Description
The first Investment Policy by Board of Investment (BOI) was given in 1997, which
opened services, social, infrastructure and agriculture sectors for foreign and local
investors. It was a major step forward for integration of Pakistan’s economy into
international markets as prior to this policy; foreign investment was restricted to
manufacturing sector only.
The global integration of economies have forced the developing countries to adopt
liberalized policies for attraction of Foreign direct Investment (FDI). Around the world
countries have adopted proactive and liberal policies to attract FDI. Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) have gained momentum in attracting FDI. To meet global
competitiveness effectively and efficiently, creation of SEZs in the country had become
an acute necessity. The law to establish SEZs has been promulgated which
necessitate to review the existing Investment Policy backed by FDI Strategy for 5-year
to implement the policy through strategic interventions.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT (FDI)
STRATEGY 2013-17
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Subject Page(s)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 6
Introduction 6
Mandate of the BOI 6
FDI Generation and International Competitiveness 7
Focus on Foreign Direct Investment 8
Pakistan Economic Targets 9
Operational Windows of FDI Strategy 9
Approaches of the FDI Strategy 10
Catalyst Functions of BOI 11
Strategy for Domestic Investment 12
FDI Strategy Document 12
1. Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue 14
1.0. Purpose 14
1.1 Structure and Modus Operandi 15
1.2 Reporting System 16
2. FDI Promotion Campaign 18
2.0 Introduction 18
2.1. Target Investor Regions 19
2.2. Project – Focused FDI Promotion 19
2.2.1. Approach 19
2.2.2 Project Promotion Cycle 19
2.3. Enhancing Pakistan’s Image as an
Investment Location 21
2.3.1 Country Message 22
2.3.2 Image Enhancement Campaign 23
3
3. Investment Facilitation (One Window) 24
3.0. Scope 24
3.1. One Window 25
3.2. Initial Priorities 26
4. Development of Special Economic Zones 27
4.0. The SEZ Act 27
4.1. SEZ Policy and Implementing Regulations 28
5. Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries 30
5.0. Purpose 30
5.1. Building Co-operative Networks 30
5.1.1. Maximizing Administrative Efficiency
and Economy 30
5.1.2. Two Co-operative Networks 30
6. Reorganization & Capacity Development of the BOI 32
6.0. Introduction 32
6.1. Governance Structure 32
6.2. Operational Structure of BOI 33
6.3. Capacity Development 34
6.3.1. Human Resources 35
6.3.2. Information Technology 36
7. BOI as self Financing Organization 37
7.0. Need for Increased Funds 37
7.1. Self-financing 37
7.2. Donor Support 37
*****
4
ABBREVIATIONS
ADB Asian Development Bank
AEDB Alternate Energy Development Board
BITs Bilateral Investment Treaties
BOA Board of Approvals
BOI Board of Investment
CRM Customer Relationship Management
CTS Client Tracking System
ICSID International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
ECC Economic Coordination Committee
EPA Export Processing Zones
EU European Union
FEG Framework for Economic Growth (Policy Document by Planning
Commission)
FIC Foreign Investor Council
FIAS Foreign Investment Advisory Service of the World Bank & IFC
FPCCI Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce & Industry
FDI Foreign Direct Investment
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GoP Government of Pakistan
HR Human Resources
ID Investor Documentary
IFI International Financial Institutions
IPA Investment Promotion Agencies
5
IPDF Infrastructure Project Development Facility
IPFF Infrastructure Project Finance Facility
IT Information Technology
ITS Investor Tracking System
MIGA Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency
MOLJ HR Ministry of Law, J ustice and Human Rights
MOU Memorandum of Understanding
OICCI Overseas Investors Chambers of Commerce & Industry
OPIC Overseas Pakistan Investors Council
PPD Public-Private Sector Dialogue
PMTDF Pakistan Medium Term Development Framework
PBC Pakistan Business Council
PBIPA Pakistan Business Industry Promotion Association
PPP Private-Public Partnership
RIA Regulatory Impact Assessment
SMEDA Small and Medium Enterprise Development Authority
SME Small and Medium Enterprises
SEZs Special Economic Zones
USD United States Dollar
VGF Viability Gap Funding
WIPA World Association of Investment Promotion Agencies
*****
6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Introduction
The first Investment Policy by Board of Investment (BOI) was given in 1997, which
opened services, social, infrastructure and agriculture sectors for foreign and local
investors. It was a major step forward for integration of Pakistan’s economy into
international markets as prior to this policy; foreign investment was restricted to
manufacturing sector only.
The global integration of economies have forced the developing countries to adopt
liberalized policies for attraction of Foreign direct Investment (FDI). Around the world
countries have adopted proactive and liberal policies to attract FDI. Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) have gained momentum in attracting FDI. To meet global
competitiveness effectively and efficiently, creation of SEZs in the country had become
an acute necessity. The law to establish SEZs has been promulgated which
necessitate to review the existing Investment Policy backed by FDI Strategy for 5-year
to implement the policy through strategic interventions.
Mandate of the BOI
The Ordinance 2001 (Clause -9) mandates BOI to promote, encourage and facilitate
local and foreign investment inflow in Pakistan. Towards this end, the BOI is an
intermediary of the Government of Pakistan (GoP) between the public and the private
sectors. Its mandate encompasses;
a) policy advocacy with a view to promoting business friendly regulatory
reforms that improve the enabling conditions for doing business
b) investment promotion through
i. enhancing the image of Pakistan as an investment location
ii. marketing investment opportunities to attract investments into projects
c) investment protection with a view to strengthening investor confidence in
the stability of investment conditions through concluding international
investment agreements
d) investment facilitation at all the stages of the investment cycle, notably
through
i. acting as an intermediary between private investors and Pakistani
authorities (“one window” or “one stop shop” concept);
ii. matching foreign and domestic joint venture partners
iii. promoting public-private partnerships
7
e) networking and coordinating with public authorities and non-governmental
organizations in Pakistan with a view to implementing a coherent investment
promotion strategy
The BOI’s mandate approximates that of the most successful investment promotion
agencies in the world which have played a crucial role in achieving private sector based
prosperity in their countries. These agencies notably include the Singapore
Development Board, the Irish Development Authority, the Thailand Board of Investment,
Turkish Investment Promotion Agency and the Malaysian Industrial Development
Authority.
The BOI Board is comprising of both public and private sector members (Clause 3 of
BOI Ordinance, 2001) chaired by the Prime Minister of Pakistan. The BOI Board has
been established by BOI Ordinance as the highest joint public-private sector policy
council on private investment, the BOI Organization has emerged as the administrative
organization implementing decisions of the BOI Board. This implies that the policy
agenda of the BOI Board may be broader than the action programs administered by the
BOI Organization. In other words, policy consultations in the BOI Board can be pursued
without prejudice to the administrative competencies of ministries and agencies.
In October 2009, BOI was placed under the administrator control of the Prime Minister’s
Secretariat by the decision of the Prime Minister. Since then BOI is working under the
leadership of the prime Minister as Minister-in-charge.
FDI Generation and International Competitiveness
For an investor, the expected relative risk/return ratio is the driving force of investment
decisions. Therefore, they tend to invest in countries and projects where they expect the
highest returns and the lowest risks relative to alternative investment opportunities.
Pakistan’s success in attracting foreign investment thus depends on its competitiveness
as an investment location relative to other countries. Boosting Pakistan’s international
competitiveness on a global scale will be crucial in reaching Pakistan’s growth targets in
general and its FDI targets in particular.
Pakistan is widely perceived as a high risks investment proposition. A pro-active
campaign will be launched under this FDI Strategy to enhance Pakistan’s international
image as an investment location.
International investors must be persuaded that Pakistan, despite challenges, offers
investment opportunities with risk/return ratios outcompeting alternative opportunities
elsewhere. This calls for a strategy concentrating on identifying, developing, marketing
and facilitating “Competitive Projects” in Pakistan.
Such a strategy, to yield results, must encompass a broader “Investment Generation
Cycle”, including the:
8
1) Identification and Development of “Focal Sectors” , i.e., sectors with favorable
fundamentals for Competitive Projects;
2) Identification and Development of “Competitive Projects” in Focal Sectors;
3) Identification and Advocacy of policy measures likely to increase the
profitability of and decrease the risk level of investments in Pakistan
(“Competitiveness Enhancement”),
4) International Promotion of Competitive Projects with a focus on “Target
Investors” (i.e., investors most likely to be attracted by Competitive Projects
on offer) and “Target Regions” (i.e., countries/regions with most Target
Investors); and
5) Investment Facilitation, i.e., services provided to potential foreign investors
with a view to converting their interest in Competitive Projects into actual
investment in Pakistan.
Focus on Foreign Direct Investment
Although BOI’s mandate covers both domestic and foreign private investment, this
Strategy focuses on generating Foreign Direct Investments (FDI), i.e., investments of
foreign nationals into business activities in Pakistan. This focus is proposed, because
FDI promotion is the uncontested core competency of the BOI as Pakistan’s investment
promotion agency.
Foreign investors operate in the Pakistani economy alongside with domestic Pakistani
investors. The Investment Policy 2013 offers equal treatment to both local and foreign
investors. Therefore, to avoid distortions of competition, the same framework conditions
must in principle apply to all enterprises operating in the Pakistani market. Efforts
towards improving the investment climate in Pakistan (“policy advocacy”) are hence
envisaged to stimulate both domestic and foreign investment in Pakistan while offering
the level fields. In the same vein, sector strategies aiming at developing Focal Sectors
should be designed with a view to energizing domestic and foreign private investments
in these sectors.
To maximize the contributions of FDI to Pakistan’s economic development, this FDI
Strategy furthermore envisages special programs to promote the linkages between
domestically and foreign-owned private enterprises, such as local supplier, sub-
contractor or joint venture programs.
Finally, the Board of Investment is Pakistan’s highest level consultative body on
domestic and foreign private investments, comprising the Federal, Provincial and
Private Sector leaderships of the country. It is ideally suited to serve as a frame for joint
public – private sector consultations towards a coherent private sector development
agenda.
9
Pakistan Economic Targets
This FDI Strategy outlines a conceptual framework for cooperation of economic sectors
in Pakistan, public and private sectors, towards mobilizing the Private Investments,
(domestic and foreign) that are required to achieve Pakistan’s economic targets.
The following targets are highlighted for the purposes of this FDI Strategy:
? Average growth rate of some 7 – 8 % per year (supported by the Framework for
Economic Growth)
? Employment for an increasing and increasingly urbanized population (230 – 260
million by 2030)
? Building a knowledge-based economy and prioritizing the development of human
capital
? Enhancing the global competitiveness of the Pakistani economy from the 2011-
12 rank (118 out of 142 benchmarked countries) to rank 50 by 2030.
Operational Windows of FDI Strategy
Towards these targets, this FDI Strategy foresees seven action programs (“operational
windows”), namely to:
1) Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue (PPD);
2) FDI Promotion Campaign;
3) Investment Facilitation (One Window);
4) Development of Special Economic Zones (SEZs);
5) Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries;
6) Re-organization & Capacity Development of the BOI and
7) BOI as self Financing Organization.
To facilitate these programs, the FDI Strategy proposes a revitalization of the BOI
Organization with an attendant Capacity Building and restructuring program
The aforementioned our operational programs, together with the enabling revitalization
and capacity building are conceptualized as interdependent and mutually supportive
parts of an overarching coherent FDI Strategy.
This FDI Strategy cannot be implemented by the BOI alone. Its success requires the
collaboration of all actors in developing Pakistan’s Private Sector. The BOI will play a
catalytic role with the aim of facilitating and energizing this collaboration.
Accordingly, this FDI Strategy is designed as a framework of cooperation of all
stakeholders, public and private, in its success. This framework should meet with broad
consensus of Pakistan’s civil society beyond political divisions; and all stakeholders
10
should “co-own” this FDI Strategy and feel committed to its success in their own
interest.
As a framework for cooperation, this FDI Strategy has been designed with a view to
avoiding any interference with competencies of ministries and agencies of the GoP or
the Provinces; and all activities envisaged to be carried out by the BOI are covered by
the latter’s mandate under Article 9 of the 2001 BOI Ordinance.
As a framework for cooperation also, this FDI Strategy is not a business plan. It rather
envisages that specific action plans be determined in public – private sector
consultations under each chapter of the Strategy.
Approaches of the FDI Strategy
The FDI Strategy sets out roadmap to promote FDI in Pakistan and proposes four
broadly defined action programmes (hereinafter called “operational windows”) for
attracting FDI into Pakistan. These are:
Institutionalizing a structured Public - Private Sector Dialogue as a
framework of co-operation on:
a. Identifying and developing Focal Sectors and Competitive Projects in such
sectors,
b. Improving Investment Protection and
c. Linking FDI generation with related GoP policies and programs towards a
coherent Private Sector Development Strategy and policy framework
Promoting Foreign Direct Investment to Pakistan through:
a. Internationally promoting investment projects in Pakistan;
b. Enhancing internationally the image of Pakistan as an investment location;
and
c. Facilitating FDI in Pakistan by providing a variety of services to foreign
investors at various stages of the investment cycle and Creating and
Facilitating Special Economic Zones.
To perform operational programs effectively and efficiently, plans are outlined for:
i. Reorganizing and Capacity Building of BOI
ii. Building Cooperative Networks and the necessary administrative capacities of
the BOI to implement this FDI Strategy and
iii. Mobilizing the necessary financing for building the aforementioned capacities
The aforementioned “operational windows” and attendant organizational/capacity
development measures are envisaged to become building blocks of an inter-
11
independent strategy where activities in one area supplement and reinforce activities in
other areas.
The successful implementation of this FDI Strategy will require considerable
administrative capacities with attendant budgetary implications. Activities will therefore
be gradually phased in tandem with progress in building the necessary capacities.
In view of the present challenges faced by Pakistan, priority will be given to:
? Reorganizing the BOI with a view to setting the institutional basis for effective
and efficient operations;
? Institutionalizing the Public- Private Sector Dialogue with a view to mobilizing the
necessary Federal – Provincial – Private Sector collaboration for implementing
this Strategy
? Determining first Target Sectors and competitive investment projects in these
sectors (Competitive Projects);
? Promoting FDI into Competitive Projects; and
? Launching the SEZ program.
Catalyst Functions of BOI
BOI’s mandate is exceptionally broad by international comparison. However, BOI’s
budget is exceptionally small. Even IPAs with much narrower mandates and in much
smaller countries command over significantly larger resources than BOI. This requires
BOI to:
1) Determine and concentrate on priority activities where BOI can best mobilize
investments that would not have occurred without BOI support (“additionality
approach”); and
2) To the extent possible seek the co-operation of other Governmental and Non-
Governmental organizations inside and outside of Pakistan to further its
objectives (“Multiplier” approach through “Networking”).
This approach will especially apply to BOI’s Project Identification and Development
program. This program will include:
3) The selection of key sectors or subsectors on which BOI’s efforts will concentrate
(“ focal sectors”);
4) The preparation of sector development roadmaps with strategies for developing
focal sectors;
5) The identification of “competitive investment projects”, i.e., investment
opportunities with competitive expected relative risk/return ratios in focal sectors,
and;
12
6) The “packaging” of relevant information on these projects into “project profiles”
likely to attract (foreign) investors.
Many of these activities will have to be performed in the Provinces and regions where
prospective competitive investment projects are located. With its capacity and resource
constraints, the BOI will not be able to carry out these activities itself. Rather, it will have
to rely on the co-operation of other, notably Provincial agencies and private sector
organizations. The BOI will act as a catalyst rather than a performer of sector/project
development programs. It is for that reason that “Project Identification and
Development” is organizationally placed within the “Public-Private Sector Dialogue”, the
envisaged platform for co-operation of BOI with public and private sector organizations
with related responsibilities.
Strategy for Domestic Investment
Although BOI`s mandate covers both “local and foreign investment”, this Strategy
concentrates on generating Foreign Direct Investment. This focus is not meant to
indicate any priority of foreign investments. It just follows practical exigencies.
BOI clearly cannot launch ambitious action programs in support of domestic Pakistani
investments on account of its present resources. More importantly, such programs are
carried out by other Federal and Provincial agencies; and the above advocated
“subsidiary policy” applies especially to those programs. Proposing BOI initiatives in
support of domestic investments would require a stocktaking of existing similar
programs in Pakistan, a conceptualization of modes of co-operation between BOI and
such programs, and an assessment of BOI’s comparative organizational advantages in
involving itself in such programs. Such an exercise, with the attendant administrative
and political implications, would likely delay implementing actions on this FDI Strategy in
defiance of Pakistan’s need for speedy tangible results.
FDI Strategy Document
The first draft of this FDI Strategy was disseminated in 2008 to pertinent Federal
ministries and agencies, Provincial Governments as well as private organizations for
comments. The draft was revised in light of comments received and discussed in the 3
rd
BOI Board Meeting on 22
nd
October 2009. Updated in light of these discussions, this
FDI Strategy was approved in principle by the BOI Board at its Fourth Meeting on 18
th
May 2010 with the decision to circulate the updated version again to the Provincial
Governments and then present it to the Cabinet for final approval/endorsement.
13
FDI Strategy has again been revised after promulgation of SEZ Act 2012. The FDI
Strategy will remain a “living document”, i.e., the progress in its implementation will be
monitored jointly with cooperating organizations; and it intends to be consistent so that
change in government does not affect policy, however the Strategy stands to be
amended in the light of experience and resource mobilization whenever deemed
expedient.
14
1. Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue
1.0. Purpose
A structured Dialogue with the Private Sector is the backbone of this FDI Strategy. This
Dialogue will provide a platform for a systematic co-operation of Federal and Provincial
authorities as well as Private Sector organizations with responsibilities related to this
Strategy. It will serve two principal purposes, namely to:
1) Co-ordinate efforts on developing Target Sectors as well as identifying and
developing competitive investment projects in these sectors as a basis for
promoting FDI into such projects; and
2) Consult on policy initiatives towards improving the investment climate in
Pakistan.
As envisaged, the Dialogue will involve Federal, Provincial and Private Sector
stakeholders in the implementation of this FDI Strategy in all its stages. It will thus
inspire a sense of co-ownership, public and private, in the Strategy and in this way
commit all stakeholders to co-operating in its implementation.
If consulted informally, private sector representatives tend to articulate just particular
interests of individual enterprises or business groups. By bringing the various
consultations with different Private Sector interest groups under one umbrella in a
structured process, particular individual or group interests will be vetted against
competing interests of others a s well as Pakistan ’s (budgetary and other) constraints.
Conflicting interests and exigencies will thus be revealed and balanced policy
conclusions furthered.
Through the Dialogue, actors in various sectors and policy domains will exchange
information on developments, problems and initiatives related to this FDI Strategy. This
will contribute to the overall consistency and coherence of private sector – related
policies, programs and activities.
The consultation process will require responsible authorities periodically to report back
on actions taken on reform proposals made by the Private Sector. This is expected to
ensure proper follow-up on reform proposals and thus energize the reform process.
Finally, through the Private Sector Dialogue, the BOI stands to obtain the necessary in-
depth information for enhancing Pakistan’s image as an investment location, promoting
investment opportunities and rejuvenating investor service programs. These activities
require realistic assessments of the various sectors’ comparative strengths, risks and
weaknesses; they include the identification of both “marketable” investment projects as
well as potential investors abroad that might be interested in those opportunities. For all
15
these activities, the BOI will need the on-going advice and feedback of the Private
Sector. The PPD is envisaged to provide the framework for this interaction between the
Private Sector and the BOI.
1.1 Structure and Modus Operandi
Two – Wing Structure
The PPD has been divided into two wings – a consultative and an operational. The
consultations will primarily take place in J oint Public-Private Advisory Boards for key
sectors (“Focal Sectors”) under the Executive Committee. The operational wing will
feature the Department for Sector and Project Development. Figure 2 illustrates the two
– wing structure of the PPD:
This structure is proposed, because the identification and development of Focal Sectors
as well as competitive investment projects in these sectors must necessarily be a joint
action program of the BOI, sector ministries/agencies, Provincial/local agencies and
Private Sector organizations. The Sector Advisory Boards will be the core frame for this
collaboration; and the Sector Divisions will be the secretariats and implementing arms of
the Boards.
The combination of Private Sector consultations with Sector and Project Development is
probably the most immediate tangible benefit of the PPD; without it, systematic
sector/project identification and development will hardly be feasible.
Subject
presentl
Mines &
PPD wil
? a
p
? a
A
s
g
? a
p
Figure 2
1.2 R
A forma
attention
might co
to decision
y envisage
& Minerals, T
l have a thr
t the centr
rocess;
t the botto
Academic A
ector roadm
enerated; a
t the top th
olitical atte
2 illustrates
Reporting S
alized repor
n of politica
onsider the
ns of the E
ed, namely
Textiles, M
ree-tier stru
e Executiv
om Sector
Advisory C
maps, proje
and
he BOI Boa
ention to the
s the three-t
System
rting system
al decision-m
following a
Executive C
on Energy,
anufacturin
ucture for po
ve Committe
r Advisory
Council whe
ect identifica
ard under t
e results of
tier structur
m will ensu
makers. In
approach:
Committee,
Infrastruct
ng, Livestoc
olicy decisi
ee which c
Boards, a
ere substa
ations, joint
the Prime
f the PPD p
re for policy
re the tran
enacting th
, seven Se
ture and Co
ck & Dairy.
on making:
creates the
ad hoc –
antive cons
t actions an
Minister wh
process.
y decision m
sparency o
his system,
ector Adviso
ommunicati
:
structure a
Working G
sultations t
nd recom
hich ensure
making:
of the PPD
, the Execu
ory Boards
ion, Agricul
and steers
Groups and
ake place
mendations
es highest
and attrac
utive Comm
16
s are
lture,
s the
d an
and
s are
level
ct the
mittee
17
The Advisory Boards will send summary reports on each meeting to the Executive
Committee. These reports will include the (notably Private Sector) proposals made in
meetings as well as the follow-up on previous proposals. The Executive Committee will
report at least quarterly to the BOI Board on the progress of the PPD, including major
reform proposals and the follow-up thereon. Such reports will be disseminated to all
members of the Executive Committee and the Advisory Board concerned, including the
Private Sector members. This system will allow all members to trace the follow-up on
proposals made; and it is expected to stimulate prompt response of responsible
ministries and agencies on proposals referred to them.
18
2. FDI Promotion Campaign
2.0 Introduction
Actions under this FDI Strategy have a priority concentrate on bringing FDI inflows well
above the $ 5 billion level. Pakistan’s FDI targets are not adequately expressed in
figures, though more important than capital are contributions of FDI to Pakistan’s
development objectives, notably:
? Improving the competitiveness of production in Pakistan through transfer of
technology and upgrading labor skills, especially in agriculture, horticulture,
mining, manufacturing, housing, engineering and chemicals.
? Boosting Pakistan’s exports through:
o Facilitating access to overseas marketing and distribution networks; and
o Including Pakistani producers and service providers into international value
added chains.
? Improving corporate governance in Pakistan through bringing in and
demonstrating to local entrepreneurs’ best international management styles and
cultures.
Attracting FDI requires Pakistan to outcompete alternating investment locations.
Specially within the South Asia region shows the FDI trends in following figure 3.
Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
India
Pakistan
Bangledesh
Sri Lanka
Others
7
8
%
19
2.1. Target Investor Regions
FDI in Pakistan mainly comes from four regions which in 2007-2008 accounted for 71%
of total FDI flows to Pakistan. These are: United States (25.4%); South East Asia mainly
Malaysia & Hong Kong (20.5%), EU mostly UK & NL (12.8%) and Middle East, mainly
UAE & KSA (12.3%).
FDI promotion efforts will focus on these regions, plus China and Far East where there
is considerable potential. Bilateral business councils with countries in these regions will
be reactivated; and new councils will be initiated with China, UAE, KSA and NL.
However the FDI trends in 2008-09 to 2011-12 shows the considerable decrease in FDI
inflows from the above mentioned sources. Some new investment source countries
have emerged i.e. this trend draws attention in policy formulation and implementation.
FDI promotion efforts may be extended to additional home countries with strong sectors
that match sector-specific strengths of Pakistan.
The aforementioned principal home regions of FDI in Pakistan are also the regions with
the largest expatriate Pakistani communities. A special action plan will be prepared with
the aim of activating Pakistani Diasporas (including leading professionals) in the
aforementioned four focal regions in promoting this FDI Strategy.
2.2. Project – Focused FDI Promotion
2.2.1. Approach
FDI promotion will initially concentrate on Focal Sectors and investment projects in
these sectors with competitive expected risk/return ratios. Promotion activities will aim
at attracting international investors’ attention to opportunities that credibly promise
attractive risk/return ratios despite the challenges faced by Pakistan as a country. The
strategy will thus be based on Sector and Project Development.
It is envisaged that activities will initially concentrate on Target Sectors, viz.
Infrastructure-Communication, Manufacturing (Textile, Food Processing, Consumer
Goods, and Engineering), Energy, Mining & Exploration, Construction & Real Estate,
Automotive, and Agriculture-Livestock-Dairies-Fisheries. In this context, existing and
planned SEZs and Industrial Estates with the attendant incentive packages will be
highlighted.
2.2.2 Project Promotion Cycle
The promotion of investment projects encompasses a cycle of activities from targeting
potential investors for specific projects in Pakistan, raising their interest, to ultimately
persuading them to invest in Pakistani opportunities. It involves (i) maintaining a
comprehensive data base and (ii) launching an investment generation campaign.
20
(i) Database
The BOI has already set up an internal databank with important investment and trade-
related statistics. This databank presently exists in MS excel format; it will be upgraded
to an “e-library” where users can extract information by searching keywords.
A more comprehensive database will be set up as the backbone of project promotion.
The data- base will include:
? Standardized profiles of Competitive Projects in Pakistan;
? The coordinates of intermediaries through which projects profiles can be
disseminated, notably the “Cooperative Network”;
? Prioritized company profiles of Target Investors; and
? Information tracking investor contacts.
As outlined before, Competitive Projects will be identified in collaboration with the
Sector Advisory Boards. Standardized Project Profiles will be prepared for Target
Sectors with the information necessary for successful investment generation.
To prepare a list of Target Investors, information will be collected on foreign companies
in Focal Sectors the business interests and investment potentials of which appear to
match with the investment opportunities in Pakistan. The initial list will concentrate on
Focal Sectors and investor communities in the aforementioned Target Regions. An
initial database will be set up in 2011-2012. This initial database will be constantly
expanded and updated.
Consideration will also be given to involving the services of advisory firms such as
investment banks and law firms to represent the BOI and/or project sponsors in
promoting investment opportunities to target investors. Such firms have expertise in
marketing and structuring investments and have the ability to identify high potential
targets. Fees for such services can be provided through the BOI or on a “success fee”
basis where payment is made as a percentage of the transaction amount.
An “Investor Tracking System” (ITS) will be installed to provide instant information on all
previous contacts with Target Investors.
The BOI Intranet will make the Database (with the ITS) easily available to all managers
and operators of the BOI.
21
(ii) Investment Generation Campaign
An investment generation campaign will be launched, including a host of activities with
the ultimate aim of persuading targeted foreign investors to invest in opportunities in
Pakistan. An important interim step will be to persuade such investors to undertake site
visits to Pakistan.
Investment generation activities will include:
? Circulation of “marketing letters” to short-listed Target Investors alerting them of
opportunities that specifically suit their corporate strategies. BOI has already
prepared model marketing letters for this purpose. These will be reviewed in the
Sector Advisory Boards.
? Participation of BOI representatives in investor conferences in Focal Sectors and
trade fairs.
? Organizing investor conferences in Pakistan and key investor communities in the
Middle East, USA, Far East, and EU
? Visits of BOI officials with Pakistani project promoters in target investor
communities and specific target investor companies, possibly in conjunction with
state visits.
? Organizing visits of foreign investor delegations from Target Regions in
Pakistan.
In carrying out these activities, the BOI will proceed in partnership with private project
promoters wherever suitable. It will also heavily rely on the support of the Pakistani
embassies in key investor communities (commercial counselors) and honorary
investment counselors. Business relationships will also be established with chambers
of commerce and other business associations in Target Regions.
2.3. Enhancing Pakistan’s Image as an Investment Location
Marketing Pakistan as a competitive investment location will be part of Project
Promotion. Nevertheless, investment conditions in particular sectors and for specific
projects will in this context be distinguished from the investment climate in Pakistan at
large. Arguments will be advanced that promoted sectors and projects will be less
vulnerable to the macro-challenges widely associated with Pakistan and that the
promoted projects represent “opportunity niches”.
This approach might imply an “oases in the desert” message. The approach is proposed
to achieve quick results, but it should be complemented by medium-term pro-active
image enhancement campaign presenting Pakistan as a more attractive investment
22
location than widely perceived negative image. Pakistan ranked No.2 in Doing Business
for South Asia Region in year 2012 as showing in the figure 4.
Figure 4. Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
2.3.1 Country Message
Attention will be drawn to Pakistan’s strengths; and arguments will be suggested on
how to address the (perceived) threats and weaknesses.
The image enhancement campaign will portray Pakistan as a large and rapidly growing
market with an increasingly skilled and yet moderately priced workforce. Pakistan’s
location at the cross-roads of main trading corridors will be emphasized, along with the
pending infrastructure development projects that will further build up Pakistan’s strategic
strengths. The recent depreciation of the Rupee and decline of asset valuation (in
foreign currency) lowers entry costs and thus increases potential rates of return. It thus
might be possible to depict Pakistan as a country with undervalued investment
opportunities.
Credibility will be the first benchmark of the message. Actual and perceived problems
will be addressed but be put in proper perspective. Special attention will be drawn to the
pending reform process (e.g., regulatory reforms process, SEZ Act, progress on macro-
economic stabilization, security, etc.). Adverse risk perceptions will be alleviated with
reference to pending measures towards improving Investment Protection (e.g., new
BITs with ICSID clauses, new Law on Commercial Arbitration). The underlying
message will be: attractive investment destination considering its strategic location,
large and growing domestic market, and skilled human resources; visible progress on
macro-economy, security and infrastructure development.
An overriding country theme should be developed with which Pakistan should be
associated by international investors, like “Incredible-India” or “Malaysia-Truly Asia”. In
view of the presently low valuation of business assets in Pakistan (in foreign currency
terms), “Pakistan-the land of undervalued opportunities with future potential” might be a
first suggestion for discussion in the PPD. The implicit message: “Buy into the economy
at low price and share with us the returns of progress.”
132
105
89
122
154
1
2
3
5
4
23
2.3.2 Image Enhancement Campaign
The proposed image enhancement campaign may chiefly be launched through the
Cooperative Network. The BOI may in particular rely on the support of commercial
counselors in the Pakistani embassies and mobilize the honorary investment counselors
in Target Regions. BOI staff may moreover make presentations at suitable international
conferences and on the occasion of state visits in target countries. Investor conferences
on opportunities in Pakistan are envisaged to be organized.. These investor
conferences will in particular involve the Pakistani Diasporas in these countries; and
support will be sought from international donors. The investor conferences may provide
opportunities for (re)activating bilateral business councils
The BOI has already set up a Website and has published an Investor Guide (pocket &
large size); it has also prepared a CDROM with detailed investment information on
Pakistan, an Investor Documentary. These information tools will be further refined and
updated, keeping in view the new status of BOI as an organization directly reporting to
the Prime Minister’s Office. BOI’s website will become the prime portal with
comprehensive and up-to-date information on investment conditions and opportunities
in Pakistan.
24
3. Investment Facilitation (One Window)
3.0. Scope
The scope of services accorded by investment promotion agencies to foreign investors
varies widely. Such services are offered at five stages of the investment cycle, viz. (i)
the preparation of site visits of prospective investors to the envisaged host country; (ii)
the management of such site visits; (iii) the follow-up on site visits until a final
investment decision is taken; (iv) start-up assistance to foreign investors in actually
making investments in the country; and (v) after-care services after the investment has
been made.
Services during the first four stages of the investment cycle (pre-investment services)
are aimed at converting an initial interest in an opportunity into an actual investment.
Such services are still part of the investment promotion cycle.
Post-investment services drive at encouraging existing investors to expand their
investment in the host country. They will also serve the purpose of enhancing host
country’s image as an investment location. International experience shows that
prospective investors largely rely on the experience of existing investors in choosing an
investment location.
More importantly, post-investment services (also called “after care – services”) aim at
maximizing the benefits of local industries from foreign investors. Towards this
objective, these services include special programs for deepening partnership-type
relationships between foreign investors and local suppliers and sub-contractors. They
may also support linkages between foreign investors and universities/research institutes
or design the training programs to introduce innovation and upgrade the skills of staff,
suppliers or subcontractors of foreign investors according to their needs.
Pre-investment services include assistance to foreign investors in selecting an
investment location in the host country, possibly among several (competing) options.
This is still a task of the national IPA. However, the more investment preparation
focuses on a particular location, the more the services needed to be provided at the
regional or even local level. After – care services almost entirely fall in the local domain.
In Pakistan, the top problematic factors of Doing Business shown in the figure 5:
25
TOP PROBLEMATIC FACTORS OF DOING BUSINESS IN
PAKISTAN
Government
Inability / Coups
Corruption Policy
Instability
Inadequa
te
Infrastruc
ture
Govt.
Bureau
cracy
Access
to
Finance
Figure 5. Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
3.1. One Window
The BOI Ordinance mandated to “provide one window facilities for provision of all
services and utilities to investors by concerned federal and provincial agencies”. Under
this “one window” or “one stop shop” – concept, the BOI would act as an administrative
broker between foreign investors and Pakistani authorities; it would take up requests of
investors for permits, licenses, the provision of utilities and more, and obtain the
necessary decisions of the authorities concerned in an inter-agency administrative
process. Many investment promotion agencies in the world have tried and are trying
this approach but the success records are mixed. Few, if any, agencies fully operate as
one window.
Presently, the BOI brokers some administrative services, notably the issuance of visas,
work permits and security clearances to foreign investors and their key personnel. It
also facilitates the establishment of representative offices.
Providing comprehensive one window services throughout Pakistan would certainly
exceed the BOI’s present administrative capacities. Nevertheless, the one window -
concept represents a goal post; the closer the BOI’s actual activities approach this ideal,
the more effective it can be in mobilizing FDI for Pakistan. Thus, although the “one
window”- concept is unlikely to be implemented across the board during this FDI
Strategy, it will serve as an orientation for building up the BOI’s investor service
program. Under the SEZ Act, 2012, the BOI is envisaged to serve as a true “one
window” in SEZs.
26
3.2. Initial Priorities
The bulk of investor services will have to be provided at the site of prospective or actual
investment projects. The BOI’s ability in providing investor services thus depends on its
administrative capabilities in the various commercial centers of Pakistan, as well as the
cooperation of federal and, more importantly, provincial and municipal authorities.
At present the BOI operates service centers in Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta.
Of those, the Karachi office is the best equipped by far. It is therefore best suited to
serve as the lead operation; and investor services in other centers will be phased in with
building requisite administrative capacities and in light of the Karachi experience.
In the initial stage, the following priorities are proposed:
? Preparing “development packages”, i.e., documentation on incentives and other
benefits ( training assistance, access to land, security packages, etc) for typical
investment projects in Focal Sectors as well as for SEZs;
? Negotiating roadmaps with local authorities for navigating investors through
investment approval and business establishment procedures in Pakistan’s major
centers, starting with Karachi;
? Negotiating co-operation agreements with Federal and Provincial authorities
enabling the provision of particular “one window” – services;
? Establishing “one windows” in SEZs; and
? Facilitating the resolution of problems between (prospective and existing)
investors and Pakistani authorities. For large investments, this service may be
offered centrally by the BOI with the benefit of the Sector Advisory Boards. For
SME investments, this service has to be rendered by the BOI Regional Offices.
A problem facilitation office might be established in the Karachi Office on a pilot
basis.
27
4. Development of Special Economic Zones
4.0. The SEZ Act
Special Economic Zones (SEZs) have been, and still are being created, in many
countries as “economic enclaves” with a view to creating conducive conditions for
private sector development in defined geographic areas. More specifically, SEZ’s serve
to facilitate site development; the provision and financing of adequate business
infrastructure; the protection of security of business installations; the alleviation of
regulatory constraints (“administrative enclaves”); the promotion of industry clusters;
and the creation of industrial lighthouses in underdeveloped regions. As successful
examples in other countries demonstrate, SEZs offer an opportunity of overcoming
investment constraints.
With two noteworthy exceptions, past SEZ initiatives in Pakistan have not been
successful, though. These include the attempts at developing Export Processing Zones
(EPZs) and the now defunct Special Industrial Zones. Previous governments have
initiated Industrial Estates and Industrial Parks in the country to meet challenges of
competitiveness.
BOI, with the support of the relevant Federal Ministries/ department/ organizations and
Provincial Governments has prepared a SEZ Act 2012 setting out a uniform policy, legal
and institutional framework for SEZs in Pakistan. The Parliament was approved the SEZ
Act on 8
th
March, 2012 (Senate) and 13
th
J uly 2012 (National Assembly) and signed by
the Honorable President of Pakistan on 10
th
September, 2012.
The SEZ Act is a “ framework law” , establishing
? The basic concepts of the SEZ regime, notably the development and operation of
SEZs by private or public-private or public agencies “Developers”;
? The bodies administering the system:
o At the federal level, the “Board of Approvals” (under the Prime Minister), the
“Approvals Committee” and the BOI;
o At the Provincial level “SEZ Authorities”;
o SEZ Secretariat at BOI level; and
o SEZ Committees: SEZ Committee for each SEZ as per the applicable zone
regulations
? The investment incentives for both Developers and Enterprises in SEZs.
The incentives available for a period of 10-years for SEZ Developers and SEZ
Enterprises;
a. Exemption from custom duties for import of all capital goods, machinery &
equipment.
b. Income tax exemption.
28
In SEZ Act, 2012 there is Board of Approvals (BOA), chaired by the Prime Minister. The
meeting of (BOA) shall be convened on the orders of chairman BOA or on the
recommendations of BOI or the Provincial SEZ Authority. BOA shall adopt its own rules
of procedure and Secretary BOI act as Secretary of the BOA.
Figure 6 illustrates the SEZ Governance Framework as under:
Board of
Approvals
Approvals
Committee
Provincial SEZ
Authorities
SEZ
SEZ
Committee
Secretariat
(BOI)
District Gov
Developer
A
p
p
o
i
n
t
s
C
o
m
m
i
t
t
e
e
M
e
m
b
e
r
s
A
p
p
r
o
v
a
l
a
n
d
O
v
e
r
s
i
g
h
t
A
p
p
r
o
v
a
l
a
n
d
O
v
e
r
s
i
g
h
t
Oversight and
facilitation
Delegate
responsibilities
Special Economic Zone Governance Framework
Illustrative Flow Chart
Appoints Committee
Members
Build and operate SEZ
4.1. SEZ Policy and Implementing Regulations
As a framework law, the SEZ Act, 2012 is not self-executing, though. To be
implemented, Implementing Regulations will have to be adopted by the Board of
Approvals (the “BOA”). These will have to cover the powers and procedures of the
various SEZ bodies, and the procedures for designating areas as SEZs, selecting
Developers (tender procedures) and approving Developer Agreements (concession
agreements).
The preparation of Implementing Regulations should be preceded by adopting an SEZ
Policy; and the cornerstones of this Policy should be incorporated in the Implementing
Regulations. This approach is suggested in light of international experience (and
previous experience in Pakistan) with SEZs. This experience shows that the success
record of SEZs is mixed. Only technically well-planned SEZs tend to contribute to
economic development. The concept of privately developed and operated SEZs reflects
favorable international experience, but it also introduces additional complexities and
misuse potential into the system.
For instance, poorly designed or administrated SEZs have been misused for real estate
speculation at the expense of the budget. Also, a risk exists that existing Pakistani
29
enterprises would just relocate their production sites into SEZs to reap the fiscal
benefits. In such cases, tax revenues would be sacrificed but no additional economic
activity would be stimulated in Pakistan. Worse, both domestic and foreign-owned SEZ
enterprises might try to sell from the SEZs into the domestic Pakistani market in
competition with Pakistani enterprises outside the zones. This competition could be
distorted by virtue of the fiscal incentives and streamlined administrative procedures
applicable in the zones.
The aforementioned perils, it should be emphasized, do not militate against SEZs per
se. Yet, they show that diligent policies must be introduced to curb potential misuse and
ensure that SEZs really generate additional economic activity in Pakistan and benefit
the Pakistani economy at large through developing technology clusters, enhancing
export competitiveness and the like.
Under the SEZ Act, 2012, the BOI will become the Secretariat of the Board of Approvals
and will take charge of all administrative functions at the federal level to launch the SEZ
program, process the designation and development of individual SEZs, supervise the
operation of SEZs and promote and facilitate (foreign) investments in SEZs. These
functions are primarily (though not exclusively) regulatory functions and thus differ
fundamentally from BOI’s investment promotion functions. The SEZ administration thus
in practice adds a new institution to the BOI.
However, BOI instead of being a regulator will perform as an effective facilitator offering
One Window facilities to investors.
30
5. Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries
5.0. Purpose
Implementing this FDI Strategy exceeds the capacities of the BOI by far; it requires joint
efforts of all stakeholders in Pakistan’s economic growth. Accordingly, administrative
capacities for implementing this Investment Strategy will be developed in two ways,
namely by:
1) Building a Co-operative Network of organizations that will join forces with the
BOI to carry out this Investment Strategy; and
2) Linkages of macro and micro economic policies will bring all stake holders:
Line Ministries, Provincial Governments, Regulators and other relevant
Departments in unison for greater convergence on important nation public
policy agenda. This will enhance transparency, predictability and consistency
in the system.
3) Networking at international level for sharing of experience, policy,
opportunities for investment promotion and BOI has also membership of
World Association of Investment Promotion Agencies (WIPA).
5.1. Building Co-operative Networks
The BOI is envisaged to bring together a host of organizations, public and private,
Pakistani and international, with a view to co-operating in the implementation of this FDI
Strategy. This endeavor will pursue two distinct purposes, viz. to:
1) Complement BOI’s own capacities and financial resources; and
2) Link FDI generation to broader private sector development programs in
support of both domestic and foreign investment
5.1.1. Maximizing Administrative Efficiency and Economy
BOI will largely rely on other agencies and business organizations in developing Focal
Sectors and identifying and developing competitive investment projects in these sectors.
Moreover, the BOI will count on the support of the Pakistani embassies and strategic
partnerships with foreign business organizations in carrying out its image enhancement
and investment generation activities. In the interest of budgetary economy, this strategy
is designed to utilize existing facilities and capacities to the extent possible rather than
creating new capacities at considerable cost.
5.1.2. Two Co-operative Networks
In line with the aforementioned purposes, two Co-operative Networks are proposed,
namely:
31
? Network 1 comprising Pakistani agencies at the federal, provincial, and municipal
levels with investment related responsibilities as well as business organizations
in Pakistan. This Network will chiefly co-operate in the frame of the PPD on
Sector and Project Development, Investment Policies, and Investor Services
linking FDI with domestic businesses ; and
? Network 2 comprising Pakistani embassies, investor counselors, business
organizations, and other business intermediaries in target foreign investor
countries. This Network will co-operate in promoting investment projects and
Pakistan’s country image abroad (ch. 6 above)
As regards foreign institutions and organizations, network building is envisaged initially
to concentrate on the United States, the Middle East (KSA, UAE, Kuwait etc), Europe
(United Kingdom, Netherlands etc), China, and Far East. The commercial counselors in
the Pakistani embassies as well as the honorary investment counselors in these regions
could be initial international members of the Co-operative Network. Contacts to suitable
chambers of commerce and other business organizations and authorities in the
aforementioned target regions should be established through the Pakistan embassies
with a view to including such institutions in the Cooperative Network. Additional target
countries may be added to the Cooperative Network at a later stage.
Eventually, official investment counselors should be appointed in Target Regions,
starting with the United States as the prime source country of FDI in Pakistan. These
should become the prime antennae of the BOI in the aforementioned regions. They
should manage the interaction with the members of the Cooperative Network and carry
out investment promotion activities in the countries concerned; in particular, they should
build and maintain personal relationships with Target investors in their countries.
Special efforts are proposed to mobilize the Pakistani Diasporas in Target Regions,
notably in the United States, the UK, the NL, KSA and the UAE.
32
6. Reorganization & Capacity Development of the BOI
6.0. Introduction
Reorganization of the BOI, the BOI Board, at its Fourth Meeting on 18 May 2010, has
approved a new organizational structure. This structure has been devised with a view to
the overriding benchmarks of organizational effectiveness and efficiency, i.e., the
optimal performance of the functions laid down in the BOI Ordinance (and
conceptualized in this FDI Strategy) with the minimum of budgetary resources. The
BOI’s objective and functions determine its organizational structure which in turn drives
its operational procedures and resource development/allocation.
The new structure distinguishes between a “Governance Structure” of the BOI (policy-
making and senior management) and “Operational Structure” (administrative
departments and divisions).
6.1. Governance Structure
The governance structure comprises two different types of bodies, namely:
1) The BOI Board chaired by the Prime Minister as the supreme policy-making and
supervisory body; and
2) The BOI Organization under the Chairman BOI as the administrative institution
carrying out the operational functions assigned to the BOI as per the Board’s
policy directives.
Between the meetings of the BOI Board, its powers will be exercised by an Executive
Committee headed by the Chairman, BOI.
Figure 7 Governance Structure of the BOI.
BOI Board
Chair: Prime Minister
Chairman, BOI
Secretary, BOI
Executive Committee
Chair: Chairman, BOI
Organization of BOI
33
6.2. Operational Structure of BOI
The Operational Structure follows the functions of the BOI as set out in the BOI
Ordinance and conceptualized in this FDI Strategy. The five aforementioned
departments are divided up in divisions. These are the core operational cells of the BOI.
The divisions are organized with a view to mobilizing the required specialized expertise
and facilitating a smooth workflow among the specialized operational units.
The divisions under “Central Services” will facilitate all operations of the BOI; they
include especially Information Technology, Publications, Personnel.
As outlined before the “Public-Private Sector Dialogue” is divided into two wings - a
consultative and an operational. The private sector consultations will mainly take place
in J oint Public-Private Advisory Boards to be established for key sectors by the
Executive Committee. Also under the Public-Private Sector Dialogue comes the
operative Department for Project Identification and Development. This structure is
proposed because Project Identification and Development must be a joint action
program of BOI, sector ministries and, especially, Provincial/Local agencies as well as
Private Sector Organizations. The Sector Advisory Boards will be the core frame for this
collaboration; and the Sector Divisions will be the secretariats and implementing arms of
the Boards.
The combination of Private-Sector consultations with Project Identification and
Development is probably the most immediate tangible benefit of the PPD; without it,
systematic project identification and development will hardly be feasible.
Moreover, project development is linked with sector development and thus benefits
foreign and domestic investments alike. Through its structured collaboration with public
and private sector organizations in the PPD, the BOI will also promote domestic
investments as mandated by the BOI Ordinance.
The “Investment Promotion” Department will be charged with attracting foreign investors
into Pakistan. It will be organized by main investor regions: Americas, Europe, Far East
and the Middle East.
“Investment Facilitation”, i.e., the assistance to foreign investors in setting up their
business in Pakistan, will primarily be performed by the BOI Regional Offices where the
concerned project is located. “One-Window” services through which BOI will assist
foreign investors in obtaining visas, licenses, permits, utility connections and the like,
will have to be based on administrative arrangements between the BOI and the
authorities concerned. These arrangements will be concluded by the Investment
Facilitation Department and implemented by the Regional Offices.
34
The Divisions of the SEZ Department are organized by types of responsibilities set out
in the SEZ Act, taking into account that most administrative functions with respect to
individual SEZs will be performed by the Provincial SEZ Authorities.
Figure 8 Operational Structure of the BOI.
The above outlined organizational structure has been prepared on following principles:
1. Responsiveness to the postulates of the BOI Ordinance;
2. Straightforward transformation of administrative functions (as set out in the
BOI Ordinance and conceptualized in this FDI Strategy) into organizational
structure, i.e., the structure follows the functions, and not vice versa;
3. Furtherance of clarity, transparency and accountability with clearly defined
responsibilities of each unit and clear reporting lines;
4. Combination of professional specialization with coordination and
management oversight;
5. Encouragement of initiatives and result-orientation, especially in the
operational divisions; and
6. Facilitation of a smooth horizontal work and information flow among the
divisions (rather than a focus on vertical workflow through hierarchies).
6.3. Capacity Development
Despite the envisaged reliance on the cooperation of other organizations, implementing
this FDI Strategy will require upgrading the administrative capacities of the BOI and its
Regional Offices considerably. In particular, a state-of-the art management information
system
meet the
Figure 9
6.3.1. H
Impleme
different
officials.
investme
the first
whom th
promote
focus on
The BO
Private S
the Priva
PPD wi
Executiv
To som
expert b
Resourc
will have to
e challenge
9 illustrates
Human Res
enting this F
t type of t
While gov
ent promot
Pakistani
hey want to
ers from oth
n business
OI officials i
Sector. The
ate Sector
ill chiefly d
ve Committ
e extent, t
bodies, as e
ce Developm
o be install
es of the job
s BOI’s env
sources
FDI Strateg
talent and
vernment o
ters must p
contact pe
o attract to
her countri
results that
n charge o
ey will have
which cuts
depend on
tee secreta
he BOI wil
envisaged in
ment Plan
led, and hu
b.
isaged cap
gy not only
mindset th
officials typ
pro-actively
ersons of s
Pakistan.
es. To suc
t are expec
of the PPD
e to manag
s across ma
n the com
riat.
ll have to
n art. 9 (k)
is envisage
uman resou
acity devel
requires ad
han conve
pically react
market pr
senior exe
In this mis
cceed, they
ted in intern
will be the
ge an intera
any policy
mpetence, c
supplemen
of the BOI
ed.
urces will h
opment pro
dditional hu
ntionally re
t to actions
ojects worl
cutives of
ssion, they
y must disp
national bu
e liaisons b
active proce
domains. In
commitmen
nt its own s
Ordinance.
have to be
ogram:
uman resou
equired fro
s and reque
dwide. Th
internation
y compete w
play the qu
siness.
between th
ess betwee
ndeed, the
nt and dyn
staff with c
. A compreh
developed
rces; it nee
om governm
ests of citiz
ey are typi
nal corpora
with investm
ualifications
e GoP and
en the GoP
success o
namism of
consultants
hensive Hu
35
that
eds a
ment
zens,
ically
tions
ment
and
d the
P and
of the
f the
and
uman
36
6.3.2. Information Technology
As has been shown in the previous chapters, comprehensive, readily accessible and
current information must support virtually all activities under this Investment Strategy.
Much more is needed than collecting and collating data. A successful proactive
investment strategy will require a dynamic interactive IT system that:
? Provides comprehensive and up-to-date information on the status of investment
conditions and investment projects in Pakistan;
? Facilitates rapid and efficient communication amongst the members of the
Cooperative Network;
? Provides access to intelligence into industry trends, company strategies,
investment promotion activities of competitor countries, etc worldwide;
? Allows tracking progress of and follow-up on the various activities; and
? Enables the BOI to maintain relationships with targeted and current investors.
Such a system will have to include a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and a
Client Tracking System (CTS).
37
7. BOI as self Financing Organization
7.0. Need for Increased Funds
According to international experience, functioning investment promotion agencies yield
high economic returns – one percent increase in an IPA budget tends to translate into a
0.25 percent increase of FDI into the country concerned. Financing an IPA is hence a
sound investment in future economic growth. Pakistan’s fiscal constraints make it
nevertheless necessary to seek sources in addition to the budget for funding the
necessary Capacity Development of the BOI. It should also be taken into account that
investment mobilization activities alleviate poverty only indirectly and in the medium- to
long term and that FDI is still fraught with some political controversy. To ensure a broad
social support for the BOI and its mission, extra-budgetary financing will be sought to
the extent possible for the implementation of this initial Investment Strategy. Once the
contribution of investment mobilization activities to economic growth and poverty
alleviation in Pakistan become visible, it should become broadly acceptable to shift the
attendant costs predominantly to the budget.
On 18
th
May 2010, the BOI Board approved the creation of the BOI Fund envisaged in
the BOI Ordinance. This provides the basis for soliciting donor support of grants made
by the Federal Government, foreign aid or loans obtained or raised by the BOI with
special or general permission of Federal Government and others sums including fees
and changes receivable by the BOI on the approval of Visa, Branch/ Liaison Offices.
7.1. Self-financing
In pursuance of provision of section 9(u) of BOI ordinance 2001, BOI Board in its
meeting held on 29
th
J uly, 2011 approved the levy of service charges on Visa, Branch/
Liaison Offices. The receipts from above levy/service charges are being deposited in
BOI Fund.
7.2. Donor Support
Examples exist where IPAs during their start up – phase were supported by
international donors and/or IFI’s, notably the European Union and the World Bank. A
strong case can be made for obtaining similar support for the Pakistani investment
strategy. Potential donors should be contacted with a view to launching an investment
strategy support project.
doc_725754871.pdf
The first Investment Policy by Board of Investment (BOI) was given in 1997, which
opened services, social, infrastructure and agriculture sectors for foreign and local
investors. It was a major step forward for integration of Pakistan’s economy into
international markets as prior to this policy; foreign investment was restricted to
manufacturing sector only.
The global integration of economies have forced the developing countries to adopt
liberalized policies for attraction of Foreign direct Investment (FDI). Around the world
countries have adopted proactive and liberal policies to attract FDI. Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) have gained momentum in attracting FDI. To meet global
competitiveness effectively and efficiently, creation of SEZs in the country had become
an acute necessity. The law to establish SEZs has been promulgated which
necessitate to review the existing Investment Policy backed by FDI Strategy for 5-year
to implement the policy through strategic interventions.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT (FDI)
STRATEGY 2013-17
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Subject Page(s)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 6
Introduction 6
Mandate of the BOI 6
FDI Generation and International Competitiveness 7
Focus on Foreign Direct Investment 8
Pakistan Economic Targets 9
Operational Windows of FDI Strategy 9
Approaches of the FDI Strategy 10
Catalyst Functions of BOI 11
Strategy for Domestic Investment 12
FDI Strategy Document 12
1. Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue 14
1.0. Purpose 14
1.1 Structure and Modus Operandi 15
1.2 Reporting System 16
2. FDI Promotion Campaign 18
2.0 Introduction 18
2.1. Target Investor Regions 19
2.2. Project – Focused FDI Promotion 19
2.2.1. Approach 19
2.2.2 Project Promotion Cycle 19
2.3. Enhancing Pakistan’s Image as an
Investment Location 21
2.3.1 Country Message 22
2.3.2 Image Enhancement Campaign 23
3
3. Investment Facilitation (One Window) 24
3.0. Scope 24
3.1. One Window 25
3.2. Initial Priorities 26
4. Development of Special Economic Zones 27
4.0. The SEZ Act 27
4.1. SEZ Policy and Implementing Regulations 28
5. Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries 30
5.0. Purpose 30
5.1. Building Co-operative Networks 30
5.1.1. Maximizing Administrative Efficiency
and Economy 30
5.1.2. Two Co-operative Networks 30
6. Reorganization & Capacity Development of the BOI 32
6.0. Introduction 32
6.1. Governance Structure 32
6.2. Operational Structure of BOI 33
6.3. Capacity Development 34
6.3.1. Human Resources 35
6.3.2. Information Technology 36
7. BOI as self Financing Organization 37
7.0. Need for Increased Funds 37
7.1. Self-financing 37
7.2. Donor Support 37
*****
4
ABBREVIATIONS
ADB Asian Development Bank
AEDB Alternate Energy Development Board
BITs Bilateral Investment Treaties
BOA Board of Approvals
BOI Board of Investment
CRM Customer Relationship Management
CTS Client Tracking System
ICSID International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes
ECC Economic Coordination Committee
EPA Export Processing Zones
EU European Union
FEG Framework for Economic Growth (Policy Document by Planning
Commission)
FIC Foreign Investor Council
FIAS Foreign Investment Advisory Service of the World Bank & IFC
FPCCI Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce & Industry
FDI Foreign Direct Investment
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GoP Government of Pakistan
HR Human Resources
ID Investor Documentary
IFI International Financial Institutions
IPA Investment Promotion Agencies
5
IPDF Infrastructure Project Development Facility
IPFF Infrastructure Project Finance Facility
IT Information Technology
ITS Investor Tracking System
MIGA Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency
MOLJ HR Ministry of Law, J ustice and Human Rights
MOU Memorandum of Understanding
OICCI Overseas Investors Chambers of Commerce & Industry
OPIC Overseas Pakistan Investors Council
PPD Public-Private Sector Dialogue
PMTDF Pakistan Medium Term Development Framework
PBC Pakistan Business Council
PBIPA Pakistan Business Industry Promotion Association
PPP Private-Public Partnership
RIA Regulatory Impact Assessment
SMEDA Small and Medium Enterprise Development Authority
SME Small and Medium Enterprises
SEZs Special Economic Zones
USD United States Dollar
VGF Viability Gap Funding
WIPA World Association of Investment Promotion Agencies
*****
6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Introduction
The first Investment Policy by Board of Investment (BOI) was given in 1997, which
opened services, social, infrastructure and agriculture sectors for foreign and local
investors. It was a major step forward for integration of Pakistan’s economy into
international markets as prior to this policy; foreign investment was restricted to
manufacturing sector only.
The global integration of economies have forced the developing countries to adopt
liberalized policies for attraction of Foreign direct Investment (FDI). Around the world
countries have adopted proactive and liberal policies to attract FDI. Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) have gained momentum in attracting FDI. To meet global
competitiveness effectively and efficiently, creation of SEZs in the country had become
an acute necessity. The law to establish SEZs has been promulgated which
necessitate to review the existing Investment Policy backed by FDI Strategy for 5-year
to implement the policy through strategic interventions.
Mandate of the BOI
The Ordinance 2001 (Clause -9) mandates BOI to promote, encourage and facilitate
local and foreign investment inflow in Pakistan. Towards this end, the BOI is an
intermediary of the Government of Pakistan (GoP) between the public and the private
sectors. Its mandate encompasses;
a) policy advocacy with a view to promoting business friendly regulatory
reforms that improve the enabling conditions for doing business
b) investment promotion through
i. enhancing the image of Pakistan as an investment location
ii. marketing investment opportunities to attract investments into projects
c) investment protection with a view to strengthening investor confidence in
the stability of investment conditions through concluding international
investment agreements
d) investment facilitation at all the stages of the investment cycle, notably
through
i. acting as an intermediary between private investors and Pakistani
authorities (“one window” or “one stop shop” concept);
ii. matching foreign and domestic joint venture partners
iii. promoting public-private partnerships
7
e) networking and coordinating with public authorities and non-governmental
organizations in Pakistan with a view to implementing a coherent investment
promotion strategy
The BOI’s mandate approximates that of the most successful investment promotion
agencies in the world which have played a crucial role in achieving private sector based
prosperity in their countries. These agencies notably include the Singapore
Development Board, the Irish Development Authority, the Thailand Board of Investment,
Turkish Investment Promotion Agency and the Malaysian Industrial Development
Authority.
The BOI Board is comprising of both public and private sector members (Clause 3 of
BOI Ordinance, 2001) chaired by the Prime Minister of Pakistan. The BOI Board has
been established by BOI Ordinance as the highest joint public-private sector policy
council on private investment, the BOI Organization has emerged as the administrative
organization implementing decisions of the BOI Board. This implies that the policy
agenda of the BOI Board may be broader than the action programs administered by the
BOI Organization. In other words, policy consultations in the BOI Board can be pursued
without prejudice to the administrative competencies of ministries and agencies.
In October 2009, BOI was placed under the administrator control of the Prime Minister’s
Secretariat by the decision of the Prime Minister. Since then BOI is working under the
leadership of the prime Minister as Minister-in-charge.
FDI Generation and International Competitiveness
For an investor, the expected relative risk/return ratio is the driving force of investment
decisions. Therefore, they tend to invest in countries and projects where they expect the
highest returns and the lowest risks relative to alternative investment opportunities.
Pakistan’s success in attracting foreign investment thus depends on its competitiveness
as an investment location relative to other countries. Boosting Pakistan’s international
competitiveness on a global scale will be crucial in reaching Pakistan’s growth targets in
general and its FDI targets in particular.
Pakistan is widely perceived as a high risks investment proposition. A pro-active
campaign will be launched under this FDI Strategy to enhance Pakistan’s international
image as an investment location.
International investors must be persuaded that Pakistan, despite challenges, offers
investment opportunities with risk/return ratios outcompeting alternative opportunities
elsewhere. This calls for a strategy concentrating on identifying, developing, marketing
and facilitating “Competitive Projects” in Pakistan.
Such a strategy, to yield results, must encompass a broader “Investment Generation
Cycle”, including the:
8
1) Identification and Development of “Focal Sectors” , i.e., sectors with favorable
fundamentals for Competitive Projects;
2) Identification and Development of “Competitive Projects” in Focal Sectors;
3) Identification and Advocacy of policy measures likely to increase the
profitability of and decrease the risk level of investments in Pakistan
(“Competitiveness Enhancement”),
4) International Promotion of Competitive Projects with a focus on “Target
Investors” (i.e., investors most likely to be attracted by Competitive Projects
on offer) and “Target Regions” (i.e., countries/regions with most Target
Investors); and
5) Investment Facilitation, i.e., services provided to potential foreign investors
with a view to converting their interest in Competitive Projects into actual
investment in Pakistan.
Focus on Foreign Direct Investment
Although BOI’s mandate covers both domestic and foreign private investment, this
Strategy focuses on generating Foreign Direct Investments (FDI), i.e., investments of
foreign nationals into business activities in Pakistan. This focus is proposed, because
FDI promotion is the uncontested core competency of the BOI as Pakistan’s investment
promotion agency.
Foreign investors operate in the Pakistani economy alongside with domestic Pakistani
investors. The Investment Policy 2013 offers equal treatment to both local and foreign
investors. Therefore, to avoid distortions of competition, the same framework conditions
must in principle apply to all enterprises operating in the Pakistani market. Efforts
towards improving the investment climate in Pakistan (“policy advocacy”) are hence
envisaged to stimulate both domestic and foreign investment in Pakistan while offering
the level fields. In the same vein, sector strategies aiming at developing Focal Sectors
should be designed with a view to energizing domestic and foreign private investments
in these sectors.
To maximize the contributions of FDI to Pakistan’s economic development, this FDI
Strategy furthermore envisages special programs to promote the linkages between
domestically and foreign-owned private enterprises, such as local supplier, sub-
contractor or joint venture programs.
Finally, the Board of Investment is Pakistan’s highest level consultative body on
domestic and foreign private investments, comprising the Federal, Provincial and
Private Sector leaderships of the country. It is ideally suited to serve as a frame for joint
public – private sector consultations towards a coherent private sector development
agenda.
9
Pakistan Economic Targets
This FDI Strategy outlines a conceptual framework for cooperation of economic sectors
in Pakistan, public and private sectors, towards mobilizing the Private Investments,
(domestic and foreign) that are required to achieve Pakistan’s economic targets.
The following targets are highlighted for the purposes of this FDI Strategy:
? Average growth rate of some 7 – 8 % per year (supported by the Framework for
Economic Growth)
? Employment for an increasing and increasingly urbanized population (230 – 260
million by 2030)
? Building a knowledge-based economy and prioritizing the development of human
capital
? Enhancing the global competitiveness of the Pakistani economy from the 2011-
12 rank (118 out of 142 benchmarked countries) to rank 50 by 2030.
Operational Windows of FDI Strategy
Towards these targets, this FDI Strategy foresees seven action programs (“operational
windows”), namely to:
1) Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue (PPD);
2) FDI Promotion Campaign;
3) Investment Facilitation (One Window);
4) Development of Special Economic Zones (SEZs);
5) Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries;
6) Re-organization & Capacity Development of the BOI and
7) BOI as self Financing Organization.
To facilitate these programs, the FDI Strategy proposes a revitalization of the BOI
Organization with an attendant Capacity Building and restructuring program
The aforementioned our operational programs, together with the enabling revitalization
and capacity building are conceptualized as interdependent and mutually supportive
parts of an overarching coherent FDI Strategy.
This FDI Strategy cannot be implemented by the BOI alone. Its success requires the
collaboration of all actors in developing Pakistan’s Private Sector. The BOI will play a
catalytic role with the aim of facilitating and energizing this collaboration.
Accordingly, this FDI Strategy is designed as a framework of cooperation of all
stakeholders, public and private, in its success. This framework should meet with broad
consensus of Pakistan’s civil society beyond political divisions; and all stakeholders
10
should “co-own” this FDI Strategy and feel committed to its success in their own
interest.
As a framework for cooperation, this FDI Strategy has been designed with a view to
avoiding any interference with competencies of ministries and agencies of the GoP or
the Provinces; and all activities envisaged to be carried out by the BOI are covered by
the latter’s mandate under Article 9 of the 2001 BOI Ordinance.
As a framework for cooperation also, this FDI Strategy is not a business plan. It rather
envisages that specific action plans be determined in public – private sector
consultations under each chapter of the Strategy.
Approaches of the FDI Strategy
The FDI Strategy sets out roadmap to promote FDI in Pakistan and proposes four
broadly defined action programmes (hereinafter called “operational windows”) for
attracting FDI into Pakistan. These are:
Institutionalizing a structured Public - Private Sector Dialogue as a
framework of co-operation on:
a. Identifying and developing Focal Sectors and Competitive Projects in such
sectors,
b. Improving Investment Protection and
c. Linking FDI generation with related GoP policies and programs towards a
coherent Private Sector Development Strategy and policy framework
Promoting Foreign Direct Investment to Pakistan through:
a. Internationally promoting investment projects in Pakistan;
b. Enhancing internationally the image of Pakistan as an investment location;
and
c. Facilitating FDI in Pakistan by providing a variety of services to foreign
investors at various stages of the investment cycle and Creating and
Facilitating Special Economic Zones.
To perform operational programs effectively and efficiently, plans are outlined for:
i. Reorganizing and Capacity Building of BOI
ii. Building Cooperative Networks and the necessary administrative capacities of
the BOI to implement this FDI Strategy and
iii. Mobilizing the necessary financing for building the aforementioned capacities
The aforementioned “operational windows” and attendant organizational/capacity
development measures are envisaged to become building blocks of an inter-
11
independent strategy where activities in one area supplement and reinforce activities in
other areas.
The successful implementation of this FDI Strategy will require considerable
administrative capacities with attendant budgetary implications. Activities will therefore
be gradually phased in tandem with progress in building the necessary capacities.
In view of the present challenges faced by Pakistan, priority will be given to:
? Reorganizing the BOI with a view to setting the institutional basis for effective
and efficient operations;
? Institutionalizing the Public- Private Sector Dialogue with a view to mobilizing the
necessary Federal – Provincial – Private Sector collaboration for implementing
this Strategy
? Determining first Target Sectors and competitive investment projects in these
sectors (Competitive Projects);
? Promoting FDI into Competitive Projects; and
? Launching the SEZ program.
Catalyst Functions of BOI
BOI’s mandate is exceptionally broad by international comparison. However, BOI’s
budget is exceptionally small. Even IPAs with much narrower mandates and in much
smaller countries command over significantly larger resources than BOI. This requires
BOI to:
1) Determine and concentrate on priority activities where BOI can best mobilize
investments that would not have occurred without BOI support (“additionality
approach”); and
2) To the extent possible seek the co-operation of other Governmental and Non-
Governmental organizations inside and outside of Pakistan to further its
objectives (“Multiplier” approach through “Networking”).
This approach will especially apply to BOI’s Project Identification and Development
program. This program will include:
3) The selection of key sectors or subsectors on which BOI’s efforts will concentrate
(“ focal sectors”);
4) The preparation of sector development roadmaps with strategies for developing
focal sectors;
5) The identification of “competitive investment projects”, i.e., investment
opportunities with competitive expected relative risk/return ratios in focal sectors,
and;
12
6) The “packaging” of relevant information on these projects into “project profiles”
likely to attract (foreign) investors.
Many of these activities will have to be performed in the Provinces and regions where
prospective competitive investment projects are located. With its capacity and resource
constraints, the BOI will not be able to carry out these activities itself. Rather, it will have
to rely on the co-operation of other, notably Provincial agencies and private sector
organizations. The BOI will act as a catalyst rather than a performer of sector/project
development programs. It is for that reason that “Project Identification and
Development” is organizationally placed within the “Public-Private Sector Dialogue”, the
envisaged platform for co-operation of BOI with public and private sector organizations
with related responsibilities.
Strategy for Domestic Investment
Although BOI`s mandate covers both “local and foreign investment”, this Strategy
concentrates on generating Foreign Direct Investment. This focus is not meant to
indicate any priority of foreign investments. It just follows practical exigencies.
BOI clearly cannot launch ambitious action programs in support of domestic Pakistani
investments on account of its present resources. More importantly, such programs are
carried out by other Federal and Provincial agencies; and the above advocated
“subsidiary policy” applies especially to those programs. Proposing BOI initiatives in
support of domestic investments would require a stocktaking of existing similar
programs in Pakistan, a conceptualization of modes of co-operation between BOI and
such programs, and an assessment of BOI’s comparative organizational advantages in
involving itself in such programs. Such an exercise, with the attendant administrative
and political implications, would likely delay implementing actions on this FDI Strategy in
defiance of Pakistan’s need for speedy tangible results.
FDI Strategy Document
The first draft of this FDI Strategy was disseminated in 2008 to pertinent Federal
ministries and agencies, Provincial Governments as well as private organizations for
comments. The draft was revised in light of comments received and discussed in the 3
rd
BOI Board Meeting on 22
nd
October 2009. Updated in light of these discussions, this
FDI Strategy was approved in principle by the BOI Board at its Fourth Meeting on 18
th
May 2010 with the decision to circulate the updated version again to the Provincial
Governments and then present it to the Cabinet for final approval/endorsement.
13
FDI Strategy has again been revised after promulgation of SEZ Act 2012. The FDI
Strategy will remain a “living document”, i.e., the progress in its implementation will be
monitored jointly with cooperating organizations; and it intends to be consistent so that
change in government does not affect policy, however the Strategy stands to be
amended in the light of experience and resource mobilization whenever deemed
expedient.
14
1. Policy Formulation & Public-Private Sector Dialogue
1.0. Purpose
A structured Dialogue with the Private Sector is the backbone of this FDI Strategy. This
Dialogue will provide a platform for a systematic co-operation of Federal and Provincial
authorities as well as Private Sector organizations with responsibilities related to this
Strategy. It will serve two principal purposes, namely to:
1) Co-ordinate efforts on developing Target Sectors as well as identifying and
developing competitive investment projects in these sectors as a basis for
promoting FDI into such projects; and
2) Consult on policy initiatives towards improving the investment climate in
Pakistan.
As envisaged, the Dialogue will involve Federal, Provincial and Private Sector
stakeholders in the implementation of this FDI Strategy in all its stages. It will thus
inspire a sense of co-ownership, public and private, in the Strategy and in this way
commit all stakeholders to co-operating in its implementation.
If consulted informally, private sector representatives tend to articulate just particular
interests of individual enterprises or business groups. By bringing the various
consultations with different Private Sector interest groups under one umbrella in a
structured process, particular individual or group interests will be vetted against
competing interests of others a s well as Pakistan ’s (budgetary and other) constraints.
Conflicting interests and exigencies will thus be revealed and balanced policy
conclusions furthered.
Through the Dialogue, actors in various sectors and policy domains will exchange
information on developments, problems and initiatives related to this FDI Strategy. This
will contribute to the overall consistency and coherence of private sector – related
policies, programs and activities.
The consultation process will require responsible authorities periodically to report back
on actions taken on reform proposals made by the Private Sector. This is expected to
ensure proper follow-up on reform proposals and thus energize the reform process.
Finally, through the Private Sector Dialogue, the BOI stands to obtain the necessary in-
depth information for enhancing Pakistan’s image as an investment location, promoting
investment opportunities and rejuvenating investor service programs. These activities
require realistic assessments of the various sectors’ comparative strengths, risks and
weaknesses; they include the identification of both “marketable” investment projects as
well as potential investors abroad that might be interested in those opportunities. For all
15
these activities, the BOI will need the on-going advice and feedback of the Private
Sector. The PPD is envisaged to provide the framework for this interaction between the
Private Sector and the BOI.
1.1 Structure and Modus Operandi
Two – Wing Structure
The PPD has been divided into two wings – a consultative and an operational. The
consultations will primarily take place in J oint Public-Private Advisory Boards for key
sectors (“Focal Sectors”) under the Executive Committee. The operational wing will
feature the Department for Sector and Project Development. Figure 2 illustrates the two
– wing structure of the PPD:
This structure is proposed, because the identification and development of Focal Sectors
as well as competitive investment projects in these sectors must necessarily be a joint
action program of the BOI, sector ministries/agencies, Provincial/local agencies and
Private Sector organizations. The Sector Advisory Boards will be the core frame for this
collaboration; and the Sector Divisions will be the secretariats and implementing arms of
the Boards.
The combination of Private Sector consultations with Sector and Project Development is
probably the most immediate tangible benefit of the PPD; without it, systematic
sector/project identification and development will hardly be feasible.
Subject
presentl
Mines &
PPD wil
? a
p
? a
A
s
g
? a
p
Figure 2
1.2 R
A forma
attention
might co
to decision
y envisage
& Minerals, T
l have a thr
t the centr
rocess;
t the botto
Academic A
ector roadm
enerated; a
t the top th
olitical atte
2 illustrates
Reporting S
alized repor
n of politica
onsider the
ns of the E
ed, namely
Textiles, M
ree-tier stru
e Executiv
om Sector
Advisory C
maps, proje
and
he BOI Boa
ention to the
s the three-t
System
rting system
al decision-m
following a
Executive C
on Energy,
anufacturin
ucture for po
ve Committe
r Advisory
Council whe
ect identifica
ard under t
e results of
tier structur
m will ensu
makers. In
approach:
Committee,
Infrastruct
ng, Livestoc
olicy decisi
ee which c
Boards, a
ere substa
ations, joint
the Prime
f the PPD p
re for policy
re the tran
enacting th
, seven Se
ture and Co
ck & Dairy.
on making:
creates the
ad hoc –
antive cons
t actions an
Minister wh
process.
y decision m
sparency o
his system,
ector Adviso
ommunicati
:
structure a
Working G
sultations t
nd recom
hich ensure
making:
of the PPD
, the Execu
ory Boards
ion, Agricul
and steers
Groups and
ake place
mendations
es highest
and attrac
utive Comm
16
s are
lture,
s the
d an
and
s are
level
ct the
mittee
17
The Advisory Boards will send summary reports on each meeting to the Executive
Committee. These reports will include the (notably Private Sector) proposals made in
meetings as well as the follow-up on previous proposals. The Executive Committee will
report at least quarterly to the BOI Board on the progress of the PPD, including major
reform proposals and the follow-up thereon. Such reports will be disseminated to all
members of the Executive Committee and the Advisory Board concerned, including the
Private Sector members. This system will allow all members to trace the follow-up on
proposals made; and it is expected to stimulate prompt response of responsible
ministries and agencies on proposals referred to them.
18
2. FDI Promotion Campaign
2.0 Introduction
Actions under this FDI Strategy have a priority concentrate on bringing FDI inflows well
above the $ 5 billion level. Pakistan’s FDI targets are not adequately expressed in
figures, though more important than capital are contributions of FDI to Pakistan’s
development objectives, notably:
? Improving the competitiveness of production in Pakistan through transfer of
technology and upgrading labor skills, especially in agriculture, horticulture,
mining, manufacturing, housing, engineering and chemicals.
? Boosting Pakistan’s exports through:
o Facilitating access to overseas marketing and distribution networks; and
o Including Pakistani producers and service providers into international value
added chains.
? Improving corporate governance in Pakistan through bringing in and
demonstrating to local entrepreneurs’ best international management styles and
cultures.
Attracting FDI requires Pakistan to outcompete alternating investment locations.
Specially within the South Asia region shows the FDI trends in following figure 3.
Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
India
Pakistan
Bangledesh
Sri Lanka
Others
7
8
%
19
2.1. Target Investor Regions
FDI in Pakistan mainly comes from four regions which in 2007-2008 accounted for 71%
of total FDI flows to Pakistan. These are: United States (25.4%); South East Asia mainly
Malaysia & Hong Kong (20.5%), EU mostly UK & NL (12.8%) and Middle East, mainly
UAE & KSA (12.3%).
FDI promotion efforts will focus on these regions, plus China and Far East where there
is considerable potential. Bilateral business councils with countries in these regions will
be reactivated; and new councils will be initiated with China, UAE, KSA and NL.
However the FDI trends in 2008-09 to 2011-12 shows the considerable decrease in FDI
inflows from the above mentioned sources. Some new investment source countries
have emerged i.e. this trend draws attention in policy formulation and implementation.
FDI promotion efforts may be extended to additional home countries with strong sectors
that match sector-specific strengths of Pakistan.
The aforementioned principal home regions of FDI in Pakistan are also the regions with
the largest expatriate Pakistani communities. A special action plan will be prepared with
the aim of activating Pakistani Diasporas (including leading professionals) in the
aforementioned four focal regions in promoting this FDI Strategy.
2.2. Project – Focused FDI Promotion
2.2.1. Approach
FDI promotion will initially concentrate on Focal Sectors and investment projects in
these sectors with competitive expected risk/return ratios. Promotion activities will aim
at attracting international investors’ attention to opportunities that credibly promise
attractive risk/return ratios despite the challenges faced by Pakistan as a country. The
strategy will thus be based on Sector and Project Development.
It is envisaged that activities will initially concentrate on Target Sectors, viz.
Infrastructure-Communication, Manufacturing (Textile, Food Processing, Consumer
Goods, and Engineering), Energy, Mining & Exploration, Construction & Real Estate,
Automotive, and Agriculture-Livestock-Dairies-Fisheries. In this context, existing and
planned SEZs and Industrial Estates with the attendant incentive packages will be
highlighted.
2.2.2 Project Promotion Cycle
The promotion of investment projects encompasses a cycle of activities from targeting
potential investors for specific projects in Pakistan, raising their interest, to ultimately
persuading them to invest in Pakistani opportunities. It involves (i) maintaining a
comprehensive data base and (ii) launching an investment generation campaign.
20
(i) Database
The BOI has already set up an internal databank with important investment and trade-
related statistics. This databank presently exists in MS excel format; it will be upgraded
to an “e-library” where users can extract information by searching keywords.
A more comprehensive database will be set up as the backbone of project promotion.
The data- base will include:
? Standardized profiles of Competitive Projects in Pakistan;
? The coordinates of intermediaries through which projects profiles can be
disseminated, notably the “Cooperative Network”;
? Prioritized company profiles of Target Investors; and
? Information tracking investor contacts.
As outlined before, Competitive Projects will be identified in collaboration with the
Sector Advisory Boards. Standardized Project Profiles will be prepared for Target
Sectors with the information necessary for successful investment generation.
To prepare a list of Target Investors, information will be collected on foreign companies
in Focal Sectors the business interests and investment potentials of which appear to
match with the investment opportunities in Pakistan. The initial list will concentrate on
Focal Sectors and investor communities in the aforementioned Target Regions. An
initial database will be set up in 2011-2012. This initial database will be constantly
expanded and updated.
Consideration will also be given to involving the services of advisory firms such as
investment banks and law firms to represent the BOI and/or project sponsors in
promoting investment opportunities to target investors. Such firms have expertise in
marketing and structuring investments and have the ability to identify high potential
targets. Fees for such services can be provided through the BOI or on a “success fee”
basis where payment is made as a percentage of the transaction amount.
An “Investor Tracking System” (ITS) will be installed to provide instant information on all
previous contacts with Target Investors.
The BOI Intranet will make the Database (with the ITS) easily available to all managers
and operators of the BOI.
21
(ii) Investment Generation Campaign
An investment generation campaign will be launched, including a host of activities with
the ultimate aim of persuading targeted foreign investors to invest in opportunities in
Pakistan. An important interim step will be to persuade such investors to undertake site
visits to Pakistan.
Investment generation activities will include:
? Circulation of “marketing letters” to short-listed Target Investors alerting them of
opportunities that specifically suit their corporate strategies. BOI has already
prepared model marketing letters for this purpose. These will be reviewed in the
Sector Advisory Boards.
? Participation of BOI representatives in investor conferences in Focal Sectors and
trade fairs.
? Organizing investor conferences in Pakistan and key investor communities in the
Middle East, USA, Far East, and EU
? Visits of BOI officials with Pakistani project promoters in target investor
communities and specific target investor companies, possibly in conjunction with
state visits.
? Organizing visits of foreign investor delegations from Target Regions in
Pakistan.
In carrying out these activities, the BOI will proceed in partnership with private project
promoters wherever suitable. It will also heavily rely on the support of the Pakistani
embassies in key investor communities (commercial counselors) and honorary
investment counselors. Business relationships will also be established with chambers
of commerce and other business associations in Target Regions.
2.3. Enhancing Pakistan’s Image as an Investment Location
Marketing Pakistan as a competitive investment location will be part of Project
Promotion. Nevertheless, investment conditions in particular sectors and for specific
projects will in this context be distinguished from the investment climate in Pakistan at
large. Arguments will be advanced that promoted sectors and projects will be less
vulnerable to the macro-challenges widely associated with Pakistan and that the
promoted projects represent “opportunity niches”.
This approach might imply an “oases in the desert” message. The approach is proposed
to achieve quick results, but it should be complemented by medium-term pro-active
image enhancement campaign presenting Pakistan as a more attractive investment
22
location than widely perceived negative image. Pakistan ranked No.2 in Doing Business
for South Asia Region in year 2012 as showing in the figure 4.
Figure 4. Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
2.3.1 Country Message
Attention will be drawn to Pakistan’s strengths; and arguments will be suggested on
how to address the (perceived) threats and weaknesses.
The image enhancement campaign will portray Pakistan as a large and rapidly growing
market with an increasingly skilled and yet moderately priced workforce. Pakistan’s
location at the cross-roads of main trading corridors will be emphasized, along with the
pending infrastructure development projects that will further build up Pakistan’s strategic
strengths. The recent depreciation of the Rupee and decline of asset valuation (in
foreign currency) lowers entry costs and thus increases potential rates of return. It thus
might be possible to depict Pakistan as a country with undervalued investment
opportunities.
Credibility will be the first benchmark of the message. Actual and perceived problems
will be addressed but be put in proper perspective. Special attention will be drawn to the
pending reform process (e.g., regulatory reforms process, SEZ Act, progress on macro-
economic stabilization, security, etc.). Adverse risk perceptions will be alleviated with
reference to pending measures towards improving Investment Protection (e.g., new
BITs with ICSID clauses, new Law on Commercial Arbitration). The underlying
message will be: attractive investment destination considering its strategic location,
large and growing domestic market, and skilled human resources; visible progress on
macro-economy, security and infrastructure development.
An overriding country theme should be developed with which Pakistan should be
associated by international investors, like “Incredible-India” or “Malaysia-Truly Asia”. In
view of the presently low valuation of business assets in Pakistan (in foreign currency
terms), “Pakistan-the land of undervalued opportunities with future potential” might be a
first suggestion for discussion in the PPD. The implicit message: “Buy into the economy
at low price and share with us the returns of progress.”
132
105
89
122
154
1
2
3
5
4
23
2.3.2 Image Enhancement Campaign
The proposed image enhancement campaign may chiefly be launched through the
Cooperative Network. The BOI may in particular rely on the support of commercial
counselors in the Pakistani embassies and mobilize the honorary investment counselors
in Target Regions. BOI staff may moreover make presentations at suitable international
conferences and on the occasion of state visits in target countries. Investor conferences
on opportunities in Pakistan are envisaged to be organized.. These investor
conferences will in particular involve the Pakistani Diasporas in these countries; and
support will be sought from international donors. The investor conferences may provide
opportunities for (re)activating bilateral business councils
The BOI has already set up a Website and has published an Investor Guide (pocket &
large size); it has also prepared a CDROM with detailed investment information on
Pakistan, an Investor Documentary. These information tools will be further refined and
updated, keeping in view the new status of BOI as an organization directly reporting to
the Prime Minister’s Office. BOI’s website will become the prime portal with
comprehensive and up-to-date information on investment conditions and opportunities
in Pakistan.
24
3. Investment Facilitation (One Window)
3.0. Scope
The scope of services accorded by investment promotion agencies to foreign investors
varies widely. Such services are offered at five stages of the investment cycle, viz. (i)
the preparation of site visits of prospective investors to the envisaged host country; (ii)
the management of such site visits; (iii) the follow-up on site visits until a final
investment decision is taken; (iv) start-up assistance to foreign investors in actually
making investments in the country; and (v) after-care services after the investment has
been made.
Services during the first four stages of the investment cycle (pre-investment services)
are aimed at converting an initial interest in an opportunity into an actual investment.
Such services are still part of the investment promotion cycle.
Post-investment services drive at encouraging existing investors to expand their
investment in the host country. They will also serve the purpose of enhancing host
country’s image as an investment location. International experience shows that
prospective investors largely rely on the experience of existing investors in choosing an
investment location.
More importantly, post-investment services (also called “after care – services”) aim at
maximizing the benefits of local industries from foreign investors. Towards this
objective, these services include special programs for deepening partnership-type
relationships between foreign investors and local suppliers and sub-contractors. They
may also support linkages between foreign investors and universities/research institutes
or design the training programs to introduce innovation and upgrade the skills of staff,
suppliers or subcontractors of foreign investors according to their needs.
Pre-investment services include assistance to foreign investors in selecting an
investment location in the host country, possibly among several (competing) options.
This is still a task of the national IPA. However, the more investment preparation
focuses on a particular location, the more the services needed to be provided at the
regional or even local level. After – care services almost entirely fall in the local domain.
In Pakistan, the top problematic factors of Doing Business shown in the figure 5:
25
TOP PROBLEMATIC FACTORS OF DOING BUSINESS IN
PAKISTAN
Government
Inability / Coups
Corruption Policy
Instability
Inadequa
te
Infrastruc
ture
Govt.
Bureau
cracy
Access
to
Finance
Figure 5. Source: Fiscal Review 2012, Business Recorder
3.1. One Window
The BOI Ordinance mandated to “provide one window facilities for provision of all
services and utilities to investors by concerned federal and provincial agencies”. Under
this “one window” or “one stop shop” – concept, the BOI would act as an administrative
broker between foreign investors and Pakistani authorities; it would take up requests of
investors for permits, licenses, the provision of utilities and more, and obtain the
necessary decisions of the authorities concerned in an inter-agency administrative
process. Many investment promotion agencies in the world have tried and are trying
this approach but the success records are mixed. Few, if any, agencies fully operate as
one window.
Presently, the BOI brokers some administrative services, notably the issuance of visas,
work permits and security clearances to foreign investors and their key personnel. It
also facilitates the establishment of representative offices.
Providing comprehensive one window services throughout Pakistan would certainly
exceed the BOI’s present administrative capacities. Nevertheless, the one window -
concept represents a goal post; the closer the BOI’s actual activities approach this ideal,
the more effective it can be in mobilizing FDI for Pakistan. Thus, although the “one
window”- concept is unlikely to be implemented across the board during this FDI
Strategy, it will serve as an orientation for building up the BOI’s investor service
program. Under the SEZ Act, 2012, the BOI is envisaged to serve as a true “one
window” in SEZs.
26
3.2. Initial Priorities
The bulk of investor services will have to be provided at the site of prospective or actual
investment projects. The BOI’s ability in providing investor services thus depends on its
administrative capabilities in the various commercial centers of Pakistan, as well as the
cooperation of federal and, more importantly, provincial and municipal authorities.
At present the BOI operates service centers in Karachi, Lahore, Peshawar and Quetta.
Of those, the Karachi office is the best equipped by far. It is therefore best suited to
serve as the lead operation; and investor services in other centers will be phased in with
building requisite administrative capacities and in light of the Karachi experience.
In the initial stage, the following priorities are proposed:
? Preparing “development packages”, i.e., documentation on incentives and other
benefits ( training assistance, access to land, security packages, etc) for typical
investment projects in Focal Sectors as well as for SEZs;
? Negotiating roadmaps with local authorities for navigating investors through
investment approval and business establishment procedures in Pakistan’s major
centers, starting with Karachi;
? Negotiating co-operation agreements with Federal and Provincial authorities
enabling the provision of particular “one window” – services;
? Establishing “one windows” in SEZs; and
? Facilitating the resolution of problems between (prospective and existing)
investors and Pakistani authorities. For large investments, this service may be
offered centrally by the BOI with the benefit of the Sector Advisory Boards. For
SME investments, this service has to be rendered by the BOI Regional Offices.
A problem facilitation office might be established in the Karachi Office on a pilot
basis.
27
4. Development of Special Economic Zones
4.0. The SEZ Act
Special Economic Zones (SEZs) have been, and still are being created, in many
countries as “economic enclaves” with a view to creating conducive conditions for
private sector development in defined geographic areas. More specifically, SEZ’s serve
to facilitate site development; the provision and financing of adequate business
infrastructure; the protection of security of business installations; the alleviation of
regulatory constraints (“administrative enclaves”); the promotion of industry clusters;
and the creation of industrial lighthouses in underdeveloped regions. As successful
examples in other countries demonstrate, SEZs offer an opportunity of overcoming
investment constraints.
With two noteworthy exceptions, past SEZ initiatives in Pakistan have not been
successful, though. These include the attempts at developing Export Processing Zones
(EPZs) and the now defunct Special Industrial Zones. Previous governments have
initiated Industrial Estates and Industrial Parks in the country to meet challenges of
competitiveness.
BOI, with the support of the relevant Federal Ministries/ department/ organizations and
Provincial Governments has prepared a SEZ Act 2012 setting out a uniform policy, legal
and institutional framework for SEZs in Pakistan. The Parliament was approved the SEZ
Act on 8
th
March, 2012 (Senate) and 13
th
J uly 2012 (National Assembly) and signed by
the Honorable President of Pakistan on 10
th
September, 2012.
The SEZ Act is a “ framework law” , establishing
? The basic concepts of the SEZ regime, notably the development and operation of
SEZs by private or public-private or public agencies “Developers”;
? The bodies administering the system:
o At the federal level, the “Board of Approvals” (under the Prime Minister), the
“Approvals Committee” and the BOI;
o At the Provincial level “SEZ Authorities”;
o SEZ Secretariat at BOI level; and
o SEZ Committees: SEZ Committee for each SEZ as per the applicable zone
regulations
? The investment incentives for both Developers and Enterprises in SEZs.
The incentives available for a period of 10-years for SEZ Developers and SEZ
Enterprises;
a. Exemption from custom duties for import of all capital goods, machinery &
equipment.
b. Income tax exemption.
28
In SEZ Act, 2012 there is Board of Approvals (BOA), chaired by the Prime Minister. The
meeting of (BOA) shall be convened on the orders of chairman BOA or on the
recommendations of BOI or the Provincial SEZ Authority. BOA shall adopt its own rules
of procedure and Secretary BOI act as Secretary of the BOA.
Figure 6 illustrates the SEZ Governance Framework as under:
Board of
Approvals
Approvals
Committee
Provincial SEZ
Authorities
SEZ
SEZ
Committee
Secretariat
(BOI)
District Gov
Developer
A
p
p
o
i
n
t
s
C
o
m
m
i
t
t
e
e
M
e
m
b
e
r
s
A
p
p
r
o
v
a
l
a
n
d
O
v
e
r
s
i
g
h
t
A
p
p
r
o
v
a
l
a
n
d
O
v
e
r
s
i
g
h
t
Oversight and
facilitation
Delegate
responsibilities
Special Economic Zone Governance Framework
Illustrative Flow Chart
Appoints Committee
Members
Build and operate SEZ
4.1. SEZ Policy and Implementing Regulations
As a framework law, the SEZ Act, 2012 is not self-executing, though. To be
implemented, Implementing Regulations will have to be adopted by the Board of
Approvals (the “BOA”). These will have to cover the powers and procedures of the
various SEZ bodies, and the procedures for designating areas as SEZs, selecting
Developers (tender procedures) and approving Developer Agreements (concession
agreements).
The preparation of Implementing Regulations should be preceded by adopting an SEZ
Policy; and the cornerstones of this Policy should be incorporated in the Implementing
Regulations. This approach is suggested in light of international experience (and
previous experience in Pakistan) with SEZs. This experience shows that the success
record of SEZs is mixed. Only technically well-planned SEZs tend to contribute to
economic development. The concept of privately developed and operated SEZs reflects
favorable international experience, but it also introduces additional complexities and
misuse potential into the system.
For instance, poorly designed or administrated SEZs have been misused for real estate
speculation at the expense of the budget. Also, a risk exists that existing Pakistani
29
enterprises would just relocate their production sites into SEZs to reap the fiscal
benefits. In such cases, tax revenues would be sacrificed but no additional economic
activity would be stimulated in Pakistan. Worse, both domestic and foreign-owned SEZ
enterprises might try to sell from the SEZs into the domestic Pakistani market in
competition with Pakistani enterprises outside the zones. This competition could be
distorted by virtue of the fiscal incentives and streamlined administrative procedures
applicable in the zones.
The aforementioned perils, it should be emphasized, do not militate against SEZs per
se. Yet, they show that diligent policies must be introduced to curb potential misuse and
ensure that SEZs really generate additional economic activity in Pakistan and benefit
the Pakistani economy at large through developing technology clusters, enhancing
export competitiveness and the like.
Under the SEZ Act, 2012, the BOI will become the Secretariat of the Board of Approvals
and will take charge of all administrative functions at the federal level to launch the SEZ
program, process the designation and development of individual SEZs, supervise the
operation of SEZs and promote and facilitate (foreign) investments in SEZs. These
functions are primarily (though not exclusively) regulatory functions and thus differ
fundamentally from BOI’s investment promotion functions. The SEZ administration thus
in practice adds a new institution to the BOI.
However, BOI instead of being a regulator will perform as an effective facilitator offering
One Window facilities to investors.
30
5. Coordination Networks with Stakeholders Ministries
5.0. Purpose
Implementing this FDI Strategy exceeds the capacities of the BOI by far; it requires joint
efforts of all stakeholders in Pakistan’s economic growth. Accordingly, administrative
capacities for implementing this Investment Strategy will be developed in two ways,
namely by:
1) Building a Co-operative Network of organizations that will join forces with the
BOI to carry out this Investment Strategy; and
2) Linkages of macro and micro economic policies will bring all stake holders:
Line Ministries, Provincial Governments, Regulators and other relevant
Departments in unison for greater convergence on important nation public
policy agenda. This will enhance transparency, predictability and consistency
in the system.
3) Networking at international level for sharing of experience, policy,
opportunities for investment promotion and BOI has also membership of
World Association of Investment Promotion Agencies (WIPA).
5.1. Building Co-operative Networks
The BOI is envisaged to bring together a host of organizations, public and private,
Pakistani and international, with a view to co-operating in the implementation of this FDI
Strategy. This endeavor will pursue two distinct purposes, viz. to:
1) Complement BOI’s own capacities and financial resources; and
2) Link FDI generation to broader private sector development programs in
support of both domestic and foreign investment
5.1.1. Maximizing Administrative Efficiency and Economy
BOI will largely rely on other agencies and business organizations in developing Focal
Sectors and identifying and developing competitive investment projects in these sectors.
Moreover, the BOI will count on the support of the Pakistani embassies and strategic
partnerships with foreign business organizations in carrying out its image enhancement
and investment generation activities. In the interest of budgetary economy, this strategy
is designed to utilize existing facilities and capacities to the extent possible rather than
creating new capacities at considerable cost.
5.1.2. Two Co-operative Networks
In line with the aforementioned purposes, two Co-operative Networks are proposed,
namely:
31
? Network 1 comprising Pakistani agencies at the federal, provincial, and municipal
levels with investment related responsibilities as well as business organizations
in Pakistan. This Network will chiefly co-operate in the frame of the PPD on
Sector and Project Development, Investment Policies, and Investor Services
linking FDI with domestic businesses ; and
? Network 2 comprising Pakistani embassies, investor counselors, business
organizations, and other business intermediaries in target foreign investor
countries. This Network will co-operate in promoting investment projects and
Pakistan’s country image abroad (ch. 6 above)
As regards foreign institutions and organizations, network building is envisaged initially
to concentrate on the United States, the Middle East (KSA, UAE, Kuwait etc), Europe
(United Kingdom, Netherlands etc), China, and Far East. The commercial counselors in
the Pakistani embassies as well as the honorary investment counselors in these regions
could be initial international members of the Co-operative Network. Contacts to suitable
chambers of commerce and other business organizations and authorities in the
aforementioned target regions should be established through the Pakistan embassies
with a view to including such institutions in the Cooperative Network. Additional target
countries may be added to the Cooperative Network at a later stage.
Eventually, official investment counselors should be appointed in Target Regions,
starting with the United States as the prime source country of FDI in Pakistan. These
should become the prime antennae of the BOI in the aforementioned regions. They
should manage the interaction with the members of the Cooperative Network and carry
out investment promotion activities in the countries concerned; in particular, they should
build and maintain personal relationships with Target investors in their countries.
Special efforts are proposed to mobilize the Pakistani Diasporas in Target Regions,
notably in the United States, the UK, the NL, KSA and the UAE.
32
6. Reorganization & Capacity Development of the BOI
6.0. Introduction
Reorganization of the BOI, the BOI Board, at its Fourth Meeting on 18 May 2010, has
approved a new organizational structure. This structure has been devised with a view to
the overriding benchmarks of organizational effectiveness and efficiency, i.e., the
optimal performance of the functions laid down in the BOI Ordinance (and
conceptualized in this FDI Strategy) with the minimum of budgetary resources. The
BOI’s objective and functions determine its organizational structure which in turn drives
its operational procedures and resource development/allocation.
The new structure distinguishes between a “Governance Structure” of the BOI (policy-
making and senior management) and “Operational Structure” (administrative
departments and divisions).
6.1. Governance Structure
The governance structure comprises two different types of bodies, namely:
1) The BOI Board chaired by the Prime Minister as the supreme policy-making and
supervisory body; and
2) The BOI Organization under the Chairman BOI as the administrative institution
carrying out the operational functions assigned to the BOI as per the Board’s
policy directives.
Between the meetings of the BOI Board, its powers will be exercised by an Executive
Committee headed by the Chairman, BOI.
Figure 7 Governance Structure of the BOI.
BOI Board
Chair: Prime Minister
Chairman, BOI
Secretary, BOI
Executive Committee
Chair: Chairman, BOI
Organization of BOI
33
6.2. Operational Structure of BOI
The Operational Structure follows the functions of the BOI as set out in the BOI
Ordinance and conceptualized in this FDI Strategy. The five aforementioned
departments are divided up in divisions. These are the core operational cells of the BOI.
The divisions are organized with a view to mobilizing the required specialized expertise
and facilitating a smooth workflow among the specialized operational units.
The divisions under “Central Services” will facilitate all operations of the BOI; they
include especially Information Technology, Publications, Personnel.
As outlined before the “Public-Private Sector Dialogue” is divided into two wings - a
consultative and an operational. The private sector consultations will mainly take place
in J oint Public-Private Advisory Boards to be established for key sectors by the
Executive Committee. Also under the Public-Private Sector Dialogue comes the
operative Department for Project Identification and Development. This structure is
proposed because Project Identification and Development must be a joint action
program of BOI, sector ministries and, especially, Provincial/Local agencies as well as
Private Sector Organizations. The Sector Advisory Boards will be the core frame for this
collaboration; and the Sector Divisions will be the secretariats and implementing arms of
the Boards.
The combination of Private-Sector consultations with Project Identification and
Development is probably the most immediate tangible benefit of the PPD; without it,
systematic project identification and development will hardly be feasible.
Moreover, project development is linked with sector development and thus benefits
foreign and domestic investments alike. Through its structured collaboration with public
and private sector organizations in the PPD, the BOI will also promote domestic
investments as mandated by the BOI Ordinance.
The “Investment Promotion” Department will be charged with attracting foreign investors
into Pakistan. It will be organized by main investor regions: Americas, Europe, Far East
and the Middle East.
“Investment Facilitation”, i.e., the assistance to foreign investors in setting up their
business in Pakistan, will primarily be performed by the BOI Regional Offices where the
concerned project is located. “One-Window” services through which BOI will assist
foreign investors in obtaining visas, licenses, permits, utility connections and the like,
will have to be based on administrative arrangements between the BOI and the
authorities concerned. These arrangements will be concluded by the Investment
Facilitation Department and implemented by the Regional Offices.
34
The Divisions of the SEZ Department are organized by types of responsibilities set out
in the SEZ Act, taking into account that most administrative functions with respect to
individual SEZs will be performed by the Provincial SEZ Authorities.
Figure 8 Operational Structure of the BOI.
The above outlined organizational structure has been prepared on following principles:
1. Responsiveness to the postulates of the BOI Ordinance;
2. Straightforward transformation of administrative functions (as set out in the
BOI Ordinance and conceptualized in this FDI Strategy) into organizational
structure, i.e., the structure follows the functions, and not vice versa;
3. Furtherance of clarity, transparency and accountability with clearly defined
responsibilities of each unit and clear reporting lines;
4. Combination of professional specialization with coordination and
management oversight;
5. Encouragement of initiatives and result-orientation, especially in the
operational divisions; and
6. Facilitation of a smooth horizontal work and information flow among the
divisions (rather than a focus on vertical workflow through hierarchies).
6.3. Capacity Development
Despite the envisaged reliance on the cooperation of other organizations, implementing
this FDI Strategy will require upgrading the administrative capacities of the BOI and its
Regional Offices considerably. In particular, a state-of-the art management information
system
meet the
Figure 9
6.3.1. H
Impleme
different
officials.
investme
the first
whom th
promote
focus on
The BO
Private S
the Priva
PPD wi
Executiv
To som
expert b
Resourc
will have to
e challenge
9 illustrates
Human Res
enting this F
t type of t
While gov
ent promot
Pakistani
hey want to
ers from oth
n business
OI officials i
Sector. The
ate Sector
ill chiefly d
ve Committ
e extent, t
bodies, as e
ce Developm
o be install
es of the job
s BOI’s env
sources
FDI Strateg
talent and
vernment o
ters must p
contact pe
o attract to
her countri
results that
n charge o
ey will have
which cuts
depend on
tee secreta
he BOI wil
envisaged in
ment Plan
led, and hu
b.
isaged cap
gy not only
mindset th
officials typ
pro-actively
ersons of s
Pakistan.
es. To suc
t are expec
of the PPD
e to manag
s across ma
n the com
riat.
ll have to
n art. 9 (k)
is envisage
uman resou
acity devel
requires ad
han conve
pically react
market pr
senior exe
In this mis
cceed, they
ted in intern
will be the
ge an intera
any policy
mpetence, c
supplemen
of the BOI
ed.
urces will h
opment pro
dditional hu
ntionally re
t to actions
ojects worl
cutives of
ssion, they
y must disp
national bu
e liaisons b
active proce
domains. In
commitmen
nt its own s
Ordinance.
have to be
ogram:
uman resou
equired fro
s and reque
dwide. Th
internation
y compete w
play the qu
siness.
between th
ess betwee
ndeed, the
nt and dyn
staff with c
. A compreh
developed
rces; it nee
om governm
ests of citiz
ey are typi
nal corpora
with investm
ualifications
e GoP and
en the GoP
success o
namism of
consultants
hensive Hu
35
that
eds a
ment
zens,
ically
tions
ment
and
d the
P and
of the
f the
and
uman
36
6.3.2. Information Technology
As has been shown in the previous chapters, comprehensive, readily accessible and
current information must support virtually all activities under this Investment Strategy.
Much more is needed than collecting and collating data. A successful proactive
investment strategy will require a dynamic interactive IT system that:
? Provides comprehensive and up-to-date information on the status of investment
conditions and investment projects in Pakistan;
? Facilitates rapid and efficient communication amongst the members of the
Cooperative Network;
? Provides access to intelligence into industry trends, company strategies,
investment promotion activities of competitor countries, etc worldwide;
? Allows tracking progress of and follow-up on the various activities; and
? Enables the BOI to maintain relationships with targeted and current investors.
Such a system will have to include a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and a
Client Tracking System (CTS).
37
7. BOI as self Financing Organization
7.0. Need for Increased Funds
According to international experience, functioning investment promotion agencies yield
high economic returns – one percent increase in an IPA budget tends to translate into a
0.25 percent increase of FDI into the country concerned. Financing an IPA is hence a
sound investment in future economic growth. Pakistan’s fiscal constraints make it
nevertheless necessary to seek sources in addition to the budget for funding the
necessary Capacity Development of the BOI. It should also be taken into account that
investment mobilization activities alleviate poverty only indirectly and in the medium- to
long term and that FDI is still fraught with some political controversy. To ensure a broad
social support for the BOI and its mission, extra-budgetary financing will be sought to
the extent possible for the implementation of this initial Investment Strategy. Once the
contribution of investment mobilization activities to economic growth and poverty
alleviation in Pakistan become visible, it should become broadly acceptable to shift the
attendant costs predominantly to the budget.
On 18
th
May 2010, the BOI Board approved the creation of the BOI Fund envisaged in
the BOI Ordinance. This provides the basis for soliciting donor support of grants made
by the Federal Government, foreign aid or loans obtained or raised by the BOI with
special or general permission of Federal Government and others sums including fees
and changes receivable by the BOI on the approval of Visa, Branch/ Liaison Offices.
7.1. Self-financing
In pursuance of provision of section 9(u) of BOI ordinance 2001, BOI Board in its
meeting held on 29
th
J uly, 2011 approved the levy of service charges on Visa, Branch/
Liaison Offices. The receipts from above levy/service charges are being deposited in
BOI Fund.
7.2. Donor Support
Examples exist where IPAs during their start up – phase were supported by
international donors and/or IFI’s, notably the European Union and the World Bank. A
strong case can be made for obtaining similar support for the Pakistani investment
strategy. Potential donors should be contacted with a view to launching an investment
strategy support project.
doc_725754871.pdf