is known for its core competencies in alternative energy, transportation and health care.
“What we see — and thus what we think is the opportunity and why we come here — is a huge intersection,
for the first time in my lifetime, of what Michigan is good at and what is important or interesting to the venture
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
Venture Capital Panel Members Ken Pelowski & David Brophy Emerging Tech Panel Members
21
community. I think that’s a huge opportunity for the state.” At the conclusion of his remarks, Pelowski was pre-
sented with the Leaders and Best Award by MGCS founder and Ross School finance professor David J. Brophy.
Panel: Emerging Technologies And Opportunities
Emerging technologies offer a nearly unlimited horizon of entrepreneurial and venture investing opportunities,
but tapping into that deep pool of possibilities requires creative thinking, perseverance and the right synergies,
said a panel of industry experts. “We invest in early stage companies with really disruptive technologies,” said
Annette Finsterbusch of Applied Ventures, who has focused on plays in energy storage, energy conversion and
solar and non-solar fuel cells. With a background in software, business advisor and investor John Lovitt said
he looks for products that represent the marriage of different technologies to solve some problem or to capture
the “explosion of knowledge.” After 35 years at Johnson Controls, Thomas Dougherty believes many opportu-
nities can be leveraged from the automotive sector where his new startup company, Monolith Engines, is
developing specialized batteries and capacitors for use in electric and hybrid cars. Although rising gas prices
will likely foster more creativity, Dougherty expressed concern about the long lead times for product develop-
ment and the “missing conduit” to get new products through tier 1 and 2 suppliers to OEM manufacturers.
Andrew Basile Jr., a West Coast attorney, said that Michigan firms could get more traction by sticking with
secondary and tertiary entrepreneurial activities, such as service companies. “I’ve concluded that we [in
Michigan] are not poised to exploit the Silicon Valley model of new company creation,” he said. “We need to
have smaller companies doing smaller deals.” In addition to utilizing the existing expertise in the automotive
industry, he suggested new ventures might capitalize on opportunities associated with aging Baby Boomers by
focusing on the personalized delivery of health care services into homes.
Panel: Preparing Your Company For Its Initial Venture Financing
Seeking venture financing may or may not be the right decision for an entrepreneurial company, said panelists
who represented both the giving and receiving ends of the deal making. Although the infusion of capital may
benefit an early stage venture, “there is no free lunch,” cautioned Doug Camitta of the law firm Pepper
Hamilton. “How you run the company will change when you sign up with a venture capitalist. There will be
oversight and information reporting requirements.” Serial entrepreneur Vinay Gupta, who is now on his fifth
startup, Janeeva, said the decision often depends on whether a great deal of money is required to bootstrap a
new venture and whether the entrepreneur is willing to give up equity in return for venture financing. Rand
Mueller, the CEO and co-founder of Guidepoint Systems, said he used venture capital financing in half of the
13 companies he has started thus far. “Find the money guy who understands your business and vision, and be
sure you have good chemistry with them,” he advised. “Some fit, some don’t.” Venture capitalists, on the other
hand, are looking for good deals that will pay off for their own investors. “Can your business be sold for $250
million?” asked Jeff Bocan of Beringea. “VCs want to make 10 times their money back, so that’s the point
where a deal becomes attractive.” Getting in the door of a venture capital firm is often the hardest first step,
however. “This is a people business,” Camitta said. “To get into a VC firm, figure out whom you want to meet
and who knows that person and can introduce you.” Dave Fachetti of Globespan Capital Partners advised
entrepreneurs to investigate other factors such as sector expertise, fund cycle and recent deals to determine
how their company would fit into the venture firm’s investment mix.
Panel: Lessons From The Trenches: The Outlook For U.S. Venture Capital
Faced with overheated competition in Silicon Valley and other research corridors and triangles, venture capital
investors are turning their attention to Michigan and the Midwest, a panel of venture investors said. “We don’t
want to compete on the basis of term sheets with wonderful firms along Boston’s 128 Corridor because deals
are too high priced,” said Jeanne Sullivan, a general partner of StarVest Partners in New York City. “We want
to look for companies in underserved areas where people are looking for investors. We’re seeking strong entre-
preneurial and operating experience that comes out of the technology area.” Koleman Karleski of Chrysalis
Ventures, which has offices in Kentucky and Ohio, observed there is a mismatch between investment activity
and assets in the middle part of the U.S., where 22 or 23 states receive only 15% of the venture capital dol-
lars. “That’s the reason we’re here,” he said. Although venture investors are now more willing to travel to the
Midwest from the East and West coasts in search of the best companies, many prefer to partner with locally
based venture capital firms. “We like to have a strong local partner on the ground here, especially when we’re
investing in an early stage venture,” said Alison de Bord of San Francisco-based Alta Partners. David Parsigian,
a partner at the law firm of Honigman Miller Schwartz and Cohn, noted that “things are a lot different in
Michigan than they were five years ago.” The more widespread availability of capital is helping to spur the
growth of firms that can help entrepreneurial companies, he said, adding, “We have great critical mass grow-
ing in our region.” One of the biggest challenges facing venture capital firms is defining their sector focus. “At
the end of the day, we’re all trying to figure out where the puck is headed and how to carve out some sub-sec-
tor,” Karleski said. “Being diversified helps us to avoid pitfalls.”
pp.22-
M
G
C
S
C
e
l
e
b
r
a
t
e
s
2
7
Y
e
a
r
s
23
Turning Business Dreams
into Reality
Michael Edison, MBA/MS ’08
I came to Michigan to pursue a dual master’s degree
in business and natural resources and environment
through the Erb Institute for Global Sustainable
Enterprise. My interest in entrepreneurship was
piqued by the realization that new business ideas and
models will be needed to create a more sustainable
future. Through the Zell Lurie Institute, my partner
and I received a $2,500 Dare to Dream grant to help
us develop our concept for a “green” building prod-
ucts store. We honed our business plan and pitch at
the Michigan Business Challenge and received help-
ful feedback. As a Marcel Gani intern with Energy
Conversion Devices, I sharpened my skills in evalu-
ating the market potential, financing options and
resources needed to launch new businesses in the
renewable energy technologies industry.
Maya Patel, BBA ’08
I transferred to the Ross School of Business from
the College of Literature, Science and the Arts in my
junior year. I was attracted to the Ross School by its
structured coursework, excellent career counseling
and helpful workshops on resume writing and inter-
view techniques. My decision was also impacted by
the many success stories I’d heard about people who
have graduated from the School. Over the summer, I
landed a Marcel Gani Internship at GoKnow!, an Ann
Arbor-based, K-12 educational software company,
where I helped to formulate and implement its first
real sales-marketing plan. This experience gave me
an insider’s view of the challenges faced by a small
entrepreneurial company.
Mike Lung, MBA ’08
The opportunity to serve on the Wolverine Venture
Fund initially attracted me to Michigan’s Ross
School of Business. Over the past year, I have
learned how to evaluate new businesses, as well
as the process venture funds utilize to source new
deals. My WVF background enabled me to land
a Marcel Gani Internship at Plymouth Venture
Partners, an Ann Arbor-based mezzanine fund, where
I am performing investment due diligence and
financial analysis. My internship has broadened my
investment skill set and career options, and will
help me secure a full-time position in traditional or
alternative investments after I graduate.
S
t
u
d
e
n
t
S
h
o
w
c
a
s
e
Excitement about Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Investment continues to flourish at Michigan.
Students who wish to learn more about the Institute and its Center for Venture Capital and Private
Equity Finance may schedule an office hours appointment with a staff member online at www.zli.bus.
umich.edu. Business leaders who would like to become involved as a mentor, tap the unique skill-set of
our students for a project, or participate in an upcoming event, may contact us at [email protected]
for further information on how to get involved.
ADVISORY BOARD
Keith Alessi, Westmoreland Coal Company
Eugene Applebaum, Arbor Investments Group
John Barfield, The Bartech Group, Inc.
Jonn Behrman, Serial Entrepreneur
D. Theodore Berghorst, Vector Securities International, LLC
Paul Brentlinger, Morgenthaler Ventures
Kenneth Buckfire, Miller Buckfire & Co., LLC
Mary Campbell, EDF Ventures, LP
Dwight Carlson, Coherix, Inc.
Thomas Darden Jr., Reliant Equity Investors
Hal Davis, Entrepreneur & Investor
Richard Eidswick, Arbor Partners
Stanley Frankel, Frankel Associates
Marcel Gani, Santa Clara University
Jan Garfinkle, Arboretum Ventures
Michael Hallman, The Hallman Group
John Kennedy, Autocam Corporation
Bradley Keywell, Echo Global Logistics, LLC
Hans Koch, K2K Development, LLC
Ann Lurie, Lurie Investments
Steven McKean, Acceller, Inc.
Clyde E. McKenzie, Tellurex Corporation
Mitch Mondry, M Group, Inc.
Marvin Parnes, University of Michigan
Richard Rogel, Tomay, Inc.
Michael Staebler, Pepper Hamilton, LLP
Maria A. Thompson, T/J Technologies
Samuel Valenti III, Valenti Capital
Ronald N. Weiser, Ambassador, McKinley Associates, Inc.
Jeffrey Williams, HandyLab, Inc.
Warren P. Williamson, Skye Management
Samuel Zell, Equity Group Investments
Thomas Zurbuchen, University of Michigan
701 Tappan Street
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1234
(734) 615-4419
www.zli.bus.umich.edu
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Robert J. Dolan President, Zell Lurie Institute
Thomas Kinnear (ex-officio), Department of Marketing
Timothy Faley (ex-officio)
David Brophy Department of Finance
Michael Gordon Department of Business Information Technology
Andy Lawlor Department of Strategy
Len Middleton Department of Strategy
James Price Department of Entrepreneurial Studies
STAFF
Thomas Kinnear, Executive Director
Timothy Faley, Managing Director
David J. Brophy, Center for Venture Capital & Private Equity Finance
Thomas S. Porter, Executive in Residence
Mary Nickson, Communications Manager, M Entrepreneur Editor
Paul Kirsch, Program Manager
Rachel Ulrich, Program Coordinator
Marybeth Davis, Program Assistant
Carolyn Maguire, Administrator
doc_759502537.pdf